Aller au contenu

Photo

Which love intrest did u choose and why?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
88 réponses à ce sujet

#51
Forst1999

Forst1999
  • Members
  • 2 924 messages
My main Shep, William, soldier, paragon was with Liara in ME 1, he likes nice girls. So in ME 2 he had to go with Tali. Now i can't resist her with male Shep anymore, she is just cute.
Randall F., Infiltrator, once renegade, now more paragon, was always concepted as hard with a soft spot for Ashley. So he stayed true to her (but it was hard to turn Tali down).
With my third male Shep, Nick, Sentinel, Paragon, Alcoholic, i tried to romance no one in ME 1, so i wouldn't "cheat" anyone with Tali. Ash just came to the captains quarters anyway, and i couldn't say no.
My first Femshep, Mira, Adept, Paragon, is a big Asari fan. Stayed true to Liara in ME 2.
My second Femshep, Helen, Engineer, Renegade (Slogan: What would Saren do?) accidently romanced Liara, in ME 2 she went for Garrus. The two are very alike.
My third Femshep, Penelope, Vanguard, paragon who really likes to punch people is absolutly for Kaidan. He is a good guy who might be able to cool her temper.
My fourth Femshep, Amy, Soldier, paragon, finally managed to romance no one in ME 1. In ME 2 she went with Thane, because he just is cool. "Blondie and the Lizard-Man" are a nice couple.
My fifth Femshep, Lucy, Infiltrator, paragon, is an Asari-nerd like my first, but she will at least flirt with Samara. The more i play Mass Effect 2 the more i like Samara.

Modifié par Forst1999, 04 mai 2010 - 11:52 .


#52
KitsuneRommel

KitsuneRommel
  • Members
  • 753 messages
One of my Shepards went with Liara in ME1, had some fun with Kelly, romanced Tali and afterwards broke up with her and chose Jack instead. In ME3 I'll have an army of little Shepards.

#53
RollaWarden

RollaWarden
  • Members
  • 135 messages

The Awesome Darkrose wrote...

I'm no trollin', just threads like this are slooooowly getting to annoy me. And what's wrong with having one thread for one topic? You see the thread name - you post your thoughts on it. No need to read it all.


If the threads annoy you, don't post.  Take your own advice.  Never wrote that there's anything wrong with one thread for one topic.  Nothing wrong with repeated topic threads, either.  No harm, no foul--again.

Explained the question in my first reply.

I'll reply no more, my compadre Darkrose.  I'm already breaking first rule of forum responses: never start an argument with an anonymous poster.  He/she is usually indestructible, and WILL get the last word in--it's a neurosis.

So go ahead and respond once more, state/repeat your case, and then this little OT exchange will die.  I hereby already declare you the winner.  There you go.

Back to OP:

In my second playthrough, I'm considering flirting (feed the fish!!!) with Kelly.  She's mega, mega cute. 

I'd also like to see if, in ME3, there's a throwdown between Ashley and Miranda (I may romance her as well) over my Shep.  Wouldn't want to miss that scene.

Modifié par RollaWarden, 04 mai 2010 - 03:34 .


#54
SolitaireOne

SolitaireOne
  • Members
  • 183 messages
In ME1, I played 98% Paragon male -- romanced Liara, unfortunately Ashley died on Virmire. For ME2, kept all same, but played more like 75% Paragon -- liked the naughty-girl this time, so went for Jack.



Mmmm, Jack...

#55
Throw_this_away

Throw_this_away
  • Members
  • 1 020 messages
Femshep Paragon: Kaiden in ME1... stuck with him in ME2
Femshep Renegade: Kaiden (same import)... undecided... probably Jacob because he is human, and seeing the prize video should be classic. 

Sheploo Paragon: Ashley in ME1 then Miranda
Shaploo Renegade: Miranda (no ME1 import)

My thoughts: 

Tali: Boring character (no face = less emoting).  Boring story.  Annoying voice. No challange (she throws herself at you... boring).  Emotional maturity of a 13 year old.  Nothing that attracts me to her in any way, beyond being friends... and even then I never bother to talk to her after my first completionist playthrough.   

Jack: Not attractive.  Interesting, but I just don't dig the emotionally scarred rebel type.  I like a more clean cut type of woman.  

Ashley: Not bad, but overall never really did much for me.  

Liara: I would make her my LI if I did ME1 again.  Interesting character in ME1... but like Tali in ME2... kind of immature and throws herself at you.  Not appealing for that reason.  

Miranda: Hot.  I like the femme fatal image/story.  She is a cold **** early on, but the loyalty mission shows you her caring loyal side.  I like a tough woman with a soft side.  Looks to kill abd great voice acting never hurt.  Being my most useful (and used) squadmate doesn't hurt either.     

Morinth/Samara: Never felt I had anything in common with Samara... and I know better with Morinth.  

Kaiden: Meh... good guy I guess... but I let my wife pick him (she was not interested in Liara, but I kept teasing that I would choose her as my femshep was designed to look like my wife)

Jacob: Meh... but I will prob choose him next just for a laugh.  

Thane: Tempting... but I guess having sex with a lizard is not appealing to me.  PLus, I would never go for someone still so attached to a past relationship.  "I want you" after he spills his guts on his wife was never an option. 

Garrus: He is my buddy, not a LI.  

Modifié par Throw_this_away, 04 mai 2010 - 04:03 .


#56
SilverRose208

SilverRose208
  • Members
  • 701 messages
2 ME1 imports - 2 times sticking with Ashley. Tried to go for Miranda on the first import, but that face-down picture was just too much... had to reload.

#57
DoomedMello

DoomedMello
  • Members
  • 43 messages
I didn't go with anyone in ME1.

In ME2, on the other hand, I went with Thane. They seemed to have the most chemistry out of any of the options, and I just like Thane. (Also, what is up with all the Thane hate around these boards?)

#58
Annihilator27

Annihilator27
  • Members
  • 6 653 messages
Paragon shepard I stayed with liara. It was hard since tali was an option. But i still like Liara better.Its like she needs someone to be there for here or something.

#59
Aceyalone7777

Aceyalone7777
  • Members
  • 286 messages
Actually ME2 had a LI for every need...
Bit chy (Jack) , Femme-Fatale (Miranda), Love Crash (Tali) for maleShep and
Funny (Garrus), Tragic Figure (Thane) and... Jacob (at least he had a builded body) for femShep

Modifié par Aceyalone7777, 04 mai 2010 - 09:44 .


#60
Orion1836

Orion1836
  • Members
  • 800 messages
To be honest, the first I heard of Mass Effect was the "ZOMG lesbian sex" expose on Fox News. Naturally, I looked up the wiki on ME, and I was thought to myself "How the hell did I miss this game? This looks awesome."

Then I saw it was XBox only, and realized exactly why I missed the game.

So ME comes out for the PC, and I deploy. I take it with me and was absolutely blown away. I loved the universe they built, and really thought the whole concept of the Asari race was unique and well thought out. It wasn't "let's have hot blue alien babes for the sake of having hot blue alien babes." I was really looking forward to seeing what they would do with a LI character from such a race.

So then I run into Tali on the Citadel for the first time. Now, keep in mind, Quarians were a footnote on the Mass Effect wiki at the time I read it. All I got was "race of smart engineers," and "Tali is to ME what Mission was to KOTOR." I was fully prepared to just sort of have her as a side-character.

What I should have remembered was that I freaking loved Mission. And Tali is, at least, Mission squared. Maybe cubed. Tali absolutely blew me away from her introduction on the citadel. It was a testament to Sroka's voice acting that even her codex entry-type dialogue made me want to hang on every word. I was just a little sad that she didn't have a bigger role in the game.

Then I met Liara.

Not to draw the flames of the Liara fans, I really wasn't impressed. Sure, I liked her, but Bioware has created some awesome and compelling love interests before, and Liara just didn't measure up in my opinion. Hell, the consort and Shiala were more interesting, and they had a mere fraction of the lines Liara did. I liked Ashley too, but really, it was just a choice between meh, and meh.

So in my original game (paragon vanguard), I romanced Liara, and figured they'd probably develop more of the character as the series went on (boy was I in for a surprise). The more I played, though, the more I realized that I liked Tali's tiny amount of character development far more than the entire conversation chain you have with either Liara or Ash. When I played through on my renegade FemShep soldier, I had a hard time denying Tali the Geth data, even though I was trying to be as evil as I possibly could.

Then I found out while I was deployed this year that Tali would be romancable in the new game.

Holy. #*$&balls.

Needless to say, I replayed all of ME1 with no romance option (paragon soldier), and I never looked back. ME2 was as epic as I expected, and the Tali romance was handled in the best manner that I could envision the writers handling it. They didn't go for anything cheap, or contrived. They took her character, gave her a believable crush on Shepard (starting from the first game), and carried it through realistically. There wasn't suddenly a miraculous way for Quarians to be out of their suits. There wasn't a massive change in Tali's character either. Instead, it was a couple overcoming some very difficult obstacles and there was a smooth evolution from what you saw in ME1 to the start of a romance in ME2.

It didn't hurt that Tali's loyalty mission was, in my opinion, the best written of all of them. After making the paragon choices, it's no wonder she falls in love with you.

Now I have to say, Jack was a hell of a compelling character. Had Tali not been in this game, I would have chosen her as my "canon" LI. I'll probably use my original (now paragade) vanguard for that. But... for my main character (spacer/war hero soldier), I just can't see him choosing anyone other than Tali.

Miranda, as much as I found her backstory interesting, was just too much of a cliche for me. Yes, she has sex appeal, but if you play on the paragon side, could you ever see your Shep getting together with someone who not only belonged to Cerberus, but fully supported what they were doing?

Modifié par Orion1836, 04 mai 2010 - 08:29 .


#61
Aceyalone7777

Aceyalone7777
  • Members
  • 286 messages
^ Hah read your post in Tali thread. However the thread had moved 30 or so pages, so I thought it would be better to not quote it. Still , happy to see another Tali fan in the forums... Maybe we can convince Bioware for a ME3 Tali LI... I hope...

#62
Neria Rose

Neria Rose
  • Members
  • 1 135 messages

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

Mrs Vakarian wrote...

ME1- Regretfully Kaidan... Somehow being nice to him turned out to be a one night stand... :/ And I really don't see how developing a relationship with a character in ME2 is considered cheating when it was only a one night stand and you died... Just saying...

ME2- Garrus all the way. Why? Because it's freaking Garrus Vakarian, and he's the best character in ME. Plus, Garrus and Shepard are soul mates... Enough said :D


Yeah, all the ME1 LIs had that one-night stand feeling.
Also, mind I ask? Since I am male, I really can't decide... Is Kaidan suppose to be THAT good-looking? I never considered him very handsome (at least less pretty than Ashley)


Just since no one has responded to this yet:

Let me say first that I am not a huge Kaidan fan. I romanced him in ME1 because he was the only doable option for FemShep. I don't hate him, I wouldn't even say I dislike him, I just wasn't wow'd by his personality.

But the character is very handsome. He's just tall enough for FemShep and I'm very partial to dark hair and dark eyes, especially on men <3.

Garrus is my true love, however.

#63
Barquiel

Barquiel
  • Members
  • 5 847 messages
femShep
Liara (ME1/ME2)
- I like her...my favorite character:wub:
- the ME2 romance options don't appeal to me

maleShep
Miranda

#64
Aceyalone7777

Aceyalone7777
  • Members
  • 286 messages

Neria Rose wrote...

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

Mrs Vakarian wrote...

ME1- Regretfully Kaidan... Somehow being nice to him turned out to be a one night stand... :/ And I really don't see how developing a relationship with a character in ME2 is considered cheating when it was only a one night stand and you died... Just saying...

ME2- Garrus all the way. Why? Because it's freaking Garrus Vakarian, and he's the best character in ME. Plus, Garrus and Shepard are soul mates... Enough said :D


Yeah, all the ME1 LIs had that one-night stand feeling.
Also, mind I ask? Since I am male, I really can't decide... Is Kaidan suppose to be THAT good-looking? I never considered him very handsome (at least less pretty than Ashley)


Just since no one has responded to this yet:

Let me say first that I am not a huge Kaidan fan. I romanced him in ME1 because he was the only doable option for FemShep. I don't hate him, I wouldn't even say I dislike him, I just wasn't wow'd by his personality.

But the character is very handsome. He's just tall enough for FemShep and I'm very partial to dark hair and dark eyes, especially on men <3.

Garrus is my true love, however.


Thanks for the quote.... I really thought my question had been forgotten :crying:
So... next question just for ... Is Garrus supposed to be more handsome than Kaidan???

Modifié par Aceyalone7777, 04 mai 2010 - 10:08 .


#65
sonofalich

sonofalich
  • Members
  • 408 messages
in order of playthroughs: miranda, loyal to ashley, the priiize, and garrus.

#66
Guest_Trust_*

Guest_Trust_*
  • Guests
Male Shep romanced Liara in ME1, Miranda in ME2.

Female Shep - I tried all romances but I honestly didn't like any of them. I think I'll keep her single for now. Garrus was the best, Kaiden was fine, Thane is WTF and Jacob romance was badly made.

#67
Jackal904

Jackal904
  • Members
  • 2 244 messages

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

happy to see another Tali fan in the forums... Maybe we can convince Bioware for a ME3 Tali LI... I hope...


Ummm... are you new to these forums?

#68
Neria Rose

Neria Rose
  • Members
  • 1 135 messages

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

Neria Rose wrote...

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

Mrs Vakarian wrote...

ME1- Regretfully Kaidan... Somehow being nice to him turned out to be a one night stand... :/ And I really don't see how developing a relationship with a character in ME2 is considered cheating when it was only a one night stand and you died... Just saying...

ME2- Garrus all the way. Why? Because it's freaking Garrus Vakarian, and he's the best character in ME. Plus, Garrus and Shepard are soul mates... Enough said :D


Yeah, all the ME1 LIs had that one-night stand feeling.
Also, mind I ask? Since I am male, I really can't decide... Is Kaidan suppose to be THAT good-looking? I never considered him very handsome (at least less pretty than Ashley)


Just since no one has responded to this yet:

Let me say first that I am not a huge Kaidan fan. I romanced him in ME1 because he was the only doable option for FemShep. I don't hate him, I wouldn't even say I dislike him, I just wasn't wow'd by his personality.

But the character is very handsome. He's just tall enough for FemShep and I'm very partial to dark hair and dark eyes, especially on men <3.

Garrus is my true love, however.


Thanks for the quote.... I really thought my question had been forgotten :crying:
So... next question just for ... Is Garrus supposed to be more handsome than Kaidan???


Well, Garrus.. I think he's humanoid enough to be considered handsome. Turian hips and legs took some getting used to and ultimately, naturally, I prefer upper legs that are more human-looking (i.e. Saren's <3). But back to Garrus.. I thought he was cool-looking initially, though not as much as Nihlus. But then he opened his mouth and his voice was (is) just sooooo sexy. Toss in his killer personality and voila! He's suddenly gone from being cool-looking to hawt, smexy, and, at times, adorably awkward.

So for me, he is infinitely more handsome (or attractive in general) than Kaidan. But he's not supposed to be. I know Bioware was surprised by Garrus' popularity (don't have any links, but it's common knowledge now. I do remember a radio interview just before ME2 came out where Casey Hudson (was it him??) mentioned they were surprised by the interest in having Garrus as a LI).

#69
MrNose

MrNose
  • Members
  • 567 messages

Orion1836 wrote...

It didn't hurt that Tali's loyalty mission was, in my opinion, the best written of all of them. After making the paragon choices, it's no wonder she falls in love with you.

Now I have to say, Jack was a hell of a compelling character. Had Tali not been in this game, I would have chosen her as my "canon" LI. I'll probably use my original (now paragade) vanguard for that. But... for my main character (spacer/war hero soldier), I just can't see him choosing anyone other than Tali.


I found several other loyalty missions more compelling myself, but I definitely understand the loyalty mission enhancing your choice for LI.  In my opinion Miranda's loyalty mission was heads and shoulders better than the rest of the missions, and was a big part of why I romanced her.  

My loyalty mission rankings to Tali's go like this:

1. Miranda - Touching, showed a very different side of her, etc.
2. Samara - Mostly because it was just such a gigantic change of pace from before, and I love shutting Morinth down.
3. Tali & Legion (tie) - Because you have big choices to make in both of these, especially in Tali's, and because after you beat them you get the cutscene.
(Combat wise, my favourite missions are Miranda, Grunt and Zaeed's in no particular order.  I just felt like they all had their own unique flavour to them.  Miri's had intrigue, Grunt's had a thresher maw, and Zaeed's had the ability to let civilians die in a fire.)  

LAST PLACE: Jacob...  Seriously, we're on an important mission, you hated your father when you did know him, and now you want us to detour just to check up on him?  LAME.  I understood Jack wanting to blow things up.  She's crazy.  But not you. 

#70
Aceyalone7777

Aceyalone7777
  • Members
  • 286 messages

Neria Rose wrote...

Well, Garrus.. I think he's humanoid enough to be considered handsome. Turian hips and legs took some getting used to and ultimately, naturally, I prefer upper legs that are more human-looking (i.e. Saren's <3). But back to Garrus.. I thought he was cool-looking initially, though not as much as Nihlus. But then he opened his mouth and his voice was (is) just sooooo sexy. Toss in his killer personality and voila! He's suddenly gone from being cool-looking to hawt, smexy, and, at times, adorably awkward.

So for me, he is infinitely more handsome (or attractive in general) than Kaidan. But he's not supposed to be. I know Bioware was surprised by Garrus' popularity (don't have any links, but it's common knowledge now. I do remember a radio interview just before ME2 came out where Casey Hudson (was it him??) mentioned they were surprised by the interest in having Garrus as a LI).


Wow. I don't think i will be able to look (or hear) Garrus the same again. 
He seems awkward to me since he is the only LI that is not humanoid. Even Thane looks like human. And Tali implicates great human resemblances too.

It must be his lips though. I just cant imagine him getting a mouth kiss...

#71
Neria Rose

Neria Rose
  • Members
  • 1 135 messages

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

Wow. I don't think i will be able to look (or hear) Garrus the same again. 
He seems awkward to me since he is the only LI that is not humanoid. Even Thane looks like human. And Tali implicates great human resemblances too.

It must be his lips though. I just cant imagine him getting a mouth kiss...


Oh, my FemShep has no problems giving him a kiss on the mouth. He just can't kiss back, not in a human way, anyway:D.

Modifié par Neria Rose, 04 mai 2010 - 10:45 .


#72
Barquiel

Barquiel
  • Members
  • 5 847 messages

MrNose wrote...

My loyalty mission rankings to Tali's go like this:

1. Miranda - Touching, showed a very different side of her, etc.
2. Samara - Mostly because it was just such a gigantic change of pace from before, and I love shutting Morinth down.
3. Tali & Legion (tie) - Because you have big choices to make in both of these, especially in Tali's, and because after you beat them you get the cutscene.
(Combat wise, my favourite missions are Miranda, Grunt and Zaeed's in no particular order.  I just felt like they all had their own unique flavour to them.  Miri's had intrigue, Grunt's had a thresher maw, and Zaeed's had the ability to let civilians die in a fire.)  

LAST PLACE: Jacob...  Seriously, we're on an important mission, you hated your father when you did know him, and now you want us to detour just to check up on him?  LAME.  I understood Jack wanting to blow things up.  She's crazy.  But not you. 


Miranda's mission is my favorite as well.

I think the "we're on an important mission" argument can be used for most loyality missions^_^
Garrus/Zaeeds revenge stories are the worst imo.

#73
Aceyalone7777

Aceyalone7777
  • Members
  • 286 messages

Neria Rose wrote...

Aceyalone7777 wrote...

Wow. I don't think i will be able to look (or hear) Garrus the same again. 
He seems awkward to me since he is the only LI that is not humanoid. Even Thane looks like human. And Tali implicates great human resemblances too.

It must be his lips though. I just cant imagine him getting a mouth kiss...


Oh, my FemShep has no problems giving him a kiss on the mouth. He just can't kiss back, not in a human way, anyway:D.


:P At least he can *headbump*

#74
foilpainter

foilpainter
  • Members
  • 153 messages
Well, at first I thought Samara would be a love interest and I pursued it to the point where Samara and Shep were about to kiss and she says no and takes off from the observation deck to the crews quarters! So then I chose Jack as a romance after the suicide misson was done and after Kelly girl did her great stripper dance and was not sure if I would get the romance cut scene with Jack after the misson but I did and Jacks back story was interesting and touched by how she always tried to put up a wall because she did not want to get hurt...reminded me of a woman I use to know and I am always interested in a challenge! So I chose Jack and have to admit Jack and Shep look good together!

#75
Splinter Cell 108

Splinter Cell 108
  • Members
  • 3 254 messages
As a male I chose Liara in ME1 and I'm not cheating on her with that character. Besides I didn't find the LI options for males interesting enough. As for my females I always romance Garrus with them because he's my favorite character and his romance shows a part of him that is rarely seen.