GuardianAngel470 wrote...
fortunesque wrote...
Besides, I guarantee that if you returned to the Liara thread and said, "hey, let's start over. Things got a bit heated last time I was here," that they'd be cool with it and welcome you in. The ones you were arguing with would probably own up to their anger as well. It again boils down to the fact that some fans are chill about things and others get very defensive about their characters.
And that is exactly what I am saying, that you can't judge someone based on their reputations. I agree that I should have said threats were exchanged but this thread wasn't supposed to be about the Liara thread so I didn't see the need. You and several others have ignored my main point in favor of focussing on details. You ignore that I said not to judge either fanbase. Stop trying to portray me as the bad guy, I have said nothing negative about the Liara thread. Read the OP again.
I did. Again, even though you said that, your subsequent post negates that:
GuardianAngel470 wrote...
I asked why they liked their
character. I gave my opinion and how I saw the character and I stated
it as an opinion.
Before I said anything though I said very, very
clearly that I wasn't trolling, wasn't trying to offend anyone, and
wasn't trying to say I was right and they were wrong. All my posts were
respectful. This is what I did in the Liara thread and i literally got
threatened. One of them threatened to belt me. It devolved in 4 pages,
which is how many I gave the Tali thread.
There is an omission here. Again, it's simpler to say, "I talked to the Tali thread and they're reasonable folks". If this thread isn't about the Liara thread, then why mention it then pull the argument you had with them (about personal lives-not even Liara) into the OP then say it's for "context"? There's no context here. The way the OP and subsequent post come off isn't flattering, and I'm sure that wasn't your intent.