Sarah1281 wrote...
Discrimination doesn't HAVE to make sense and often doesn't. There are cases where one black parent and one white one, for instance, produce a child that appears to be white. They, like the elf-blooded humans, wouldn't face discrimination from random passerbys who don't know their story but if people did, say,see them with their non white/human parent and see the relation then they would face that same discrimination. I don't see that being out of touch with reality.
True but in the Black/White scenario producing a white child is extremely rare, most of the time they end up looking black, which actually served to reinforce the the racial segragation. In sense interracial breeding was (
and still is for some people) perceived as a very real threat to their community, in a manner that simply doesn't apply to the humans in DAO.
Hee doesn't decide that the elven race as a whole is useless and should be sold for some extra cash. He sees the conditions of the alienage after Vaughn and then Howe were through with it - which are pretty deplorable, you have to admit - and decides that it cannot be saved. There is no hope for the Alienage, the elves will just continue to get sick and die in poverty, and he needs money. Yes, it was a horrid solution to turn to slavery but he didn't write off the entire race, just those at the Alienage. They're not allowed to fight or carry weapons anyway so I doubt they reminded him of his elven soldiers.
No offense but if you actually believe that half-baked excuse Loghain gives in the landsmeet, after all he is in part responsible for those conditions, I have lovely Synagogue with an open bar to sell you in Saudi Arabia.
Further more the alienage is a walled of section of the city with in a walled off city, it easily has to be one of the most easily defensable spots in Denerim. Loghain had more or less an entire year to prepare, that's a lot of time to raise some half-decent militia (elves or not) especially if your troops are running around in the rest of the country press-ganging any one they come across.
You dont' think the other NPCs are actually racist? Maybe not every single NPC you meet feels the need to comment on your species but that would get a little repetitive and they have enough to make it clear just where you stand.
Let me put it this way I didn't really feel the hate. You had Vaughn and Ceorlic in the landsmeet (
who uses your heritage against you) but the rest of the time "racism" amounted to a few "lol knife earz" comments.
The Ash Warrior leader hates you,
Not really he just isn't impressed with you, but after the thin-boned comment he is actually fairly "nice" for lack of a better word.
the Quartermaster at Ostagar expects you to fetch him his armor,
He back tracks and grovels pretty quickly when you call him out on it, a "proper" racist really wouldn't give a rat's @ss about you being a warden recruit or not.
Lloyd and Murdock in Redcliffe both have issues with you being an elf, the guy who the elves are mugging in the Alienage assumes you must be there to mug him too when you try to talk to him, the little orphaned boy in Lothering...it's there.
IIRC Lloyd asks you if you're a run away from the alienage which given the general circumstances of elves is actually a reasonnable question, and if you point out you're dalish he doesn't even seem to mind, despite the fact dalish are murderous boogey-men bandits as far as humans are concerned.
Forgot about Murdock, he's was pretty good, sexist too so that was refreshing.
The alienage guy's reaction was farily reasonnable. If you were in a bad part of town and assaulted by a group of black people trying to mug you then all of sudden another black person shows up decked out in bling and with enough firepower to take down a police station, wouldn't you panic and GTFO?
Lothering boy really doesn't count, first off he's not really old enough to understand the concept of discrimination, and secondly if you help him out he points out his father said elves weren't very nice but you get the definite impression he thinks elves are pretty neet afterwords.
The Dalish and elf mages don't have to deal with that
Actually they should have to deal with more of it than normal city elves, since they'd be percieved as actual threat as opposed to city elves who would be seen as rather tame and domesticated.
but I think the city elve also get a taste of what it's like but that origin is only, say, half an hour long. After that you're not a helpless dowtrodden second-class citizen anymore. You're a Grey Warden, you can kill anyone who gives you ****,
No offense but the entire point of the game is that you can't simply run around and kill off any one you want just 'cause you're a Grey Warden, otherwise the Bhelen/Harrowmont situation would have been a lot easier to solve and Loghain wouldn't be in command of the relief forces at Ostagar. If you listen to Duncan being a Grey Warden actually contrains you a good deal, especially since Wardens are not solidly established in Ferelden.
and you're the only hope to save them from the Blight. At that point you really aren't getting the typical elven experience any more than the human or dwarf wardens get a typical experience for their species.
No offense but you only become the "only hope against the blight" after you manage to build an army on your own and put Loghain in his place during the landsmeet. Otherwise you're a criminal with a rather large bounty on your head or Loghain's scapegoat of choice depending on who you're taking too not exactly a position of power or respect.
Modifié par Drasanil, 29 mai 2010 - 08:28 .