CheeseEnchilada wrote...
Would people have preferred the sensual romance scenes of ME1 in ME2? While I wasn't a fan of the Kaidan romance in ME1, I loved the build-up to the scene and the scene itself. Is it the sensuality that gets people, or the fact that it doesn't "fade to black" so quickly?
-To me, this depends. I stated earlier in the thread that I thought the headbump with Garrus was the sweetest thing Shepard could've done with Garrus, seeing how he was all nervous and anxious in the buildup and during the scene itself. Sex would've been taking a great big stinking **** all over the scene.
-With Jack, it seemed nice that they didn't actually have sex, because you know thats sorta what Jack resorts to when she tries to push people away from her. I thought that the kiss they had would've been enough for the scene, and the rest of it just ruined the moment for me.
-I know a lot of people criticize the scene with Miranda, as do I, but I think its for different reasons. The engine room seemed like a great place for it to happen, imo. She had always put her personally feelings aside of her, and although she didn't try to dehumanize herself like Garrus did, she still wanted to keep her feelings as far from her as possible. By doing it in the engine room, its basically her way of getting over that hump. I thought it was good that was really sexualized in the scene, because she had been really insecure about herself in the past, and she's coming to grips with what she is.
-I didn't do Jacob, but I saw it. I wasn't emotionally invested in it, so I'm not gonna try to analyze it since someone else can probably do it better. I will say from what I can tell by his dialogue, him taking off that shirt was actually an important part. He said earlier "she requires a better man than I", and this is his way of getting over himself.
-Like with Jacob, I wasn't emotionally vested with Tali, so I saw it on youtube, but from what I saw Tali's seemed good, because it really captured her character and emotions. Somebody finally saw past her helmet for the first time in her life, and that was really a nice touch.
-Thane's is the only scene I didn't like. The dialogue was nice, but it needed skin. It showed that Thane emotionally got over his wife, but not physically. That kiss wasn't enough imo.
It really depends on the character. Skin is good for Miranda & Jacob (self-esteem). Not for Jack, seeing as thats part of her "brokeness". It would've mattered for Thane to show he got over his wife in the physical state. It only mattered in Tali's scene that he saw her face. And Garrus didn't need sex, just someone to love. If they did that headbump for 10 minutes it would've been better than 10 minutes of sex.
Modifié par MisterDyslexo, 14 novembre 2010 - 04:30 .
Retour en haut
