112 réponses à ce sujet

[Mariquis]

Oh man. Tough choice.



1. Psychonauts

2. Mass Effect 2

3. Grim Fandango

4. Mass Effect

5. Portal

6. Mirror's Edge

7. Dragon Age: Origins

8. Silent Hill 2

9. Starcraft

10. Oblivion

[Gyroscopic_Trout]

In order:



1) Dragon Age

2) BG2

3) ME2

4) Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time

5) ME1

6) RE2 (RE4 is fer sissyfolk who can't conserve their ammo)

7) Tetris

8) Beyond Good & Evil

9) Batman Arkham Asylum

10) NWN1

[thedoncarnage]

Hrmm... since we're all making lists... in order:



1) Fallout 3

2) Rainbow Six series

3) Halo series

4) A certain MUD, for those who know what one is.

5) Mass Effect series

6) Starcraft

7) Jedi Knight series

8) Tribes

9) Age of Empires 2

10) Gran Turismo series



Also... I have a beta copy of Starcraft 2... gotta say, I'm not very impressed so far. Just my humble opinion. Dissappointing since Starcraft is my favorite RTS.

[Skalman91]

Mariquis wrote...

Oh man. Tough choice.

1. Psychonauts

I did play psychonauts and although I can admit to that it is highly underrated, It's hardly the best game made by man?

Although these things are just opinions so...

Now I just need someone with Halo 3 at the top of their list so I have a valid reason for criticizing their no. 1

[Bugsie]

Karstedt wrote...

Buggirl70 wrote...

Ah I hope that wasn't directed at me because I was NOT disrespecting anybody's opinion and certainly not their choice in games (many reflect my own likes) - I was merely stating the game I mose dislike compared to the list I do, see my previous post before Karstedt. Perhaps I should have just started another thread.

That comment was a retort to the ridiculous accusation (by the quoted poster) that my previous post was a disrespectful shot at the opinions of other people.

Yes definitely a ridiculous accusation - thats why I was so annoyed - I liked your retort  !

Can't say I was lucky enough to have a C64, although I wanted one, ppphht lame non tech parents didnt think a girl would like computers....
Totally forgot about Day of the Tentacle and Sam and Max - they were great fun too.

Modifié par Buggirl70, 28 mars 2010 - 03:40 .

[uberdowzen]

Day of the Tentacle was hilarios but the puzzles were just stupid.



***SPOILER***painting a kumquat tree red to be a cherry tree, how obtuse***SPOILER***

[Throw_this_away]

Just picked up Assassins Creed 2 new for 30$



I loved AC1 (though I had to play it in small chunks as non-assassination missions got boring), and so far this game is great. May very well end up in my top 10 list. Red Dead and Fallout: New Vagas will be must haves for me when they come out. Still, the thought of ME3 is what I look forward to most... too bad it could be up to two years away.

[Bugsie]

uberdowzen wrote...

Day of the Tentacle was hilarios but the puzzles were just stupid.

***SPOILER***painting a kumquat tree red to be a cherry tree, how obtuse***SPOILER***

HAAAAAA yes I remember the puzzles were pretty daft,

***SPOILER*** getting in disguise by wearing spaghetti on your head as a wig ***SPOILER***

but the dialogue was very endearing.

[SomeKindaEnigma]

No order: ME, ME 2, Crysis, Half Life 2, Doom 3, Splinter Cell Series, Left 4 Dead series, Batman Arkham Asylum, uhhhhh I'm sure theres plenty of others

[JaylaClark]

Okay, my favorite games in order...?

• Mass Effect
• Knights of the Old Republic
• Perfect Dark (N64 original)
• Sims 2 and 3 (Same point, different methods)
• Mass Effect 2
• Guitar Hero 2 and 3
• GoldenEye
• KotOR 2

[colonelklenck]

1) Mass Effect 2

2) Fallout 3

3) Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess

4) Mass Effect

5) Mario Galaxy

6) Knights of the Old Republic

7) Dragon Age: Origins

8) Metroid Prime: Corruption

9) Super Smash Brothers

10) Resident Evil 4

[SirEmilCrane]

1) ME series (can't decide which is better)
2) Company of Heroes: Opposing Fronts
3) Company of Heroes
4) Gears of War 1,2 (same as ME)
5) Call of Duty MW2
6) Dawn of War series
7) Morrowind
8) KOTOR1
9) Oblivion
10) Fallout 3

Modifié par SirEmilCrane, 28 mars 2010 - 05:50 .

[Kalfear]

My list easy!

1) Mass Effect 1
2) Dragon Age Origins
3) Knights of the Old Republic 2
4) Knights of the Old Republic 1
5) Jade Empire
6-11) SSI AD&DGold Box games
12) Might and Magic 1
13) Gabriel Knight: The Beast Within
14) Phantasmagoria
15) Mass Effect 2

I originally ranked ME2 at 6 but then found out its got ZERO replay value so its score dropped to #15.
To linear, to shooterish, not enough FINISHED RPG elements to rate any higher.
Great graphics but graphics not everything.

Modifié par Kalfear, 28 mars 2010 - 06:45 .

[Frieza1987]

Kalfear wrote...
3) Knights of the Old Republic 2

Someone who doesn't hate KotOR 2? How is that possible?

I really never understood all of the hate directed at the game, I wouldn't go so far as to rank it above the first one, but I thought it was still a very good game, up until the very end.

Anyway my list would be:

1) KotOR 1/2
2) ME 1/2
3) Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
4) Morrowind/Oblivion
5) Age of Empires 2

Modifié par Frieza1987, 28 mars 2010 - 06:59 .

[Keltoris]

Atm:

ME2

HL2+Eps

Portal

DoW2

SupCom2

Audiosurf.





All time? Dunno, would have to take a break from all contenders to make it fair. KotOR's pretty high up though.

[Kurt M.]

Karstedt wrote...

Gladiador2 wrote...

Karstedt wrote...

I think these lists are very telling about who ME2 mostly appeals to.
Although a few of you are just plain weird and I think your lists should
be omitted from official record.

And I think you should learn to respect the opinion of the others, or otherwise get you ass kicked out. With a military boot on fire.

Because my statement was clearly identifying individuals and calling their opinions idiotic? You sir, are an idiot. Though I respect your opinion.

Oh, yes, I'm an idiot. So idiot that I clicked on "Report this post" instead of quoting it. Whoops!

[Karstedt]

Censorship is a tool of the weak minded... and the wrong.

[cepapoe]

My Top Ten or so games:
1. Dragon Age: According to steam I have played 486 hours of this game since it came out. Do I need to say more?
2. Mass Effect 2: The orginal plus better controls and gameplay, only miss was mineral mining, which thank god for save game editor.
3. Mass Effect: Still remember my first time playing this and it was awsome, but now I can't bring myself to play through it again, with the gunplay and cookie cutter side levels. That and if I hear "I will destroy you!" one more time I might kill someone for real.
4. Neverwinter Nights 1/2: Can't really rate one over the other. Mod community was stronger/ where more mores in 1 than 2, though 2 has some good mods as well. For OC's I prefer NWN 2 cause I could actually replay it. I could not bring myself to replay NWN 1 OC with all its fetching missions. Mask of the Betrayer still ranks as one of my favorite expansions, but Storm of Zehir has to be the weakest.
5. Knights of the Old Rebublic Series: Great, I prefer 2 a bit more in its finished state (yay mods ), but still have to give kudos to the orginal for biggest plot twist of all time.
6. Heroes of Might and Magic II: was one of the first games I played as a kid, and still find time to play it.
7. Portal: Great humor, awsome gameplay. A bit short and lacking cake but otherwise good.
8. Half Life series: Awsome story, wish they would make Episode 3 already.
9. Team Fortress 2: seem to havea  a bit of a valave streak here. This game introduced me to online gaming, and I love to team work and humorous characters.
10. Fallout 3: Awsome atmosphere and fun experience. Medocre story but great dlc.

Honorable mentions: Doom 1 and 2, Oblivion, Call of Duty, Civilization series, and Total War

[Kalfear]

Frieza1987 wrote...

Kalfear wrote...
3) Knights of the Old Republic 2

Someone who doesn't hate KotOR 2? How is that possible?

I really never understood all of the hate directed at the game, I wouldn't go so far as to rank it above the first one, but I thought it was still a very good game, up until the very end.

Anyway my list would be:

1) KotOR 1/2
2) ME 1/2
3) Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
4) Morrowind/Oblivion
5) Age of Empires 2

KotOR2 was a great game and really expanded on K1. I do wish LA would have let Obsidian finish it completely of course but what was there was fantastic and told a great story. And the characters were fantastic as was the influence system.

My one complaint with K2 is the feminist fans that demanded a female lead hero for Star Wars. K2 wasnt the story for that, I played both male and female and the male story with Handmaiden to me will always be cannon regardless what 10,000 nerds on wiki say.
Till Lucas himself comments (which he hasnt) nothing in stone far as K2 goes.

I rank K2 higher cause I like ADULT content and K2 was much darker and more Adult feel to it then K1s disney feel. Plus im not a Bastilla fan, Visra and Handmaiden were the perfect love interests and played off each other so well. heh, I remember nerding out when the cut screen of the two argueing over me happened! I loved it (as I loved it in DA:O as well) and it added so much atmosphere to game!

Modifié par Kalfear, 28 mars 2010 - 08:34 .

[DarthCaine]

^ You love KOTOR2 and you hate ME2

You're the exact opposite of me

[Sarcastic]

Mass Effect Series - Original story in a sci-fi themed setting = Win

Dawn of War Series - Sci-Fi setting 38k years in the future with horrificly dark undertones.

Dragon Age Series - Dark, awesome game engine.

Total War Series - Original turn-based strategy with realtime combat (If this list was based on time played this series would be first by a 200%+ margin)

Age of Empires, all of them - Considering the lacking story I fully enjoyed playing these, over and over.

Lord of the Realms 2 - For a old and by todays standards crappy game I played this title non stop for a year.

Starcraft - Awesome gameplay, crappy story.

C&C RA2 - Killer story, even better gameplay. Low on my list due to multiplayer issues that were never balanced.

[SithLordExarKun]

1) Mass Effect 1 & 2
2) Dragon Age Origins
3) Heavy Rain
4) Battlefield Bad Company 2
5) Fallout 3
6) Final Fantasy 12
7) Call of Duty 4
8) GTA 4

Modifié par SithLordExarKun, 28 mars 2010 - 09:04 .

[Jean de Valette]

Based on single player experience, replay value, and how I view the game now after all these years:

1. Baldur's Gate 2
2. Baldur's Gate 1
3. Half Life 1 (+ expansions)
4. Knights of the Old Republic
5. Medieval: Total War 2
6. Jedi Knight 2
7. Fallout 2
8. Diablo 2
9. Jaggged Alliance 2
10. Civilization 2

Above is a rough estimate, left out some other wonderful titles. BG series I consider the best games I ever played which was great at nearly everything. And I'm still thinking about replaying it.

Modifié par Jean de Valette, 28 mars 2010 - 10:15 .

[Aradace]

Let's see, in lieu of OP's top 10 list, mine would look like this:

1.) Assassin's Creed II (That's right, ME ISNT at the top of my list lol)
2.) Final Fantasy XII
3.) Mass Effect 2
4.) Mass Effect 1
5.) Elderscrolls IV: Oblivion
6.) Elderscrolls III: Morrowind
7.) Final Fantasy VI (Final Fantasy III as it is known to most)
8.) Resident Evil 5
9.) Resident Evil 4
10.) Silent Hill Series (Because they're all good lol)

That's basically it in a nutshell. Then again, Ive always like survival horror and RPGs

Modifié par Aradace, 28 mars 2010 - 10:28 .

[DMC12]

My top 10:

1) X-Wing
2) Golden Eye 007
3) NHL '94 (Best hockey game EVER)
4) Rainbow Six
5) Space Harrier
6) Scramble (for Vectrex)
7) Quake
8) Grand Theft Auto III
9) Metal Gear Solid
10) Halo: CE

For me, Mass Effect and Mass Effect 2 would probably be further down the line. The difference between ME and these games, is that they represent a significant milestone in my gaming experience.

Modifié par DMC12, 28 mars 2010 - 10:37 .