459 réponses à ce sujet

[Nightwriter]

Oh, I wouldn't say the kiss is awkward, Massy.

The buildup to it is actually pretty steamy, I thought. I assume you're referring to her immediate denial of it afterward? That was hilarious.

"What the hell was that? That - that didn't mean anything. Nothing. You should go now - and stop smiling, damn it!"

[TMA LIVE]

Though Tali's my favorite romance in the game, I think Jack's scene and the ME1 LI scene with the picture are the best scenes. With Jack, it's very easy to screw that romance up (at least compared to the others), and when she shows up and reveals her vulnerable side, it's a heartbreaking scene. Heck, I bet it didn't even involve sex. They're just in love together.



With the picture scene, it's very sad, emotional, and lonely. Shepard turned down every possible romance, because he/she couldn't move on. Thus, he/she stands alone in his/her room, staring at the photo, wishing to be with that person one more time, before going on a suicide mission. Reminding Shepard of what he/she is fighting for.

[Anoleis]

Easy

<-------JACK! by far..

[Nostradamoose]

remember, Jack doesn't have sex, she makes love.

[Nightwriter]

When you all say Jack, you mean Jack's paragon romance scene, right?

[Loki 522]

Miranda by far has the best romance scene

[Collider]

Nightwriter wrote...

When you all say Jack, you mean Jack's paragon romance scene, right?

Of course.
Personally, I think Jack needs a friend more than she needs a lover. She needs to have people who will care about her and help her without them also wanting something more. That's my opinion though, I don't think anyone is unjustified in saying that I'm wrong.

[TMA LIVE]

Collider wrote...

Nightwriter wrote...

When you all say Jack, you mean Jack's paragon romance scene, right?

Of course.
Personally, I think Jack needs a friend more than she needs a lover. She needs to have people who will care about her and help her without them also wanting something more. That's my opinion though, I don't think anyone is unjustified in saying that I'm wrong.

Yeah, I kind of wish things could go that way. If you play your cards right, it "kind of" does, but they still try to force a romance question on you, which you have to reject like an ****, and then reject again. You still end up being friends, but she's tired of you coming down to talk to her.

[kraidy1117]

I will give my list in order



1: Jack

2: Miri

3: Garrus

4: Tali

5: Thane

[Jackal904]

Nostradamoose wrote...

remember, Jack doesn't have sex, she makes love.

I agree, But the question is who do we think has the best romance scene, not the best sex scene. But I would still say Jack has the best sex scene. That renegade sex scene is ****'n hot!

Collider wrote...

Nightwriter wrote...

When you all say Jack, you mean Jack's paragon romance scene, right?

Of course.
Personally, I think Jack needs a friend more than she needs a lover. She needs to have people who will care about her and help her without them also wanting something more. That's my opinion though, I don't think anyone is unjustified in saying that I'm wrong.

A lot of people would consider their significant other as their best friend.

Modifié par Jackal904, 21 avril 2010 - 01:49 .

[Nightwriter]

Actually, after I talked to exterminator I realized what I would've liked more is a Jack sex scene that is both a little bit renegade and paragon.

Jack's got that renegade streak in there - she's wild and that will never fully go away. It's part of her. She's also vulnerable. However I think that a sex scene that shows only her violence or only her vulnerability isn't capturing her duality the way it should be captured, or the conflict therein.

I would've liked a sex scene with Jack where at first she tries to just get violent and throw you down like in the renegade sex scene, comes on strong. But the paragon approach is not letting her - you grab her, you look her in the eye, you just say, "Jack" or something. Then she melts - the violence goes, the emotion comes, and it leads to the paragon sex ending.

[MColes]

Jack's scene always feels offputting. And like people said, you're basically forced to romance her or be a dick. I was just trying to be a friend, she sure as hell needed one. Her having this huge breakdown and crying as she kisses you seems.. so out of character. She's been dealing with it for how many years, having her try to romance AND open up to you at the same time seemed like a giant leap instead of baby steps I'd expect from her. I kind of thought they didn't actually have sex, which I'm in favour of. Jack's damaged goods, she should need time.



Also, Miranda. Shep's saved the Galaxy, he's the epitome of humanity; strong, smart, confident and heroic. Those kinds of individuals always gravitate towards other strong, confident personalities.

[Strike]

They all have their weak and strong points. Paragon Jack romance scene is actually quite sweet, along with Tali's romance scene.

Miranda's could have been better. I thought it was a little out of character with the whole clearing the engine room thing. Thane's was melodramatic comprising mostly about how depressed he was about dying, kind of killed the mood. Garrus' scene was my favorite ME2 romance scene, but still awkward and the transitition between the cuteness and emotional parts were rushed.

I like the ME1 romance scenes much better because they were more realistic and engaging. I am partial to Kaidan's scene though.

[Jackal904]

Nightwriter wrote...

Actually, after I talked to exterminator I realized what I would've liked more is a Jack sex scene that is both a little bit renegade and paragon.

Jack's got that renegade streak in there - she's wild and that will never fully go away. It's part of her. She's also vulnerable. However I think that a sex scene that shows only her violence or only her vulnerability isn't capturing her duality the way it should be captured, or the conflict therein.

I would've liked a sex scene with Jack where at first she tries to just get violent and throw you down like in the renegade sex scene, comes on strong. But the paragon approach is not letting her - you grab her, you look her in the eye, you just say, "Jack" or something. Then she melts - the violence goes, the emotion comes, and it leads to the paragon sex ending.

Can't say I agree, but that would be interesting. The scene you made up is kind of how her whole paragon romance subplot goes. At first she acts "renegade" and tries to make it seem like it's all just about sex, but you show her that it isn't, and that you do want to pursue a meaningful relationship with her.

MColes wrote...

Jack's scene always feels offputting. And like people said, you're basically forced to romance her or be a dick.

That's not the character's fault. It's like that for every squadmate. Sure you have to be extra "dickish" to Jack when you tell her you don't want to have a relationship with her, but just like very other squadmate, you either have a romantic relationship with them or you don't talk to them.

MColes wrote...

I was just trying to be a friend, she sure as hell needed one. Her having this huge breakdown and crying as she kisses you seems.. so out of character.

It's not out of character at all. I don't mean to sound condescending but did you actually go through her whole paragon romance subplot? It seems completely in character after you have gone through all her paragon romance conversations.

[TMA LIVE]

Jackal904 wrote...

MColes wrote...

I was just trying to be a friend, she sure as hell needed one. Her having this huge breakdown and crying as she kisses you seems.. so out of character.

It's not out of character at all. I don't mean to sound condescending but did you actually go through her whole paragon romance subplot? It seems completely in character after you have gone through all her paragon romance conversations.

I agree. It's completely in character with her if you explore all her scenes.

[kglaser]

I have no choice but to vote Garrus. Completely adorable.

[stormrain]

For Male LI: Tali's is the sweetest, Jack's is the most emotionally engaging, and Miranda's rockin' the sexiness.

I don't have much opinion for Fem LI's as I hardly play FemShep (despite being a girl) and the one I do have beats them all off with a stick.

If I had to choose a favorite though, it'd be Jack. Hands down.

[Lady of the Waters]

Femsheps: Kaidan.



Malesheps: Jack

[enormousmoonboots]

Collider wrote...

This topic:
*Insert favorite romanceable character here* has the best romance scene!
/thread

ITT: Waifus.

[Mak999]

Jack.

[GodWood]

Male Sheps: Jack.

Fem Sheps: Thane.

[Foune]

Jack's romance made me shed a couple of tears.

[Silverite]

Mass Effect1 love scenes surpass ME2 100 times IMO.



Jack romance and love scene is the best in ME2.