107 réponses à ce sujet

[Loerwyn]

Just watched episode 3.



Eh. 8/10 but no strong feelings.

[dbt-kenny]

yes it has a bit which is lame

[Archdemon Cthulhu]

Celrath wrote...

Just wondering when the sonic screwdriver turned into a tricorder

It's practically been a magic wand since Ten got his hands on it, not that it wasn't well on its way during Nine's season as well.  

[addiction21]

Celrath wrote...

Just wondering when the sonic screwdriver turned into a tricorder

Its more like a Dues Ex Machina tool. Does whatever it needs to do whenever it needs to do something... even when it is broken/lost that is what is needed for the plot.

[addiction21]

87

Edit: I am not positive but I think The Doctor has gotten information off it before.
Also the light is just for show. How else would we know it was doing something if it was not all shiny and bright.

Modifié par addiction21, 18 avril 2010 - 05:10 .

[nikki191]

i watched it a few hours ago and despite a few misgivings, david tennant was my favourite doctor i love the new season.. rating: 5 sonic screwdrivers

[TOBY FLENDERSON]

Just saw the 3 episode and the return of the Daleks, can't take these ones serious because of the power ranger motif. Next episode looks great with the return of the blink angels and river song.

[Rubbish Hero]

Doctor who isn't really a serous show.

He uses a Jammie dodger.

[chiliztri]

I haven't watched the third episode yet, because I'm dreading the whole return of the Daleks. I'd have to say my least favorite episodes involve the Daleks.



At first I was iffy about Matt; I'm an avid Tennant fan. However, the second episode really sold me on him. It seems he hasn't changed too much from Tennant's portrayal of The Doctor, and is more of a continuation rather then a whole new Doctor. The transition to Matt was a lot easier then Eccelston to Tennant, because he reminds me so much of Tennant.



I still miss Tennant though.

[Rive Caedo]

McBegbie wrote...
The writing's worrying me though. After a great series opener the second ep was quite good but last night's felt a little flat and, without giving any spoilers, I'm not convinced by some of the choices or the direction they seem to be taking

Keep in mind that Moffat wrote the first two episodes, but then episode 3 was written by Mark Gatiss --- who wrote "The Unquiet Dead" and "The Idiot's Lantern" previously... which are some of my least favorite episodes.

The next two episodes are written by Moffat.
The one after that is by the guy who wrote "School Reunion"
After that is one written by Simon Nye - who hasn't done any DW episodes previously.
Following that are two episodes written by Chris
Chibnall - who previously did "42" and lots of Torchwood.
Then one by Richard Curtis. He's done plenty but no Doctor Who.
Then one by Gareth Roberts (he did "The Shakespeare Code", "The Shakespeare Code", "Planet of the Dead"... all of which were pretty "meh" <_<).

And, finally, we close with a duo from Moffat.

[FlintlockJazz]

I'm liking it personally, even the new intro music (sounds alot more like the old Who music than the old New Who music they had). The new Daleks I'm not sure on, it was good to see them win and go off to set up a new Dalek empire (just need the Time Lords to break free of their bubble and we can get the ruckus going again), but the new look is a bit off, their proportions seem wrong and they look more like giant toys than actual daleks. Matt Smith makes a good Doctor, I actually reckon he could be better than Tennant once he stops trying to copy Tennant and instead play to his own strengths (a new Doctor shouldn't play the same as previous ones I feel, instead we need to get people used to the idea of the doctor changing into different people like back with the old series).



I think the biggest concern I have is that while I love the new style and change from the faux hip and trendy style of before to a more old style Who, I can see how many of the people who liked the New Who may not like the new one, and I'd rather it not get cancelled even if it means having to put up with all the lame attempts at being trendy.

[monika26]

I've been a fan for a long time! I love Doctor Who! I'm still not sure about Matt Smith though, he's no David Tennant. Plus I get the feeling they may be pushing the show towards younger viewers with the new younger cast. We shall see...

[Andarthiel_Demigod]

I'm a big fan of Doctor Who and I've watched mos of the old series and pretty much all of the new series.
Eccleston wasn't that great and I'm glad David Tennant took over. As for Matt Smith I like what Isaw from him so far, he's quite amusing with all of his little jokes and quite hyper(like Tennant) and deliciously odd. I've only seen the first episode of the latest season but I wwas very impressed, one paricular moment springs to mind at the end when the Doctor pretty much says "Mess with the Earth and you mess with me" That was awesome. The new companion is quite cool, the acting from the little girl was really good.

[Chris Priestly]

I grew up watchign the Tom Baker era Doctor on BBC Wales (still have a crush on Leela). <3

I watched the new Who this weekend and it looks like it'll be good. I'm going to keep watching.

[pdspazzz]

Dr boring..... just give me some new Red Dwarf





"There's one thing you should know. Last time we met I was wearing a cute little black number with peach trim and gold spangles, and although it looks like I'm wearing the same outfit today, it is in fact an entirely different cute little black number, with completely different gold spangles!"

[McBegbie]

Rive Caedo wrote...

McBegbie wrote...
The writing's worrying me though. After a great series opener the second ep was quite good but last night's felt a little flat and, without giving any spoilers, I'm not convinced by some of the choices or the direction they seem to be taking

Keep in mind that Moffat wrote the first two episodes, but then episode 3 was written by Mark Gatiss --- who wrote "The Unquiet Dead" and "The Idiot's Lantern" previously... which are some of my least favorite episodes.

The next two episodes are written by Moffat.
The one after that is by the guy who wrote "School Reunion"
After that is one written by Simon Nye - who hasn't done any DW episodes previously.
Following that are two episodes written by Chris
Chibnall - who previously did "42" and lots of Torchwood.
Then one by Richard Curtis. He's done plenty but no Doctor Who.
Then one by Gareth Roberts (he did "The Shakespeare Code", "The Shakespeare Code", "Planet of the Dead"... all of which were pretty "meh" <_<).

And, finally, we close with a duo from Moffat.

Not a huge fan of "The Idiot's Lantern" but I quite enjoyed "The Unquiet Dead".  I know the Daleks are essentially the Doctor's nemesis but I think we could do with a break from them, they're getting a little overused.  As far as I know the Silurians are back this season and we're overdue a multiple doctor episode, I'd like to see McGann back, he definitely missed out.

Dr boring..... just give me some new Red Dwarf





"There's
one thing you should know. Last time we met I was wearing a cute little
black number with peach trim and gold spangles, and although it looks
like I'm wearing the same outfit today, it is in fact an entirely
different cute little black number, with completely different gold
spangles!"

If Back to Earth is anything to go by then it's probably best left alone now, unless they can get Grant and Naylor to collaborate one last time.

[pdspazzz]

If Back to Earth is anything to go by then it's probably best left alone now, unless they can get Grant and Naylor to collaborate one last time.

[/quote]   


sadly you are right i just like to pretend that back to earth was just a bad dream

[Loerwyn]

Chris Priestly wrote...

I grew up watchign the Tom Baker era Doctor on BBC Wales (still have a crush on Leela). <3

I watched the new Who this weekend and it looks like it'll be good. I'm going to keep watching.

Wow, you're from the Great Island too?

[McBegbie]

Chris Priestly wrote...

I grew up watchign the Tom Baker era Doctor on BBC Wales (still have a crush on Leela). <3

I watched the new Who this weekend and it looks like it'll be good. I'm going to keep watching.

I was always a fan of romana (lalla ward) myself

[Rive Caedo]

McBegbie wrote...
we're overdue a multiple doctor episode

Time Crash was so perfectly done I don't really care much if they do a full mutliple Doctor story or not.

Two minutes to Belgium!

[Pacifien]

I haven't really finalized my opinion of the Eleventh Doctor. I had heard that his mimicking of the Tenth Doctor is deliberate, so as not to be immediately polarizing to the fans because Tennant was that popular. But the Tenth Doctor was so dramatically different from the Ninth, I don't entirely buy that argument. Then again, they had the benefit of having Rose for continuity.

Tenth Doctor was good, but I personally loved the Ninth Doctor the best out of all of them. There was a dark intensity that really drew me in, but he still maintained a bit of glee about the universe. Eccleston immediately drew me in.

Part of my problem with the Eleventh Doctor is that he's yet to do anything that makes me care about this current incarnation, his reputation solely rests on the benefit of being the Doctor. The Ninth and Tenth Doctors had quirks that became apparent much earlier on.

Looking forward to the return of--wait, would it be a spoiler to say?