6700 réponses à ce sujet

[GuitarShredUK]

kyle924 wrote...

All right, everyone.

The List has been refined - details are below.


The Refined List (ME 1 & 2 Characters)
 
MASS EFFECT
 
Here's John:
1. Christian Bale - 13. Matthew Fox - Mark Wahlberg - 34. Karl Urban - 47. Matt Damon - 
49. Chris O’Donnell - 55. Chris Pine - 57. Ewan McGregor - 58. 2. Josh Hartnett 

Here's Jane:
2. Milla Jovovich - 6. Scarlet Johansson - 8. Anne Wersching - 12. Famke Janssen - 
21. Jessica Alba - 23. Keira Knightley -

Here's Kaidan:
2. Milo Ventimiglia - 7. Benjamin Bratt - 14. Chris Pine - 15. Mark Ruffalo -
18. James Franco - 21. Eddie Cahill - 24. Gaspard Ulliel - 25. Charlie Clausen -
34. Joshua Jackson – 36. Patrick Dempsey

Here's Ashley: 
2. Erica Cerra - 3. Morena Baccarin - 5. Jessica Alba - 6. Mila Kunis -  
9. Michelle Rodriguez - 12. Odette Yustman - 20. Holly Marie Combs - 22. Natalie Martinez –
24. Kelly Overton - 25. Jordana Brewster

Here's Liara:
5. Jillian Murray - 9. Sophia Myles - 14. Emma Watson –
15. Zoe Saldana - 16. Zooey Desanchel - 18. Molly C. Quinn - 19. Jordana Brewster -
21. Alexa Davalos – 23. Summer Glau


Here's Garrus:
1. Brandon Keener (VA) - 2. Hugo Weavin 7. Michael Wincott - 19. Adam Baldwin – 20. Viggo Mortensen

Here's Tali:
1. Emma Watson - 2. Famke Janssen - 3. Milla Jovovich - 4. Liz Sroka (VA) -
5. Kristen Bell - 9. Charlize Theron - 10. Stana Katic - 11. Emily Deschanel -
12. Summer Glau – 16. Mila Kunis –

Here's Wrex:  
2. Steve Barr (VA) - 7. Kevin Grevioux - 8. Michael Clarke Duncan - 10. Ray Winstone -
13. Robert Wisdom

Here's Anderson:
1. Keith David (VA) - 3. Laurence Fishburne - 5. Denzel Washington - 6. Morgan Freeman -
10. Dennis Haysbert

Here's Udina:
1. Sidney Poitier - 7. Ruben Santiago-Hudson - 9. Andre Braugher - 10. Robert Wisdom -
15. Morgan Freeman

Here's Joker:
1. Seth Green (VA)

Here's Chakwas:
1. Helen Mirren - 2. Meryl Streep - 5. Carolyn Seymour (VA) - 6. Patricia Clarkson -
7. Kate Mulgrew

Here's Conrad:
4. Jason Segel - 5. Jeff Page (VA)

Here's Hackett:
1. Lance Henriksen (VA)
 
Here's Prestly:
1. Dwight Schultz (VA + as Dr. Zev Cohen)
 
Here’s Vigil:
1. David Shaughnessy (VA)

Here's Benezia:
2. Cate Blanchett - 3. Marina Sirtis (VA) - 4. Sigourney Weaver


Here's Saren:
1. Eric Bana - 2. Mark Strong - 3. Michael Wincott -
6. Fred Tatasciore (VA + as Balak & Warden Kuril in ME 2) -
13. Sean Bean

And here's Sovereign:
3. Peter Jessop (VA + as Lorik Qui’in) - 4. Bruce Spence - 5. Dee Bradley Baker
 
MASS EFFECT 2
 
Here’s Jacob Taylor:
2. Tyrese Gibson - 4. Will Smith - 5. Keith Robinson - 8. Jamie Foxx -
10. Michael Jai White
 
Here’s Miranda Lawson:
1. Yvonne Strahovski
 
Here’s Mordin Solus:
2. Wallace Langham - 3. David Tennant - 5. Michael Beattie (VA) - 6. Simon Pegg -
8. John Billingsley –
 
Here’s Grunt:
1. Tom Lister - 2. Steve Blum (VA + as Dr. Wilson)
 
 Here’s Jack:
1. Megan Fox - 3. Milla Jovovich - 4. Courtenay Taylor (VA) -
7. Keira Knightley
 
Here’s Thane:
1. Paul Bettany - 3. Keythe Farley (VA)
 
Here’s Samara:
1. Liv Tyler - 2. Sarah Clarke - 3. Sigourney Weaver - 4. Gillian Anderson -
9. Famke Janssen
 
Here’s Legion:
1. D.C. Douglas (VA)
 
Here’s Morinth:
1. Famke Janssen - 2. Liv Tyler - 3. Natalia Cigliuti (VA) - 4. Jolene Blalock -
5. Rhona Mitra
 
Here’s Zaeed:
1. Robin Sachs (VA)
 
Here’s Kasumi:
1. Michelle Rodriguez - 3. Jordana Brewster
 
Here’s Admiral Hackett:
1. Lance Henriksen (VA)
 
Here’s Kelly Chambers:
2. Cara Pifko (VA)
 
Here’s EDI:
1. Tricia Helfer (VA)
 
Here’s Adm. Daro’Xen vas Moreh:
1. Claudia Black (VA + as Aethyta & Rachni-Allied Asari)
 
Here’s Adm. Han’Gerrel vas Neema:
1. Simon Templeman (VA)
 
Here’s Capt. Bailey:
1. Michael Hogan
 
Here’s Aria T’Loak:
1. Carrie Ann-Moss (VA)
 
Here’s Gatatog Uvenk:
1. Michael Dorn (VA)
 
Here’s Kal’Reegar:
1. Adam Baldwin (VA)
 
Here’s Adm. Shala’Raan vas Tombay:
1. Shohreh Agadeshloo (VA)
 
Here’s the Illusive Man:
1. Martin Sheen (VA) - 2. David Straithairn - 4. Bruce Greenwood
 
And here’s Harbinger:
1. Keith Szarabajka (VA + as Liliherax in ME 1, Delan, & Elias Kelham)

^ My preferred cast list based on kyle924's original. Seriously, Kyle why did you think Seth Green and Yvonne Strahovski would only be in VA for the roles of Joker and Miranda, especailly considering that the dev team purposely re-modelled the character of Miranda in ME2 based on Yvonne herself? I would have thought they would be dead certainties to fill those roles hands down. 

Also, has no-one yet considered the possibility of Jason Statham as Shepard?

[kyle924]

GuitarShredUK wrote...

kyle924 wrote...

All right, everyone.

The List has been refined - details are below.


The Refined List (ME 1 & 2 Characters)
 
MASS EFFECT
 
Here's John:
1. Christian Bale - 13. Matthew Fox - Mark Wahlberg - 34. Karl Urban - 47. Matt Damon - 
49. Chris O’Donnell - 55. Chris Pine - 57. Ewan McGregor - 58. 2. Josh Hartnett 

Here's Jane:
2. Milla Jovovich - 6. Scarlet Johansson - 8. Anne Wersching - 12. Famke Janssen - 
21. Jessica Alba - 23. Keira Knightley -

Here's Kaidan:
2. Milo Ventimiglia - 7. Benjamin Bratt - 14. Chris Pine - 15. Mark Ruffalo -
18. James Franco - 21. Eddie Cahill - 24. Gaspard Ulliel - 25. Charlie Clausen -
34. Joshua Jackson – 36. Patrick Dempsey

Here's Ashley: 
2. Erica Cerra - 3. Morena Baccarin - 5. Jessica Alba - 6. Mila Kunis -  
9. Michelle Rodriguez - 12. Odette Yustman - 20. Holly Marie Combs - 22. Natalie Martinez –
24. Kelly Overton - 25. Jordana Brewster

Here's Liara:
5. Jillian Murray - 9. Sophia Myles - 14. Emma Watson –
15. Zoe Saldana - 16. Zooey Desanchel - 18. Molly C. Quinn - 19. Jordana Brewster -
21. Alexa Davalos – 23. Summer Glau


Here's Garrus:
1. Brandon Keener (VA) - 2. Hugo Weavin 7. Michael Wincott - 19. Adam Baldwin – 20. Viggo Mortensen

Here's Tali:
1. Emma Watson - 2. Famke Janssen - 3. Milla Jovovich - 4. Liz Sroka (VA) -
5. Kristen Bell - 9. Charlize Theron - 10. Stana Katic - 11. Emily Deschanel -
12. Summer Glau – 16. Mila Kunis –

Here's Wrex:  
2. Steve Barr (VA) - 7. Kevin Grevioux - 8. Michael Clarke Duncan - 10. Ray Winstone -
13. Robert Wisdom

Here's Anderson:
1. Keith David (VA) - 3. Laurence Fishburne - 5. Denzel Washington - 6. Morgan Freeman -
10. Dennis Haysbert

Here's Udina:
1. Sidney Poitier - 7. Ruben Santiago-Hudson - 9. Andre Braugher - 10. Robert Wisdom -
15. Morgan Freeman

Here's Joker:
1. Seth Green (VA)

Here's Chakwas:
1. Helen Mirren - 2. Meryl Streep - 5. Carolyn Seymour (VA) - 6. Patricia Clarkson -
7. Kate Mulgrew

Here's Conrad:
4. Jason Segel - 5. Jeff Page (VA)

Here's Hackett:
1. Lance Henriksen (VA)
 
Here's Prestly:
1. Dwight Schultz (VA + as Dr. Zev Cohen)
 
Here’s Vigil:
1. David Shaughnessy (VA)

Here's Benezia:
2. Cate Blanchett - 3. Marina Sirtis (VA) - 4. Sigourney Weaver


Here's Saren:
1. Eric Bana - 2. Mark Strong - 3. Michael Wincott -
6. Fred Tatasciore (VA + as Balak & Warden Kuril in ME 2) -
13. Sean Bean

And here's Sovereign:
3. Peter Jessop (VA + as Lorik Qui’in) - 4. Bruce Spence - 5. Dee Bradley Baker
 
MASS EFFECT 2
 
Here’s Jacob Taylor:
2. Tyrese Gibson - 4. Will Smith - 5. Keith Robinson - 8. Jamie Foxx -
10. Michael Jai White
 
Here’s Miranda Lawson:
1. Yvonne Strahovski
 
Here’s Mordin Solus:
2. Wallace Langham - 3. David Tennant - 5. Michael Beattie (VA) - 6. Simon Pegg -
8. John Billingsley –
 
Here’s Grunt:
1. Tom Lister - 2. Steve Blum (VA + as Dr. Wilson)
 
 Here’s Jack:
1. Megan Fox - 3. Milla Jovovich - 4. Courtenay Taylor (VA) -
7. Keira Knightley
 
Here’s Thane:
1. Paul Bettany - 3. Keythe Farley (VA)
 
Here’s Samara:
1. Liv Tyler - 2. Sarah Clarke - 3. Sigourney Weaver - 4. Gillian Anderson -
9. Famke Janssen
 
Here’s Legion:
1. D.C. Douglas (VA)
 
Here’s Morinth:
1. Famke Janssen - 2. Liv Tyler - 3. Natalia Cigliuti (VA) - 4. Jolene Blalock -
5. Rhona Mitra
 
Here’s Zaeed:
1. Robin Sachs (VA)
 
Here’s Kasumi:
1. Michelle Rodriguez - 3. Jordana Brewster
 
Here’s Admiral Hackett:
1. Lance Henriksen (VA)
 
Here’s Kelly Chambers:
2. Cara Pifko (VA)
 
Here’s EDI:
1. Tricia Helfer (VA)
 
Here’s Adm. Daro’Xen vas Moreh:
1. Claudia Black (VA + as Aethyta & Rachni-Allied Asari)
 
Here’s Adm. Han’Gerrel vas Neema:
1. Simon Templeman (VA)
 
Here’s Capt. Bailey:
1. Michael Hogan
 
Here’s Aria T’Loak:
1. Carrie Ann-Moss (VA)
 
Here’s Gatatog Uvenk:
1. Michael Dorn (VA)
 
Here’s Kal’Reegar:
1. Adam Baldwin (VA)
 
Here’s Adm. Shala’Raan vas Tombay:
1. Shohreh Agadeshloo (VA)
 
Here’s the Illusive Man:
1. Martin Sheen (VA) - 2. David Straithairn - 4. Bruce Greenwood
 
And here’s Harbinger:
1. Keith Szarabajka (VA + as Liliherax in ME 1, Delan, & Elias Kelham)

^ My preferred cast list based on kyle924's original. Seriously, Kyle why did you think Seth Green and Yvonne Strahovski would only be in VA for the roles of Joker and Miranda, especailly considering that the dev team purposely re-modelled the character of Miranda in ME2 based on Yvonne herself? I would have thought they would be dead certainties to fill those roles hands down. 

Also, has no-one yet considered the possibility of Jason Statham as Shepard?

I thought Seth and Yvonne would be certainties for their VA roles for a live-action film of ME as well. Apparently, I was wrong.

And actually, Statham was considered as Shepard before, but not in this list.

Modifié par kyle924, 16 août 2010 - 01:12 .

[KlownSnypr]

I still think BW should just make it CG just like their theatrical trailer, it looked amazing and the energy and intensity were incredible.

[snfonseka]

KlownSnypr wrote...

I still think BW should just make it CG just like their theatrical trailer, it looked amazing and the energy and intensity were incredible.

<3 to see a CG movie of ME2.

[Hyper_gateway]

If it will be a CG movie, it will be more interesting since the factor that actor/actress may ruin the movie is gone. The reason I say that is unless the actor/actress really understand MS universe, otherwise there will be no connection between characters, story at all....



Lets just hope my concern is unnecessary.

[DIrishB]

NightAntilli wrote...

There should be no Shepard in any Mass Effect movie. They should not use the main game character as the main movie character. It will ruin the image of freedom and choice that the gamer has playing as Shepard. They should do it around someone else, like when Captain Anderson was young or something, or the first contact war, or one of the novels...

Seriously, a movie coming out based on a video game you like SHOULD HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO BEARING ON HOW MUCH YOU LIKE THE GAME AFTER THE MOVIE COMES OUT.  While the movie is based on the game, in the end they're two separate entities.  The movie could suck, but that doesn't mean all of a sudden the Mass Effect games will suck too.

And the whole "ITS MY SHEPARD" to the exclusion of the default Shep being included in spin-off media (which has NO BEARING ON THE CANON OF THE GAMES like the novels do) is just insane.  You can still have your version of Shepard in the game, and it shouldn't mean Bioware has to walk on eggshells when planning spin-off media featuring default Shep, just so as not to upset YOUR VERSION OF SHEPARD. 

I understand where you're coming from, but understand where Bioware as a company is coming from, and what they're trying to do with the IP THEY created.  This "ownership" thing all the fans have for their specific version of Shepard is one of the silliest debates I've ever stumbled upon. 

If they use a default Shep in a movie or other ME related product, it doesn't mean your Shep is now invalid.  If anything, it can be chalked up to an alternate universe, or some lame explanation like extensive plastic surgery (or sex change).

The establishment of a Default Shep in movies does not invalidate your choices or your Shep from the games in any way.  Why do people keep thinking it will?

[Supernova123]

First contact war.

Nuff said

[Daniel Dunlop]

Go on Mass Effect Wiki for a lot more details on the movie.

[Gnaeus.Silvanus]

I won't watch the movie if Seth Green is not casted as Joker!

[NightAntilli]

DIrishB wrote...

NightAntilli wrote...

There should be no Shepard in any Mass Effect movie. They should not use the main game character as the main movie character. It will ruin the image of freedom and choice that the gamer has playing as Shepard. They should do it around someone else, like when Captain Anderson was young or something, or the first contact war, or one of the novels...

Seriously, a movie coming out based on a video game you like SHOULD HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO BEARING ON HOW MUCH YOU LIKE THE GAME AFTER THE MOVIE COMES OUT.  While the movie is based on the game, in the end they're two separate entities.  The movie could suck, but that doesn't mean all of a sudden the Mass Effect games will suck too.

And the whole "ITS MY SHEPARD" to the exclusion of the default Shep being included in spin-off media (which has NO BEARING ON THE CANON OF THE GAMES like the novels do) is just insane.  You can still have your version of Shepard in the game, and it shouldn't mean Bioware has to walk on eggshells when planning spin-off media featuring default Shep, just so as not to upset YOUR VERSION OF SHEPARD. 

I understand where you're coming from, but understand where Bioware as a company is coming from, and what they're trying to do with the IP THEY created.  This "ownership" thing all the fans have for their specific version of Shepard is one of the silliest debates I've ever stumbled upon. 

If they use a default Shep in a movie or other ME related product, it doesn't mean your Shep is now invalid.  If anything, it can be chalked up to an alternate universe, or some lame explanation like extensive plastic surgery (or sex change).

The establishment of a Default Shep in movies does not invalidate your choices or your Shep from the games in any way.  Why do people keep thinking it will?

Ok. Should Shepard be male or female in the movie? Shepard is not a fixed character like Master Chief or Kratos or whatever. Not to mention if he's gonna be a paragon or a renegade in the movie. I love paragon Shepard, but if he's a pure renegade-like character in the movie, I simply won't feel connected. Also, they can't say anything concrete about him/her in the movie either, because you have chosen a past in the game. Which of the past stories is the Shepard gonna have in the movie? Or will they just leave that out completely? That will cause a lack of depth.

Really.. It's obvious, if you want a good movie, it should NOT be around Shepard as the main character. I'd like them to prove me wrong, but I just don't see it being a blockbuster this way..

Modifié par NightAntilli, 17 août 2010 - 03:10 .

[KlownSnypr]

I never got attached to my Shepard as much as some of the people on this forum but my Shepard is a default appearance with a spacer war hero paragon that occasionally slaps people around from time to time. I didn't particularly care for the default background as the sole survivor since it would seem to bring, to me anyway, pity rather than to inspire those around you that a "True" leader does.

It's all fine and dandy that there are people attached to "their" Shepard but technically it was BW's Shepard first and now they are making a movie about their game and they should do whatever they want with it within reason. Meaning that it doesn't suck and become a Star Wars ep 3 disaster. My take on all this is, as I previously stated as well as many others who have stated this, they should just make it CG. Capture that same energy from the theatrical trailer and apply it to the whole movie.

If they are going to make a movie about the game then we should give ideas along those lines like how far off the main story should the movie go? Obviously the main missions would be along in there but what about distractions like aiding the Consort, scanning keepers, helping Kahoku and fighting Cerberus? What elements of main missions should be left out because they were tedious in the game and would seem to be dull in a movie?

Modifié par KlownSnypr, 17 août 2010 - 01:27 .

[D4rkFire]

Michael C Hall from Dexter would make a great Commender Shepard

[Irrelevant Gamer]

My votes for Shepard: Mariska Hargitay, Denzel Washington or Gerard Butler. And if Seth Green is not Joker, I'm not going!

[DIrishB]

NightAntilli wrote...

Ok. Should Shepard be male or female in the movie? Shepard is not a fixed character like Master Chief or Kratos or whatever. Not to mention if he's gonna be a paragon or a renegade in the movie. I love paragon Shepard, but if he's a pure renegade-like character in the movie, I simply won't feel connected. Also, they can't say anything concrete about him/her in the movie either, because you have chosen a past in the game. Which of the past stories is the Shepard gonna have in the movie? Or will they just leave that out completely? That will cause a lack of depth.

Really.. It's obvious, if you want a good movie, it should NOT be around Shepard as the main character. I'd like them to prove me wrong, but I just don't see it being a blockbuster this way..

Honestly, I would love to see either a male or female Shepard in the movie, but lets be honest, it'll be male. Is that fair? No, but it is that way for a reason: despite the large number of women who play Bioware games (arguably a higher percentage than most other game companies fanbase) is still a smaller amount than the stereotypical video game player: males between the ages of 15-30.

So, to go with the male version of Shep seems like the not so obvious choice, but there it is. As for his look? Easy: the default male Shep from the covers of the games. Granted, the actor won't look exactly like this, but a close enough casting would work for me.

In terms of personality, it'll probably be mostly a Paragon Shep, with some minor Renegade elements when necessary.

Now, the result might be different than your version of Shepard, but thats ok, because its not YOUR version of Shepard, its Bioware's. And again, if a default movie version is different than yours, your version still counts and exists in its own game universe. Bioware's exists within the movie universe.

You know, the same way my Shepard and your Shepard and everyone else's Shepard is different, yet it still works. Why can't people accept a default Shep for spin-off media that has no bearing on the canonicity of the games (which this movie probably will be) in the same manner? It makes no sense to me. I love my Shepard, but an actor playing the role with a different look or gender than the Shep in my game isn't going to make me feel "less connected" to my game character. Thats just silly, I'm sorry.

Now, if Bioware made Mass Effect 3 with a default Shep and no ability to customize or import our characters and decisions from Mass Effect 1 and 2 into that game, I'd completely agree with you. But thats now what this is, its a movie based on those games, which almost certainly will feature the main hero/protagonist of those games in a role played by an actor who is limited to only one look and gender. Reality sucks sometimes, but thats no reason to ignore it.

(Sorry if I come off as a bit testy in my post, it wasn't intended, I just don't agree with fans telling creators what can or can't be done with their characters and intellectual properties.)

KlownSnypr wrote...

It's all fine and dandy that there are people attached to "their" Shepard but technically it was BW's Shepard first and now they are making a movie about their game and they should do whatever they want with it within reason. Meaning that it doesn't suck and become a Star Wars ep 3 disaster.

Exactly.

Modifié par DIrishB, 17 août 2010 - 07:27 .

[Mehow_pwn]

Finally some good news.. lets hope the bioware will do this right

[OneDrunkMonk]

I'd like to vote Jeri Ryan as Samara. Also Milla Jovovich shouldn't be allowed anywhere near Mass Effect.

Really though, as much as a live action Mass Effect would be cool I think a CG movie would be better. Why? Because with a live action Mass Effect your bound to disappoint those who are accustomed to seeing and hearing the Mass Effect characters as originally presented. That and the fact that Hollywood rarely casts appropriate people for big roles like this, rather they go for whatever they believe will draw all the tweens with disposable income. Take the Kasumi Goto character, I can't imagine another actor being able to capture the essence of the character as well as Kym Lane voiced her.

Modifié par OneDrunkMonk, 17 août 2010 - 11:59 .

[Uninvited Geth]

Seems like a step back, really. I don't want to watch ME, I want to be interactively immersed in it.

[MustangManiac]

ArmyofEffect3 wrote...

If Bruce Willis plays Shepard, I will facepalm.

If the movie does end up going along with the games, and Bruce Willis acctually does end up playing Shepard, you know sh*t is gonna go down. He almost always gets messed-up in his movies. Not to mention sends them out with a big band. Look at Die Hard!                  -Plane takes off with fuel leak. McClane lights zippo, "Yippy-Ky-Yay, Motherf*ckr,"     tosses zippo at fuel leak, giant explotion- (Die Hard 2)

[MustangManiac]

KlownSnypr wrote...

I still think BW should just make it CG just like their theatrical trailer, it looked amazing and the energy and intensity were incredible.

Not a bad idea at all. That and a fast-paced but in-depth movie about something other that the main storyline (ex. novel "Mass Effect: Revolation") and you've got something that only James Cameron could do better than.

One little side is to have EVERYONE from the Mass Effect team possible to work on this unless they're working on ME3.

Bioware, you're the only people that can beat bungie at storyline and action at the same time

[Sgt Lindog]

follow mass effect revelation, it would be perfect for drawing people into the mass effect franchise without pissing off any of their die hard fans

if it is to follow the game then im all for CG

[SumoMau]

Colin Farrell as Shepard !

[Leoism]

Late post but, my god i've been waiting for a ME movie since the first time i ever played the game, i just hope it lives upto expectation there's alot of fans wanting alot of different things but at the end of the day this is BW's version of shepard everyone must realise and respect this fact. Whatever happens for this version is their own "playthrough" version noone else's in particular. Good luck bioware/Legendary Pictures, Do us proud!

[Zeratul20]

Legendary Pictures? I can live with that.



Still. It's a movie based on a video game. The odds are against us.

[Ferocious7]

They need Spielberg and/or to make it CG like that trailer with Jack talking.

Also, Ashley could also be played by Eva Mendes just as well as a few others listed.

No one other than Seth Green should be playing Joker as well as Martin Sheen playing The Illusive Man, they both did their parts so damn well.

Modifié par Ferocious7, 18 août 2010 - 02:42 .

[E-MailA.K.A.Mr.Fox]

Matthew Fox could make a good Shepard, hell hes already played a great Sheperd who leads a group of people.....