72 réponses à ce sujet

[H8Cr1me]

Anybody care to predict a final Metacritic score? I am going to guess a 92, with a user score of 9.6

I have a feeling that graphics will be an issue for some reviewing parties.

[Arandomindividual]

I think it might receive a solid 85 or there abouts.

[Kilsot]

Why and how would the graphics be an issue?

[Napoleon1853]

I hope it is in the 90s.

[SwankyMcSwish]

I'm going to say 93.

[Aleksandrov]

Around mid-80s I presume. It's really hard to get over 90s nowadays because there will always be those sites that give them low 80s which bring down the score.

The graphics aren't bad, but in the other thread on things that irk people the blood splatter might get annoying after a while. Might be graphic requirements are tad on the high side, though I hope the scaling should be good.

[SwankyMcSwish]

I'm pretty sure that the blood can be toggled as a setting. I remember reading that in an interview, but I'm not sure which one.

[cyanrabbit]

Well, considering a pile of .... as oblivion reached 94, I do hope it will at least be as high as that.

but come on, more recently Fallout 3 got a 91, so I would even say 112 would be fair in this case.....



Anyway, so that to answer your question 95. I hope a well deserved 9.5.

[Sexy.KOT69]

my guess will be around 85-94.. not sure. some reviews were really surprising this year

[M_arc]

I believe the critics will give it somehwere between the 90 and 100, with a 89 at least.

[Twitchmonkey]

A 93 is more or less the reasonable Metacritic roof. If you check their best of 08 list (09 is, of course, still a WIP) only 2 games received better than a 93 (LittleBigPlanet got a 95 and GTAIV got a 98). I have high hopes for DA:O, it might manage something like a 91-92, which would still put it among the best games of the year and likely in the top 3 PC games.

[aebriol]

91 is my prediction.

[Holy Mortar]

cyanrabbit wrote...

Well, considering a pile of .... as oblivion reached 94, I do hope it will at least be as high as that.
but come on, more recently Fallout 3 got a 91, so I would even say 112 would be fair in this case.....

Anyway, so that to answer your question 95. I hope a well deserved 9.5.

Yep, exactly what I was going to say. With all this bs with Oblivion getting so high scores...

As for F3 - as a hardcore F1 and F2 fan, I was really dissapointed in F3.

Oh, nevermind my rants...

[SwankyMcSwish]

All of the reviews so far have been a 9 and above haven't they?



Hopefully that trend continues and the game lives up to that when we get our hands onto it.

[Twitchmonkey]

Yep, exactly what I was going to say. With all this bs with Oblivion getting so high scores...

As for F3 - as a hardcore F1 and F2 fan, I was really dissapointed in F3.

Oh, nevermind my rants...

Compared to Morrowind, Oblivion might not have been as good (though that's debatable) but it is a very nice looking game with a lot of polish and content, so I think a 94 is pretty fair. That doesn't mean that DA:O will do any worse though, KotOR also got a 94, so while that kind of score is a huge task to manage, they've done it before.

[elijah_kaine]

I don't know that site very well but my guess is low 90'd or high 80's.



I find that RPG's tend to be judged more harshly then other styles of games.



Fallout 3 got a good score because it's got a lot of first person shooter elements. At least, IMHO.

[elijah_kaine]

Holy Mortar wrote...

cyanrabbit wrote...

Well, considering a pile of .... as oblivion reached 94, I do hope it will at least be as high as that.
but come on, more recently Fallout 3 got a 91, so I would even say 112 would be fair in this case.....

Anyway, so that to answer your question 95. I hope a well deserved 9.5.

Yep, exactly what I was going to say. With all this bs with Oblivion getting so high scores...

As for F3 - as a hardcore F1 and F2 fan, I was really dissapointed in F3.

Oh, nevermind my rants...

I'm a younger guy and I tired to go back and play F1 and F2 when I had a gametap account and I'm sad to say that I had trouble doing it. However, I was disappointed in F3 because it just wasn't that dramatic, or didn't have that much of a powerful story, at least in my opinion. It was fun at first to run around, shoot things and etc, but to me it just never really felt like I had enough of an impact. Maybe I just didn't get far enough, but meh.

[GhoXen]

95-100 for my prediction. Just recently MGS4 got a score of 10 on gamespot.

[Holy Mortar]

elijah_kaine wrote...

Holy Mortar wrote...

cyanrabbit wrote...

Well, considering a pile of .... as oblivion reached 94, I do hope it will at least be as high as that.
but come on, more recently Fallout 3 got a 91, so I would even say 112 would be fair in this case.....

Anyway, so that to answer your question 95. I hope a well deserved 9.5.

Yep, exactly what I was going to say. With all this bs with Oblivion getting so high scores...

As for F3 - as a hardcore F1 and F2 fan, I was really dissapointed in F3.

Oh, nevermind my rants...

I'm a younger guy and I tired to go back and play F1 and F2 when I had a gametap account and I'm sad to say that I had trouble doing it. However, I was disappointed in F3 because it just wasn't that dramatic, or didn't have that much of a powerful story, at least in my opinion. It was fun at first to run around, shoot things and etc, but to me it just never really felt like I had enough of an impact. Maybe I just didn't get far enough, but meh.

Where the trouble was?

[Twitchmonkey]

GhoXen wrote...

95-100 for my prediction. Just recently MGS4 got a score of 10 on gamespot.

You do realize that a score of 100 would require every included review to have given the game a 100? That's already an impossiblity, as far as I know no reviewer has yet to give DA:O a 100 (though that doesn't mean there won't be one that will).

There was also a bit of controversy over that MGS4 review, but that's a story for another day.

[Gilgonwin]

Im thinking a solid 92 with a user score of 9.4

[elijah_kaine]

Holy Mortar wrote...

elijah_kaine wrote...

Holy Mortar wrote...

cyanrabbit wrote...

Well, considering a pile of .... as oblivion reached 94, I do hope it will at least be as high as that.
but come on, more recently Fallout 3 got a 91, so I would even say 112 would be fair in this case.....

Anyway, so that to answer your question 95. I hope a well deserved 9.5.

Yep, exactly what I was going to say. With all this bs with Oblivion getting so high scores...

As for F3 - as a hardcore F1 and F2 fan, I was really dissapointed in F3.

Oh, nevermind my rants...

I'm a younger guy and I tired to go back and play F1 and F2 when I had a gametap account and I'm sad to say that I had trouble doing it. However, I was disappointed in F3 because it just wasn't that dramatic, or didn't have that much of a powerful story, at least in my opinion. It was fun at first to run around, shoot things and etc, but to me it just never really felt like I had enough of an impact. Maybe I just didn't get far enough, but meh.

Where the trouble was?

Um, I think this is, where was the trouble.

I'd hate to say it but the controls and the graphics were just too outdated for me. 

I did go back and play through planescape torment which I absolutely loved and I've gone back and played baulders gate 2, but something about fallout 1 and 2 just rubbed me the wrong way. Something about the interface or graphics. 

[Jonp382]

None of this matters because Out of the Park Baseball 2007 is still the greatest game of all time.

[H8Cr1me]

For those of you bashing on Oblivion:
I have never played an unmodded Oblivion but I have seen it and agree that it doesn't look all that great and knowing what the mods I have installed, changed, I know what aspects of gameplay kinda sucked. However, a fully modded Oblivion is something truly majestic. Of course there was a lot of missed potential, but the game is truly epic. It is second, in my book, to the infinity engine games. I haven't played KotOR yet so I can't factor that in.

Modifié par H8Cr1me, 19 octobre 2009 - 11:39 .