LadyDamodred wrote...
I always let Cauthrien live. Maybe I'm a softie, but I can't bring myself to punish her for being everything I expect one of my subordinates to be. On my HNF anyway. Other character's fight her when rescuing Anora, but never before the Landsmeet. Even my thickest characters figure walking in coated with blood is not the *best* way to get things rolling.
I like her, but it depends on my character's mood. The way she speaks to you and to Alistair really begs an ass-kicking. OTOH, if you can talk her down, her "would that I had died at Ostagar" is wrenching.
What I don't get about her is that she is despising Alistair and your PC for being the very thing that she and Loghain are- commoners (or disgraced noble, for a HN character) who are rising to power due to sheer force of will, skill, and luck.