It's nice to see a DLC thread that isn't spammed with patch requests.... yet.
errant_knight wrote...
This is one of my biggest problems with the DLC. It takes a character that I roleplayed as a human being with flaws like any of the other characters and elevates them to the position of a walking, talking deus ex machina without whom the world invariably ends and no good decision is made.
I disagree regarding the lack of "good decisions".
Alistair et al have made it as far as Denerim, he has also gathered the companions, suggesting that he's made a good fist of completing the quests.
At the end of the day, they fail because they get killed at the final battle.... by Team Darkspawn and their sentient Vanguard (i.e. by you)...
That's hardly failure.
It ignores the objections of the companions and the fact that they may
be willing to sacrifice their lives to prevent certain events and makes
it all about you (the PC). Basically, it strips all characterization and
complexity from the game and makes the unappealing result into
pseudo-canon.
I also disagree with this.
In the main campaign, you are the leader, your personality overides Alistair's and convinces him to become Robin to your Batman.
Now... imagine if you weren't there.
Who's going to lead the group?
Zevran - An assassin with shady, shady morals
Morrigan - A witch of the wilds with her own agenda
Oghren - A drunk
Sten - A man completely at odds with the world and the charm of a open gunshot wound
Leliana - A ditzy assassin pretending to be something she's not
Shale - .... right...
Wynne - A possible candidate.
Seems to me that, without your powerful personality, that either Alistair or Wynne would be leading the group.
Alistair is by no means a coward, he's quite funny, and he's determined. Who's to say this isn't the kick up the arse the guy needed to get his act together?
I don't see any reason why Alistair couldn't lead the group. He acts fairly normally when he's been "hardened" in the main campaign. Why couldn't leading the group have "hardened" him in DSC?