42 réponses à ce sujet

[Clammo]

I haven't seen this posted (apologies if it has), but there's a nice review form Eurogamer here, probably nothing we haven't heard before but it does speak fairly glowingly about the game.

And there's a small section which may put to rest the worries some have had about the "easy" difficulty setting not being all that easy.

http://www.eurogamer...nds-on_6?page=1

Edit: contains spoilers, like most reviews do!

Modifié par Clammo, 20 octobre 2009 - 08:03 .

[Halfcab]

It has been posted and WARNING page 2 contains some hefty spoilers.

[Lucy Glitter]

yeah a lot of spoilers guys I got caught :[

[Clammo]

Hmm, not sure why the link doesn't click, but it works if it's copy and pasted.

[Clammo]

Apologies but to be fair, reviews tend to contain spoilers, I didn't think a warning was necessary.



I've edited the original post.

[Arcite550]

what kind of spoilers?

[Clammo]

Story spoilers.

[Arcite550]

Dooooh I dunno if i want to read it now dang that reviewer

[Halfcab]

Reviews are made to review the game, not announce major initial plot turn.



Harry Potter movie reviews don't say, "Snape kills dumbledoor."



Do you still think reviews are made to contain spoilers. Some do, there called bad reviews. Good reviews are objective without giving spoilers away so people can still enjoy the twists. I've been seeing alot of bad reviews from eurogamer and I'm pretty much done with their links people post. Thanks for putting the final nail in the coffin for me =\\

[Arcite550]

soooo dont read it

[Clammo]

If you've read their reviews before and considered them spoilerific and bad quality it begs the question why open that and expect any different?

I've already apologised that you got caught out by spoilers, however most reviews contain them. It's subjective as to whether someone considers a spoiler making a review poor quality.

Modifié par Clammo, 20 octobre 2009 - 08:33 .

[Lucy Glitter]

I am not having a go at you, Clammo, I am saying in my humble opinion that the article does constitute as a big spoiler, as it tell you the outcome of a huge main quest. I know you put up a spoiler warning Jus' saying that I think that something like that isn't subjective.

[Arcite550]

Well the GI review had little spoilers

[Clammo]

Yeah, but the fact that I personally expect spoilers, big or small, in a review makes it subjective. Yes granted one of the spoilers is very big.



*shrugs* I've apologised some people are pissed at finding spoilers, and edited it to warn people, I'm not really sure what else I can do to make amends apart from bake cookies.

[Clammo]

Arcite550 wrote...

Well the GI review had little spoilers

The GI review? Don't think I've seen that one. Got a link please?

[Lucy Glitter]

Omg cookies!! Yes please Mistuh Clammo.

[Arcite550]

gameinformer.com/games/dragon_age_origins/b/pc/archive/2009/10/05/review.aspx

there ya go

[Clammo]

Lucy_Glitter wrote...

Omg cookies!! Yes please Mistuh Clammo.

You really want cookies baked by someone who looks like this avatar<< On your digestion be it!

[Clammo]

Arcite550 wrote...

gameinformer.com/games/dragon_age_origins/b/pc/archive/2009/10/05/review.aspx

there ya go

Cheers for that Arcite, gonna go have a browse.

[Silentplanet]

This isn't a review but a Hands on preview.. T_T i thought a new review had been posted.

[Arcite550]

No problem, tell me what you think

[Clammo]

Arcite550 wrote...

No problem, tell me what you think

Nice concise review, I'm liking the way tactics sound like they're a big part of the game, which seems to have been lacking in most western RPG's for a while now. Kinda eases any worries about the party AI acting dumb and doing things I plainly won't want them to.

A couple of screenies I hadn't seen before too.

[Lucy Glitter]

Clammo wrote...

Lucy_Glitter wrote...

Omg cookies!! Yes please Mistuh Clammo.

You really want cookies baked by someone who looks like this avatar<< On your digestion be it!

He would make sexy cookies.

[SilverApollo]

Not going to read simply to avoid major spoilers, but it seems its at least very favorable to say the least.

[Arcite550]

Clammo wrote...

Arcite550 wrote...

No problem, tell me what you think

Nice concise review, I'm liking the way tactics sound like they're a big part of the game, which seems to have been lacking in most western RPG's for a while now. Kinda eases any worries about the party AI acting dumb and doing things I plainly won't want them to.

A couple of screenies I hadn't seen before too.

yeah Giantbomb has a 20 min vid that has no spoilers as far as story unless your just now comin out of the dark about this game, i reccomend watching that too