Lemonwizard wrote...
Come on now, now you're just ignoring me.
If it wasn't a bunch of people making jokes I would put it on the list. I just don't want hate threads listed (even if you intended it otherwise when you started it).
Comprehensive List of Squadmate Support Threads
Iniziato da
NICKjnp
, mag 28 2010 01:31
#26
Inviato il 30 maggio 2010 - 09:12
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
If it wasn't a bunch of people making jokes I would put it on the list. I just don't want hate threads listed (even if you intended it otherwise when you started it).
Torna su
#27
Inviato il 30 maggio 2010 - 09:46
Lemonwizard
-
- Members
- 1748 Messaggi:
It was that for the first two pages but the novelty is fading for those posters and we're actually being serious now.
.....Do not force me to use my more unpleasant tactics of persuasion.
.....Do not force me to use my more unpleasant tactics of persuasion.
#28
Inviato il 30 maggio 2010 - 09:52
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Lemonwizard wrote...
It was that for the first two pages but the novelty is fading for those posters and we're actually being serious now.
.....Do not force me to use my more unpleasant tactics of persuasion.
I'll check it tomorrow morning. If it is better at that time then I will put it on the list.
Modificata da NICKjnp, 30 maggio 2010 - 09:53 .
#29
Guest_justinnstuff_*
Inviato il 01 giugno 2010 - 06:54
Guest_justinnstuff_*
Guest_justinnstuff_*
-
- Guests
Sand King wrote...
lmao!
#30
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 12:09
Lemonwizard
-
- Members
- 1748 Messaggi:
Really? Seriously? What has Udina got that the Turian Councilor hasn't? Why is it so hard to believe that there's people who actually LIKE the character?
#31
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 12:38
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Lemonwizard wrote...
Really? Seriously? What has Udina got that the Turian Councilor hasn't? Why is it so hard to believe that there's people who actually LIKE the character?
There was an actual discussion going on. The discussion I read in the turian councilor thread was something like "why doesn't isn't the turian councilor thread listed" and "there really are turian councilor fans." Get more posts about actual things related to the Turian Councilor and I'll put it up.
#32
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 12:44
Lemonwizard
-
- Members
- 1748 Messaggi:
Every post in the thread in the last 2 days except for one is serious discussion. It's a slow moving thread, but I'm not certain what more you request.
#33
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 12:48
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Lemonwizard wrote...
Every post in the thread in the last 2 days except for one is serious discussion. It's a slow moving thread, but I'm not certain what more you request.
We'll make a compromise. You change the name to Turian Councilor (because we don't know if his name is Velarn) as well as make sure people are having a discussion about the Turian Councilor (not just saying we need more fans) and I'll post it. As an act of good faith I'll post it now (but I'm trying to monitor my thread so... keep it an official thread).
#34
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 01:43
Lemonwizard
-
- Members
- 1748 Messaggi:
I think making sure people are having real discussion and calling out those who are just posting "Ah yes, X..." to keep the thread on topic and serious is an excellent idea.
However, I'd prefer not to change the topic's name for a number of reasons. Sure, one reason is because it's part of my secret campaign to get Bioware to pick that name for him, which is not super serious, but I'd also like to point out that very few fan threads actually have just "(Character name) fan thread" as their title. That Tali thread has "official migrant fleet" or the previously mentioned Udina thread has "THIS IS AN OUTRAGE". I like a more flavorful and personal title, but would express my concern that most of the options I could use such as "Ah yes, Turian councilor fans..." or something of that nature would just serve to invite more joke posters. I don't think it really harms the thread.
However, I'd prefer not to change the topic's name for a number of reasons. Sure, one reason is because it's part of my secret campaign to get Bioware to pick that name for him, which is not super serious, but I'd also like to point out that very few fan threads actually have just "(Character name) fan thread" as their title. That Tali thread has "official migrant fleet" or the previously mentioned Udina thread has "THIS IS AN OUTRAGE". I like a more flavorful and personal title, but would express my concern that most of the options I could use such as "Ah yes, Turian councilor fans..." or something of that nature would just serve to invite more joke posters. I don't think it really harms the thread.
#35
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 01:46
Pacifien
-
- Members
- 11527 Messaggi:
You don't get to make demands of the Turian Councilor thread!
It's like the Jacob thread, sometimes it's really really hard to resist the inanity of it.
It's like the Jacob thread, sometimes it's really really hard to resist the inanity of it.
#36
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 03:54
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Lemonwizard wrote...
I think making sure people are having real discussion and calling out those who are just posting "Ah yes, X..." to keep the thread on topic and serious is an excellent idea.
However, I'd prefer not to change the topic's name for a number of reasons. Sure, one reason is because it's part of my secret campaign to get Bioware to pick that name for him, which is not super serious, but I'd also like to point out that very few fan threads actually have just "(Character name) fan thread" as their title. That Tali thread has "official migrant fleet" or the previously mentioned Udina thread has "THIS IS AN OUTRAGE". I like a more flavorful and personal title, but would express my concern that most of the options I could use such as "Ah yes, Turian councilor fans..." or something of that nature would just serve to invite more joke posters. I don't think it really harms the thread.
I can remove it.
#37
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:08
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Pacifien wrote...
You don't get to make demands of the Turian Councilor thread!
It's like the Jacob thread, sometimes it's really really hard to resist the inanity of it.
Actually the Turian Councilor thread doesn't get to make demands of me. I'm the (all human) council in here. The others have to follow my lead.
#38
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:24
AM50
-
- Members
- 597 Messaggi:
Oh noes! My thread has been replaced! Alas, I am undone.
#39
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:26
AM50
-
- Members
- 597 Messaggi:
Hey since you stole my thread idea. 
Please use my thread for all the links, groups, and sigbars you can imagine.
Just reference me as the creator!
social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/128/index/1257202/1
Please use my thread for all the links, groups, and sigbars you can imagine.
Just reference me as the creator!
social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/128/index/1257202/1
#40
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:27
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
AM50 wrote...
Oh noes! My thread has been replaced! Alas, I am undone.
It didn't make the great southern migration. List any squadmates and links I missed and I'll put them in the first post.
#41
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:29
AM50
-
- Members
- 597 Messaggi:
NICKjnp wrote...
AM50 wrote...
Oh noes! My thread has been replaced! Alas, I am undone.
It didn't make the great southern migration. List any squadmates and links I missed and I'll put them in the first post.
No harm man. I am getting ready to leave for the Air Force so I am glad you are fulfilling my duty. There are a ton of links if you check the link I posted. And sigbars too!
#42
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:31
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
AM50 wrote...
NICKjnp wrote...
AM50 wrote...
Oh noes! My thread has been replaced! Alas, I am undone.
It didn't make the great southern migration. List any squadmates and links I missed and I'll put them in the first post.
No harm man. I am getting ready to leave for the Air Force so I am glad you are fulfilling my duty. There are a ton of links if you check the link I posted. And sigbars too!
Your links go to the old subforum anywase. I'm not putting any links in mine until they are moved to the new subforum (except for Morinth... because I'm her biggest fan... and I like Expel 10).
#43
Inviato il 02 giugno 2010 - 04:35
AM50
-
- Members
- 597 Messaggi:
NICKjnp wrote...
AM50 wrote...
NICKjnp wrote...
AM50 wrote...
Oh noes! My thread has been replaced! Alas, I am undone.
It didn't make the great southern migration. List any squadmates and links I missed and I'll put them in the first post.
No harm man. I am getting ready to leave for the Air Force so I am glad you are fulfilling my duty. There are a ton of links if you check the link I posted. And sigbars too!
Your links go to the old subforum anywase. I'm not putting any links in mine until they are moved to the new subforum (except for Morinth... because I'm her biggest fan... and I like Expel 10).
Alas, you have a valuable point. Well, I wish you the best in your thread creating. Feel free to use any sig bars or groups listed there as well!
Happy Hunting!
#44
Guest_LuckyIronAxe_*
Inviato il 03 giugno 2010 - 05:14
Guest_LuckyIronAxe_*
Guest_LuckyIronAxe_*
-
- Guests
OP, your link jumps to the 4th page of the Udina thread, could you possibly fix it to jump to the 1st page?
#45
Inviato il 03 giugno 2010 - 05:20
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
LuckyIronAxe wrote...
OP, your link jumps to the 4th page of the Udina thread, could you possibly fix it to jump to the 1st page?
fixed
#46
Inviato il 03 giugno 2010 - 06:50
Lemonwizard
-
- Members
- 1748 Messaggi:
With respect, sir, while I am fully aware that I am a sarcastic **** who has nothing if not a reputation for nonsensical posting, I feel I've adequately demonstrated my intents and done my best to steer the thread to more serious discussion. I can understand your distaste for me, but imposing arbitrary standards like not having a title that's good enough for you frankly strikes me as petty. If another fan thread for the Turian Councilor existed that proved to be a better place for serious discussion, I gladly would encourage any posters in mine to abandon it for there.
However, there does not. I would ask you to find another fan thread on this forum that doesn't have a significant share of off-topic or joke posts in it, and I doubt you'd be able to accomplish such a task. I freely admit the Councilor Velarn thread has a higher proportion than it should, but that is simply because many people originally misunderstood my intentions. I simply would like to be included, there is little more to say.
At this point, though, it's become clear to me that arguing the point with you further is not going to bear any additional results, so with this post I am no longer going to continue wasting my time on the subject.
Before I go, however, a helpful bit of advice: If you want to get the Morinth thread (or anything else that got missed) moved over here, just send a PM to Chris Priestly and he should take care of it for you. He was quite courteous with me.
However, there does not. I would ask you to find another fan thread on this forum that doesn't have a significant share of off-topic or joke posts in it, and I doubt you'd be able to accomplish such a task. I freely admit the Councilor Velarn thread has a higher proportion than it should, but that is simply because many people originally misunderstood my intentions. I simply would like to be included, there is little more to say.
At this point, though, it's become clear to me that arguing the point with you further is not going to bear any additional results, so with this post I am no longer going to continue wasting my time on the subject.
Before I go, however, a helpful bit of advice: If you want to get the Morinth thread (or anything else that got missed) moved over here, just send a PM to Chris Priestly and he should take care of it for you. He was quite courteous with me.
#47
Inviato il 03 giugno 2010 - 02:17
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Lemonwizard wrote...
With respect, sir, while I am fully aware that I am a sarcastic **** who has nothing if not a reputation for nonsensical posting, I feel I've adequately demonstrated my intents and done my best to steer the thread to more serious discussion. I can understand your distaste for me, but imposing arbitrary standards like not having a title that's good enough for you frankly strikes me as petty. If another fan thread for the Turian Councilor existed that proved to be a better place for serious discussion, I gladly would encourage any posters in mine to abandon it for there.
However, there does not. I would ask you to find another fan thread on this forum that doesn't have a significant share of off-topic or joke posts in it, and I doubt you'd be able to accomplish such a task. I freely admit the Councilor Velarn thread has a higher proportion than it should, but that is simply because many people originally misunderstood my intentions. I simply would like to be included, there is little more to say.
At this point, though, it's become clear to me that arguing the point with you further is not going to bear any additional results, so with this post I am no longer going to continue wasting my time on the subject.
Before I go, however, a helpful bit of advice: If you want to get the Morinth thread (or anything else that got missed) moved over here, just send a PM to Chris Priestly and he should take care of it for you. He was quite courteous with me.
"Velarn" is not his name. It could very well be the name of the Salarian councilor. If you want me to add it to the list then simply remove that part from the thread name.
#48
Inviato il 03 giugno 2010 - 03:42
Pacifien
-
- Members
- 11527 Messaggi:
Aside from requiring the thread be in the correct forum, what's your criteria for adding a character support thread to the list? For instance, AM50's list included links to the Biotic God and Blasto.
#49
Inviato il 03 giugno 2010 - 03:48
NICKjnp
-
- Members
- 5048 Messaggi:
Pacifien wrote...
Aside from requiring the thread be in the correct forum, what's your criteria for adding a character support thread to the list? For instance, AM50's list included links to the Biotic God and Blasto.
As long as it isn't a joke thread. Post links to it as long as it isn't a joke thread that is... well... there to make fun of a character. I would put the Turian Councilor thread in here if the guy would remove Velarn from the name. The fact is that we don't know if that was his name. Velarn could easily be the name of the Salarian Councilor.
#50
Inviato il 05 giugno 2010 - 12:38
Lambda Faction
-
- Members
- 110 Messaggi:
Not sure if you want to post the link, as I just requested the thread be moved.
I run both the original Illusive Man Group + Thread. Not much discussion as of late due to thread regulars having things going on in life, however I try to keep it up when I can since I just finished college finals myself. Thread is a mix of discussion/joking/"support". Can be moved in a more serious/discussion direction if need be and if people would like to post (to be listed.) Will probably need to work on the original post of the thread to make it more discussion based vs. support based.
I run both the original Illusive Man Group + Thread. Not much discussion as of late due to thread regulars having things going on in life, however I try to keep it up when I can since I just finished college finals myself. Thread is a mix of discussion/joking/"support". Can be moved in a more serious/discussion direction if need be and if people would like to post (to be listed.) Will probably need to work on the original post of the thread to make it more discussion based vs. support based.
Modificata da Lambda Faction, 05 giugno 2010 - 12:54 .
