Here's the low approval scenes I could find:

Cassandra

http://www.youtube.c...bed/WAZOvgKcwk8

Solas

http://www.youtube.c...O6CqejueiY615Bg

Dorian

http://www.youtube.c...bed/6sqb30p-3Pk

I'm doing my evil playthrough and struggling to do the same thing. If you get Dorian's approval down low enough (he really hates it when you meet him in Redcliffe and then leave to recruit the Templars anyway), they'll be a scene where you can punch him in the face and tell him to leave. It's really intense and awesome. I punched Solas too but he's still with me but hates my guts.

Cassandra, Vivienne and Iron Bull love me. Sera surprisingly does too even though I've been doing EVERYTHING in my power to get rid of her (does she ever leave? haven't done her personal quest yet). I rejected Cole from joining up. Blackwall loathes me and will likely leave when I allow Celene to die. 

I didn't want to kill off my evil pro-templar Hawke so Varric is actually ok with me despite being a colossal douchebag. Does he really leave if Hawke dies? Is it possible to go through the game without a rogue? I wish all the low disapproval/'crisis' scenes where online because they are actually really well done from what i've seen.

Yes! I love Origins but too many warriors with the same gruff worldview. While Alistair/Leliana/Morrigan will always be my favourite party team for nostalgia's sake, I think all the Inquisition companions are much more fleshed out and varied, all have very strong and different opinions from one another. Vivienne is a bitchier, funnier Wynne, Dorian is Zevran with more depth, Varric and Iron Bull are less stereotypical than Oghren and Sten, Cole is a HUGE improvement over Justice's lameness, Leliana and Morrigan have matured. Yes Sera's annoying and her world view is not particularly intelligent but she's probably the most unique and best written character in the game, never thought I'd see a 'chav' elf. I really love the whole cast, even when they hate me or annoy me.

I was really hoping for a tough boss fight where you have to fight a possessed Connor, a possessed Amalia and a possessed Feynriel all at once.

Has ANYONE done a playthrough without Keiran appearing? Does Morrigan always have a kid? How does the whole scene with Flemeth play without him and the Old God soul?

Judging by the videos, Cassandra's, Cullen's, Dorian's and Solas' are AWESOME and have a lot of depth and emotion. Iron Bull's is funny but a little thin. Blackwall's I need to see more of. Josephine's is cute but kinda cheesy and juvenile in places. Sera's is the worst of what I've seen, she doesn't seem to care much for the Inquisitor at all and if they aren't qunari female, she constantly puts them down. But I'm planning to do all of them at some point (trying to go for the most dialogue options with these race/class combinations):

male human warrior with Cassandra

female human mage with Cullen

male elf mage with Dorian

female elf archer with Solas

male dwarf rogue with Josephine

female dwarf warrior with Blackwall

male qunari mage with Iron Bull

female qunari rogue with Sera

"Harder choices"? I just had to choose between sacrificing Hawke and Alistair. That choice was pretty damn heartbreaking.

 

But yes, I approve of #1 and #3, though I personally don't need anything more with my Warden. That chapter is finished.

I meant harder, more morally grey choices especially in terms of villains, Archdemon/Meredith/Corypheus are very black and white antagonists. I just wouldn't mind a break from a 'magical apocalyptic big bad who needs to be put down' and explore more 'human evil'

I want:

a 'Finding Solas' DLC that wraps up the elven gods plot and resolves Solas/Flemeth/Morrigan once and for all

a 'Warden's Calling' DLC from the Warden's perspective that wraps up their storyline and all the DAO-DAA-DA2 plot threads (including Sandal and who he really is)

a Citadel-style fun DLC to finish off the Inquisitor's story

then DA4: Tevinter which starts fresh with all new characters and more focused on Qunari/Tevinter issues with more grounded villians and harder choices 

I think Sandal is an old god (maybe June or Dirthamen?) who created 'the Stone' which created the dwarven race. Or he was the first dwarf ever created. I really hope theres a DLC that brings him back and explains him once and for all. 

Has anyone encountered him yet? It's weird that they set him up in DA2 to be working in Orlais and then they just drop him entirely from the game. I was looking forward to getting explanation of who or what he really is.

Yeah, Sera's one of my least favourite romances so far from the videos, she's cute but its not that interesting a storyline.

Just from the videos i'd rank the romances (i prefer the more 'emotional' ones):

1. Solas (yeah he always breaks up with you in the end but its still a cool storyline)

2. Cassandra

3. Cullen

4. Dorian (hot)

5. Iron Bull (funny)

6. Blackwall (still want confirmation that he comes back after sleeping with you)

7. Sera

8. Josephine

ugh its been said repeatedly on here that Sten makes a cameo (and only refuses to help if you are a Qunari mage or bring Iron Bull with you), was that just a rumour?

The only thing I've heard

I read somewhere

ok so the main story decisions seem to be:

any others? do we know specifically what decisions make the companions leave or stay or die? so far i've read/seen:

What about the others? I don't want to accidentally ****** someone off forever. I thought the whole game would leak by now, also want to know about Sandal

The bit that killed it for me was the big epic scene after you save Haven where you walk through a crowd of hundreds of NPCs cheering you is GONE in the 360 version. You literally walk out to the big music and there's one guard. 

After i saw that I gave up and am now researching where to buy an Xbox one for cheap. 

Exactly I smell a 'Finding Solas' DLC ala Witch Hunt. 

This is really more of a main story spoiler but here you go:

 

Spoiler

If you choose to recruit the mages over the templars, there's time travel craziness that sends the Inquisitor and Dorian (mandatory party member for this) a year into the future. Leliana will have been tortured for a good part of that time. As will the two party members besides Dorian and the leader of the mages. Near the end of the quest, Dorian and the Inquisitor go back to when they came from and everything that happened during the year they were gone is undone. Leliana won't even remember it happening.

So

YES! LOVE this idea. Can't wait to dismantle the whole Chantry and tweak it how I see fit. I don't see the problem with these choices or why people are so passionately against it. At least they are characters we get to know in depth throughout the whole game before we make a decision. I think people take the Maker/Andraste/Chantry/Jesus/Christianity allegory waaaaaaay too seriously and rigidly. Would love to live in a world where a black witch was the Pope. 

Male, qunari, mage, necromancer, Iron Bull. 

Well different strokes for different folks cause from the streams the American male voice is absolutely PERFECT for my sarcastic qunari and will be the one I use for my first play through.

Honestly that would make him more interesting to me. Just from watching the streams he's my least favourite companion on first impressions and a backstory like that would make me more willing to spend time exploring his character imo. 

Is Low a good indication of what the Xbox 360 will look like? or will it be worse?

I think they both look good. Different but good. I was worried for another DA2 redesign disaster. 

FPJ is totally romancing himself, isn't he?

Totally. Not going to lie I was hoping he'd make an blonde female warrior Inquisitor named Buffy.