60083 réponses à ce sujet

[Sarah1281]

Herr Uhl wrote...

Merilsell wrote...

Although that doesn't hinder the thread to go its destined fate, like every thread like this had done before. Loghain/Alistair landsmeet, that is. >__>

I wonder why everybody has to compare them in order to judge how they act.  If it's about Loghain, Alastair is brought up as an example and vice versa.

Probably because you are basically choosing between them once Alistair tells you it's him or Loghain. Of course, sometimes it feels like people don't believe in a middle ground. I like Alistair as a character - though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora - but I cannot forgive the Anora solo ruler Loghain spared action of leaving. In most of my playthroughs it's not really relevant because him not fighting as King so he'll be more likely to survive and get coronated does have merit.

[Axekix]

yukidama wrote...

Well, aside from that one of the first conversations she had with Leliana was the elf one... from then on she never cared much for her beyond that she's useful :| Other characters of mine like her better but they're humans, but the only one who was really BFFs with her I played as a religious too.

Oooh you should do her with your HNF rogue!  It'd be like watching two sisters go at it... kinky. 

I know she's  not with Alistair, didn't you post pics of him stabbing her?!

[Kryyptehk]

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

I see them as discussions. But yes if you see them as arguments, then perhaps it would be best to stay away. Less headaches lol

Eh, I say arguments, other people say debates, you say discussions. All the same meanings, just different words. I made my original commit tongue in cheek and it should have stayed there, because I realize I sounded passive aggressive. Didn't mean to start anything. Morri cookies for all Morri fans in the thread (all two of us lol)!

[Axekix]

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

I see them as discussions. But yes if you see them as arguments, then perhaps it would be best to stay away. Less headaches lol

She tore my head off for dissing the 'Stair last week.  Apparently she's very passionate about Ali debates...

[mellifera]

Axekix wrote...

yukidama wrote...

Well, aside from that one of the first conversations she had with Leliana was the elf one... from then on she never cared much for her beyond that she's useful :| Other characters of mine like her better but they're humans, but the only one who was really BFFs with her I played as a religious too.

Oooh you should do her with your HNF rogue!  It'd be like watching two sisters go at it... kinky. 

I know she's  not with Alistair, didn't you post pics of him stabbing her?!

It was an accident (and just a flesh wound, she recovered fully)!! She's totally going for him anyway, muahaha. Also, I kind of abandoned Leliana in Lothering and Lothering is dead now

Modifié par yukidama, 06 juin 2010 - 07:17 .

[Kryyptehk]

Axekix wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

I see them as discussions. But yes if you see them as arguments, then perhaps it would be best to stay away. Less headaches lol

She tore my head off for dissing the 'Stair last week.  Apparently she's very passionate about Ali debates...

And I thought I was passive aggressive

[Axekix]

yukidama wrote...

Axekix wrote...

yukidama wrote...

Well, aside from that one of the first conversations she had with Leliana was the elf one... from then on she never cared much for her beyond that she's useful :| Other characters of mine like her better but they're humans, but the only one who was really BFFs with her I played as a religious too.

Oooh you should do her with your HNF rogue!  It'd be like watching two sisters go at it... kinky. 

I know she's  not with Alistair, didn't you post pics of him stabbing her?!

It was an accident (and just a flesh wound, she recovered fully)!! She's totally going for him anyway, muahaha. Also, I kind of abandoned Leliana in Lothering and Lothering is dead now

You left her to be ravaged by the Darkspawn?!  How could you??? 

[Addai]

Sarah1281 wrote...
 though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora 

Not bloody likely. 

At least he's in little danger in that department.  Hopefully in time he finds a nice mistress who isn't too much of a golddigger.

[mellifera]

Axekix wrote...

yukidama wrote...

Axekix wrote...

yukidama wrote...

Well, aside from that one of the first conversations she had with Leliana was the elf one... from then on she never cared much for her beyond that she's useful :| Other characters of mine like her better but they're humans, but the only one who was really BFFs with her I played as a religious too.

Oooh you should do her with your HNF rogue!  It'd be like watching two sisters go at it... kinky. 

I know she's  not with Alistair, didn't you post pics of him stabbing her?!

It was an accident (and just a flesh wound, she recovered fully)!! She's totally going for him anyway, muahaha. Also, I kind of abandoned Leliana in Lothering and Lothering is dead now

You left her to be ravaged by the Darkspawn?!  How could you??? 

Oops.

[Kryyptehk]

Addai67 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...
 though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora 

Not bloody likely. 

At least he's in little danger in that department.  Hopefully in time he finds a nice mistress who isn't too much of a golddigger.

I always take Alistair virginity, even if I'm romancing, say, Zevran. And as a man, I don't have to take his virginity because 1. I'm doing the DR and 2. I'm marrying Anora. He can find some nice girl to lose it to and I get to control most of Ferelden. Seems like a good deal to me.

[Gilsa]

Hey, I romanced Morrigan on my Brosca and did the ritual with her. Somewhere out there is an emotionally-stunted half-dwarf. Hahaha, I kill myself.

[Axekix]

Addai67 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...
 though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora 

Not bloody likely. 

I'm telling you, Anora is a closet freak.

[Axekix]

Gilsa wrote...

Hey, I romanced Morrigan on my Brosca and did the ritual with her. Somewhere out there is an emotionally-stunted half-dwarf. Hahaha, I kill myself.

*groan*

[Herr Uhl]

Sarah1281 wrote...

Herr Uhl wrote...

I wonder why everybody has to compare them in order to judge how they act.  If it's about Loghain, Alastair is brought up as an example and vice versa.

Probably because you are basically choosing between them once Alistair tells you it's him or Loghain. Of course, sometimes it feels like people don't believe in a middle ground. I like Alistair as a character - though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora - but I cannot forgive the Anora solo ruler Loghain spared action of leaving. In most of my playthroughs it's not really relevant because him not fighting as King so he'll be more likely to survive and get coronated does have merit.

I just dislike people thinking that one of them has to be right and the other wrong. If someone comes with an argument that [Alastair makes a bad decision when leaving] it usually gets the stock response [but Loghain/Anora is worse]. It's like many asserting that Bhelen is the awesomest thing in dwarven society since smokeless coal mostly due to Harrowmont being terrible in comparison.

Sure, Loghain being bad has a part in Alastair wanting to leave, but the discussion usually ends up with people flinging the same old arguments at each other from either side of the trenches. Simply put Alastair bad, no Loghain bad, no Alastair bad. *le sigh*

[Kryyptehk]

Herr Uhl wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Herr Uhl wrote...

I wonder why everybody has to compare them in order to judge how they act.  If it's about Loghain, Alastair is brought up as an example and vice versa.

Probably because you are basically choosing between them once Alistair tells you it's him or Loghain. Of course, sometimes it feels like people don't believe in a middle ground. I like Alistair as a character - though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora - but I cannot forgive the Anora solo ruler Loghain spared action of leaving. In most of my playthroughs it's not really relevant because him not fighting as King so he'll be more likely to survive and get coronated does have merit.

I just dislike people thinking that one of them has to be right and the other wrong. If someone comes with an argument that [Alastair makes a bad decision when leaving] it usually gets the stock response [but Loghain/Anora is worse]. It's like many asserting that Bhelen is the awesomest thing in dwarven society since smokeless coal mostly due to Harrowmont being terrible in comparison.

Sure, Loghain being bad has a part in Alastair wanting to leave, but the discussion usually ends up with people flinging the same old arguments at each other from either side of the trenches. Simply put Alastair bad, no Loghain bad, no Alastair bad. *le sigh*

Exactly. Well said.

[Addai]

Axekix wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...
 though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora 

Not bloody likely. 

I'm telling you, Anora is a closet freak.

Ugh, Maker, do you have to draw such a picture?

Where are those screenshots which replace the PC in the tent scenes with a darkspawn or skeleton?  There's one of Alistair mounting a hurlock.  That's the picture I get here.

And Anora can be the biggest closet freak, but Alistair is still not getting busy with her.  He'll eventually get around to doing his duty for the sake of an heir, but Anora's frigidity is a mercy.

[Miri1984]

Herr Uhl wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Herr Uhl wrote...

I wonder why everybody has to compare them in order to judge how they act.  If it's about Loghain, Alastair is brought up as an example and vice versa.

Probably because you are basically choosing between them once Alistair tells you it's him or Loghain. Of course, sometimes it feels like people don't believe in a middle ground. I like Alistair as a character - though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora - but I cannot forgive the Anora solo ruler Loghain spared action of leaving. In most of my playthroughs it's not really relevant because him not fighting as King so he'll be more likely to survive and get coronated does have merit.

I just dislike people thinking that one of them has to be right and the other wrong. If someone comes with an argument that [Alastair makes a bad decision when leaving] it usually gets the stock response [but Loghain/Anora is worse]. It's like many asserting that Bhelen is the awesomest thing in dwarven society since smokeless coal mostly due to Harrowmont being terrible in comparison.

Sure, Loghain being bad has a part in Alastair wanting to leave, but the discussion usually ends up with people flinging the same old arguments at each other from either side of the trenches. Simply put Alastair bad, no Loghain bad, no Alastair bad. *le sigh*

You articulated how I feel perfectly here. I'm no Loghain fan, but I would spare him if Alistair didn't run away because of it. They're both interesting and deep characters, and they've both made bad decisions. Shockingly bad ones. Having read The Stolen Throne and The Calling I still have more sympathy for Alistair than Loghain though - but the poor bastard's had a tough life and you can see why he does what he does.

[Axekix]

Addai67 wrote...

Axekix wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...
 though he often ends up losing his virginity to Anora 

Not bloody likely. 

I'm telling you, Anora is a closet freak.

Ugh, Maker, do you have to draw such a picture?

Where are those screenshots which replace the PC in the tent scenes with a darkspawn or skeleton?  There's one of Alistair mounting a hurlock.  That's the picture I get here.

And Anora can be the biggest closet freak, but Alistair is still not getting busy with her.  He'll eventually get around to doing his duty for the sake of an heir, but Anora's frigidity is a mercy.

I don't know about that.  In my CEF game, where I married a hardened Alistair to her, he bluntly declared that she'd be having his baby.   The only question remaining is if he can fill big brother's shoes. 

Modifié par Axekix, 06 juin 2010 - 07:39 .

[Herr Uhl]

Axekix wrote...

I don't know about that.  In my CEF game, where I married a hardened Alistair to her, he bluntly declared that she'd be having his baby.   The only question remaining is if he can fill big brother's shoes. 

He needs to fill sweardaddy's shoes (figuratively speaking).

Edit: Writing in swenglish, father in laws.

Modifié par Herr Uhl, 06 juin 2010 - 07:44 .

[Kryyptehk]

Herr Uhl wrote...

Axekix wrote...

I don't know about that.  In my CEF game, where I married a hardened Alistair to her, he bluntly declared that she'd be having his baby.   The only question remaining is if he can fill big brother's shoes. 

He needs to fill sweardaddy's shoes (figuratively speaking).

Having a million kids will certainly never leave room for a Theirinless throne, would it. Unless Ferelden was taken by Antiva, of course.

[Kryyptehk]

I'm going to bed, it is far too late to be reading an inactive forum lol. Night all!

[Addai]

Axekix wrote...
I don't know about that.  In my CEF game, where I married a hardened Alistair to her, he bluntly declared that she'd be having his baby.   The only question remaining is if he can fill big brother's shoes. 

Well like I said, he'll do his duty if the ice queen lets him.  Poor slob.

[Axekix]

Addai67 wrote...

Axekix wrote...
I don't know about that.  In my CEF game, where I married a hardened Alistair to her, he bluntly declared that she'd be having his baby.   The only question remaining is if he can fill big brother's shoes. 

Well like I said, he'll do his duty if the ice queen lets him.  Poor slob.

Anora has some Bella in her... and some Isabela too... he's in good hands

Modifié par Axekix, 06 juin 2010 - 07:49 .

[Addai]

Axekix wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

Axekix wrote...
I don't know about that.  In my CEF game, where I married a hardened Alistair to her, he bluntly declared that she'd be having his baby.   The only question remaining is if he can fill big brother's shoes. 

Well like I said, he'll do his duty if the ice queen lets him.  Poor slob.

Anora has some Bella in her... and some Isabela too... he's in good hands

Ugh, stop already.  Even Duncan's beard can't improve the image.

[Herr Uhl]

Addai67 wrote...

Axekix wrote...

Anora has some Bella in her... and some Isabela too... he's in good hands

Ugh, stop already.  Even Duncan's beard can't improve the image.

True, it is too perfect.