Well French is my native tongue so I'm kinda cheating here
. No, I haven't read that one. The Mousquetaires were great but I think I prefer Monte Cristo. I'm not finished yet but the character building is top notch, even if it has some flaws such as Maximilien's lovey-dovey story.
I'm not far into Moby Dick and I can see why he said that. It's a bit of a pattern with writers of the last decade or two, like how Victor Hugo spent entire chapters describing Notre-Dame and its history and why it should be preserved (granted, his foreword made it clear he had an agenda here).
Cavelier of Maison Rouge has a lovey dovey story but it really got me, it has a building plot like Monte Cristo but camaraderie and drive like the musketeers, it really summed up Dumas views about the French Revolution, which I always enjoyed more than Tale of 2 Cities or The Scarlet Pimpernel. If you dislike lovey dovey just don't ever read The Scarlet Pimpernel. I signed up for an action adventure story, and I got a really messed up couple who can't talk to each other. She accidentally betrayed him, he ignores her, and then he kisses stuff she touched when she isn't looking, it's just really bizarre thing to focus most of the book on when your hero is smuggling people across borders.
They did love their exposition, but they really wanted the history in historical fiction. That was the genre with the most attention. Although I admit I find history of a place a little more interesting than sailing. Ever read the Aubrey-Maturin series by Patrick O'Brian? Its a modern book but a little more fun and fast paced than Moby Dick, although it gets a little over the top with drama in later books.