1651 réponses à ce sujet

[Kalithera]

Frieza1987 wrote...

The Grey Spectre wrote...

Kalithera wrote...
Yes please! This or KotOR, either would be epic!

I say star wars in general, kotor and the movies for more characters.

I think KotOR and the movies together would have too many characters to choose from, there would be a lot of good characters that would have to be left out. I say either the original trilogy or KotOR, not both.

Yeah... Much as I want there to be a combination of them, there would be too many great characters left out, and I'd really like Aayla Secura to be in it. (Not that anyone really knows who she is anyway. ._.)

[Kalithera]

Argh, double post! 
Well then...
...
...if we're doing Harry Potter, Neville has to be in it.

Modifié par Kalithera, 03 mai 2010 - 01:54 .

[The Grey Spectre]

Kalithera wrote...

Frieza1987 wrote...

The Grey Spectre wrote...

Kalithera wrote...
Yes please! This or KotOR, either would be epic!

I say star wars in general, kotor and the movies for more characters.

I think KotOR and the movies together would have too many characters to choose from, there would be a lot of good characters that would have to be left out. I say either the original trilogy or KotOR, not both.

Yeah... Much as I want there to be a combination of them, there would be too many great characters left out, and I'd really like Aayla Secura to be in it. (Not that anyone really knows who she is anyway. ._.)

Well they could be split into rounds, say a certain amount of randomly chosen characters in the first round, then the winner of that round will wait until the final round, and repeat until the winners of each round battle in the final round, just a suggestion, you guys do what you want.

[Frieza1987]

Capt. Obvious wrote...
You guys don't know how much I've wanted to include a Star Wars HoH after the first HoH(that was the Dragon Age HoH, the one that I started) was finished. MerinTB and a couple other members saw a problem with that. So did I as a matter of fact. Just look:

G Canon

T Canon

C Canon

If you're a Star Wars fan like me, you'd probably know how crammed a Star Wars in general HoH would be which is pretty much what scares me. I don't think I'll do one that includes all levels of canon. I think I'll only do one pertaining to the movies(which is G Canon, for the record). I want to do a WHOLE Star Wars Hurt or Heal featuring both levels of canon someday but I have a feeling that that day will not be so soon. That's why on the last poll, the only Star Wars HoH was Star Wars(Original Trilogy) and Star Wars KOTOR. That doesn't mean that as time passes by, I'll experiment with how many characters we can have on an HoH Elimination Game, but it just won't be happen...yet.

Until then, the poll will feature both KOTOR and the Original Trilogy like the last one.

. . . how in the world could you choose 30 characters from the entire Star Wars universe? It doesn't seem like that would be possible. You'd have to exclude dozens of even the really important characters like Corran Horn and Winter - and that's just from the later stuff, what about Exar Kun and Ulic Qel-Droma and everyone else from the Sith Era? You'd have to make dozens of contests just to choose who gets into the final competition!




But if you ever do make one, Borsk Fey'lya would win, hands down.

Modifié par Frieza1987, 03 mai 2010 - 02:23 .

[Kalithera]

Frieza1987 wrote...

But if you ever do make one, Borsk Fey'lya would win, hands down.

No way, Aayla Secura would. 

[Kalithera]

Capt. Obvious wrote...

Until then, the poll will feature both KOTOR and the Original Trilogy like the last one.

Alright, so when will the poll be up? Later tonight, tomorrow morning, Tuesday?

[Pacifien]

Could try a Dragon Age:Origins Awakening Hurt or Heal. I'd probably put my vote behind a KOTOR1&2 Hurt or Heal. Or find a list of, like, the thirty best video games of all time to Hurt or Heal. No scratch that, I'd just get irate when I notice Zork has not been included. Thirty Different Varieties of Pigeons Hurt or Heal. Yeah.

[MerinTB]

My vote would not be for "across video games" as I know the games I like would get the short end of the stick (i.e. not be included) in favor of games I've never played and have no intention of ever playing.



Like Metal Gear Solid. Like Zelda. Like Metroid. Hell, like <insert obligatory console game best seller here.>



But I'm just one vote. Majority will rule.

[MerinTB]

My STRONGEST suggestion for topic is that we keep it to something that is "common" to the forum.



Bioware Games are common to the forum.

Forum members are common to the forum.



You stray outside of those topics, you'll get a few people and lose a bunch.

[SarEnyaDor]

No one besides me would be up for best text based adventure, I'm sure.



We could always HoH BioWare games in general from Shattered Steel on up through Awakenings (methinks Sonic would die quickly) ...

[Eleima]

Why don't we just do a "Dragon Age" Hurt or Heal? It would make sense, since we just did a ME2 hurt or heal, and DA is the other BioWare game recently released. I'm not much of a fan of the member hurt or heal, mostly because most of us don't really know who's who. As for the allstar game characters, well, we all have different opinions, and there are just so many. Just my two cents. =)

[DarthCaine]

'cos there already was a DAO hurt or heal

[MerinTB]

Luc0s wrote...

MerinTB wrote...
My vote would not be for "across video games" as I know the games I like would get the short end of the stick (i.e. not be included) in favor of games I've never played and have no intention of ever playing.

Like Metal Gear Solid. Like Zelda. Like Metroid. Hell, like

But I'm just one vote. Majority will rule.

That's no good reason in my opinion for not doing a allstar videogame character HoH. That would be the same as saying:

"We shouldn't do a ME2 HoH because my favorite character is The Biotic God and he will get the short end of the stick (i.e. not be included) in favor of character I've never liked and have no intention of ever liking".

See how stupid that sounds?

Yes, I do see how stupid that sounds.  Because it's a bad comparision.

Which characters from a Bioware game that most of the members of the Bioware forums have played IS NOT the same thing as characters from games that most members of the Bioware forums haven't played.

Odds are, Luc0s, that a good number of the computer forum visiting members of the BSN are cRPG fans - and by that I do mean Computer RPG, not video game RPG.

The characters you listed are from  console games, console games that are not RPGs.  Metal Gear, Metroid, etc.
Zelda is on the fence, but I'd argue that it's action RPG at best, and that's not where I'd place it personally.  Cloud is from a JRPG, and while I personally like many JRPGs, there's a good portion of the forums who despise them.

So, again, I see how stupid your comparision is.  Saying your favorite character for a game that most everyone on these forums (who participated in the HoH especially) have played didn't make it into the HoH is NOT the same thing as saying that the majority of popular non-RPG console games are likely to have not been played by all the forum members.

---

on that point, I'd actually be one to get excited over text-based adventures.  Infocom ho!  How many Infocom games have you played, Luc0s?

---

And like I've said more than once, if Capt. Obvious puts up the poll and the majority of the votes go for "most popular video game characters like: Mario, Sonic, Crash, Samus, Master Chief, etc." then that's the one that is chosen and I'll most likely not play.  I won't complain - the voting will have spoken - but it's not for me.

[cynicalsaint1]

Wow forgot to check for a couple days and look what happens. Oh well all my favorites did well - was rooting for Garrus, Mordin, and Kal'Reegar. I'm surprised Reegar held on as long as he did.



I don't really care too much about what the next one will be, I would have voted for Baldur's Gate but since that's not an option I'm just going to abstain from voting. I might play though.

[MerinTB]

cynicalsaint1 wrote...

I don't really care too much about what the next one will be, I would have voted for Baldur's Gate but since that's not an option I'm just going to abstain from voting. I might play though.

There hasn't been a vote yet.  I think Capt. Obvious will put up a new poll with all the suggestions.

BG has been suggested twice, it'll probably be an option.

[Kalithera]

MerinTB wrote...
Odds are, Luc0s, that a good number of the computer forum visiting members of the BSN are cRPG fans - and by that I do mean Computer RPG, not video game RPG.

The characters you listed are from  console games, console games that are not RPGs.  Metal Gear, Metroid, etc.
Zelda is on the fence, but I'd argue that it's action RPG at best, and that's not where I'd place it personally.  Cloud is from a JRPG, and while I personally like many JRPGs, there's a good portion of the forums who despise them.

Exactly this. 

MerinTB wrote...
And like I've said more than once, if Capt. Obvious puts up the poll and the majority of the votes go for "most popular video game characters like: Mario, Sonic, Crash, Samus, Master Chief, etc." then that's the one that is chosen and I'll most likely not play.  I won't complain - the voting will have spoken - but it's not for me.

Also this. Unfortunately, I don't know who any of the above characters are, so that would completely prevent me from understanding it.

[SarEnyaDor]

LOL, when *I* started gaming the big system wars were Intellivision vs the Atari. Anyone else remember leaving trails of dots - I mean Reces Pieces - for ET to follow or declaring war on your rivial island nation in Utopia or cheating in Boxing by standing behind your foe and hitting feint thus ensuring a KO??

The Infocom comment was directed at me and Pacifien probably, Luc0s, as I mentioned I'd like a HoH based off of text adventures, and before there was MUDing there was Zork. See how he dotted off that part? Different train of thought distinct from your arguement.

I still think an all-out BioWare showdown might get the liveliest reaction from the community, which could be either good or bad. LOL

Modifié par SarEnyaDor, 03 mai 2010 - 09:22 .

[Seagloom]

It's sad that I actually finished E.T. on the 2600. Several times in fact. I don't remember the old system wars though. It wasn't until the NES and Master System became prominent that I was exposed to that conflict. Ah, nostalgia...

[SarEnyaDor]

See. I was a wee child playing video games and I grew-up just fine to be a productive(ish) member of society.



Yeah, sweet memories of childhood past. My whole family participated in games, took turns playing Utopia, did Skiing (listening to the thumps as we fell all over the place) and boxing, played Ultimate Wizard and Jumpman once we got the C64. I miss that aspect of gaming - my brother and parents and I passing the joystick or controller back and forth, sitting huddled together on the floor around the TV. *sigh*



Most of the multiplayer games I can play with my family now are only 2 or 4 player games, and I bred too well and have a large and odd number of people. Where are the 6 and 8 player games of the not-so-distant past??