328 réponses à ce sujet

[Mykel54]

Not killing the batarians in Mordin recruitment mission. My shepard just hate them, specially the ones that act like terrorists (memories of balak i guess). Didn´t even help the wounded batarian, instead took the money from his datapad.

[mosor]

I never had a problem appointing Udina councillor. Udina is a take no crap kind of guy, who makes no time for anti-human protesters and applauds the N7 marine strike on a batarian solar array factory as an example of human decisiveness. Haha that an some turian diplomat says he's a diplomatic incident waiting to happen. That made me laugh.

I have no problem sparring Morinth as a renegade because Samara is pretty likely to attack me when all is said and done.

There are only a couple choices that make me feel queezy. One is betraying Tali on her loyalty mission, and encouraging Jack to murder Aresh. I always seem to help those injured salarians on thane's recruitment.

Modifié par mosor, 01 juin 2010 - 05:00 .

[AntiChri5]

I have a "just so i did it" Shepard for those decisions i just cant force myself to make wih a serious character. He is the only one who:



Killed Wrex.

Put Udina in charge.

Saved Morinth.

Saved the Collector Base.

[spacehamsterZH]

I'm gonna go ahead and agree with the OP on the Shiala thing. I did it in my last ME1 playthrough because I just wanted to see what happens, and it left a foul taste in my mouth. It's just so obvious from her dialogue that it's a bad idea to kill her, and the way Shepard does it - it's pretty much a cold-blooded execution, and Shiala just lets him do it - is seven shades of wrong too. Eeek. Never doing that again.

[Christmas Ape]

...what's the big deal with making Udina the human Councilor? He's got our best interests in mind, he's a competent politician - even if he is a scumbag - and I just can't do that to Anderson.

[KOKitten]

ME1

- Kill the Rachni queen. My Paragons would consider it to be genocide and my Renegades consider her to be a potential ally.

- Kill Wrex. Wrex is just too awesome and there's just no way I'm going to kill him.



ME2

- Sell Legion to Cerberus. If I sell him to Cerberus I don't get the opportunity to talk to him and use him in my squad.

- Romance Tali. She's too young for the way I play my Shepards.



Anything else is fair game.

[nhsk]

Christmas Ape wrote...

...what's the big deal with making Udina the human Councilor? He's got our best interests in mind, he's a competent politician - even if he is a scumbag - and I just can't do that to Anderson.

I think its more screwing over Udina than do that to Anderson, at least for my part.

The same as telling Miranda that Veetor goes with Tali, even on my renegade ^^

[CalJones]

I always do enough to have everyone loyal at the end. Even my most renegade Sheps are good to their crew. Some of my Sheps are ruthless, but none of them are jerks.



I always help Conrad Verner, even if he is a big pillock. (I might shoot him in the foot first, mind you...)

I always get the asari girl to take back her krogan boyfriend, Char.

I have both blown up and kept the Collector base but I actually feel worse about destroying it, despite that being the more renegade option. I also have a hard time not helping Zaeed to kill Vido, after hearing his speech about how he sees Vido's face every time he goes to sleep. The guy needs his payback.

I can't, absolutely can't, get Harrot to shut down Kenn. I see no logic to it, at all. I always help Kenn instead (and as a renegade that's no problem, as the paragon option is pretty renegade anyway).

[inversevideo]

CalJones wrote...

I always do enough to have everyone loyal at the end. Even my most renegade Sheps are good to their crew. Some of my Sheps are ruthless, but none of them are jerks.

I always help Conrad Verner, even if he is a big pillock. (I might shoot him in the foot first, mind you...)
I always get the asari girl to take back her krogan boyfriend, Char.
I have both blown up and kept the Collector base but I actually feel worse about destroying it, despite that being the more renegade option. I also have a hard time not helping Zaeed to kill Vido, after hearing his speech about how he sees Vido's face every time he goes to sleep. The guy needs his payback.
I can't, absolutely can't, get Harrot to shut down Kenn. I see no logic to it, at all. I always help Kenn instead (and as a renegade that's no problem, as the paragon option is pretty renegade anyway).

Conrad .. agreed!

Char, I cannot do this anymore. I did it once, then found out they end up on that radioactive bombed out Tuchanka, where they hate aliens. From over hearing their conversation, on Tuchanka, she is miserable and worried.
Ever since then, I break them up.


Lately, my renegon has also killed Vido.

Always get Harrot to shut down Kenn. When you talk to Harrot, you convince him to pay off Kenn. Harrot never thought to do that before, because on Omeaga, merchants don't accept such offers. Harrot takes your advice, he does not harm Kenn, he buys him out completely, thus providing Kenn with enough money to leave Omega. 

[EricHVela]

Shepard VI: DO WANT!

I always pick that option. Sorry. (Too bad the VI's not actually in the game.)

[mosor]

CalJones wrote...

I can't, absolutely can't, get Harrot to shut down Kenn. I see no logic to it, at all. I always help Kenn instead (and as a renegade that's no problem, as the paragon option is pretty renegade anyway).

Why? Harrot buys out Kenn. Presumably that gives Kenn enough money to go home.

[CC-Tron]

nhsk wrote...

CC-Tron wrote...

nhsk wrote...

CC-Tron wrote...

nhsk wrote...

ME1 - Kill Shiala, there is just no reason to do so as she doesn't fight back - Killing her it just outright stupid and borderline criminal.
ME2 - Let the Eclipse merc go in Thane's recruitment mission - He just partipated in the gunning down unarmed civilians, no way he is going to get away.

ME1 - There was good reason to kill Shiala even if it was optional. Her crime was beyond borderline criminal. She's not being judged on whether she fights back or not. She aided Saren before she was indoctrinated by the Thorian. She explains her reasons but there is enough cause not to trust her. Shephard being a spectre can deal out death as punishment for aiding Saren in the downfall of all organic life. If Shephard is ruthless then there is no acceptable excuse and the punishment for such grand treason is death. She even willingly accepts her death sentence because she knows she deserves it.

- Rana Thanoptis derserved death also for the same reason.

ME2 - The Eclipse merc commited a lesser crime than Shiala IMO but he too was deserving of death even if it was optional. The only unarmed civilians I saw gunned down were by mechs on the order of Nasana. He was killed because he may have been a threat to Shephard later (and for not cooperating).

Oh and before that she was indoctrinated by Sovereign?

She was indoctrinated by Sovereign AFTER boarding that ship of her own free will and for no good intention. Just like Saren and Benezia.

She followed Benezia aboard Sovereign, neither knowing of the indoctrination, to lead Saren to a rightful path.

I fail to see the evil intentions here.

OK....So Benezia's plan was to board a Reaper to try to change Saren from his evil ways? Her foolishness cost her life. Shiala is deserving of that same fate. Why?

If Shiala was indoctrinated once, she could easily be contolled by evil again. Much like Benezia and Saren. How many times did Benezia relapse into being evil? Benezia wasn't even any where near Sovereign when she had her relapses on Noveria (It could happen on Feros as well). It comes down to whether or not Shepard should risk believing her or not.

A ruthless Shephard would be justified in not trusting Shiala given what is known about the indoctrination. The potential for future evil is there and foolishness does not excuse it.  Heavy risk leaving her behind. Again, Shiala willingly accepts her death sentence because it is justified.

[Cra5y Pineapple]

Definately deciding between killing or overiding the heretic geth. I eventually just agreed with the majority of Legion's programs and choose to overide them.

[Kenshen]

DrathanGervaise wrote...

Lemonwizard wrote...

Dark_Caduceus wrote...

...Marvin?

You disappoint me.

Vincent: Whoa!
Jules: What the f*ck's happening, man? Ah, sh!t, man!
Vincent Oh man, I shot Marvin in the face.
Jules : Why the f*ck did you do that?!
Vincent Well, I didn't mean to do it, it was an accident!
Jules: Oh man, I've seen some crazy-ass sh!t in my time...

Also, I can't not kill Sgt. Cathka.

5 Renegade points on my Paragon player is totally worth not dying on Insanity.

Ya know when I first saw the name Marvin it didn't come to me but once I saw this line  "Jules drives the car over that bump" that whole part came flooding back.  A great movie for sure.

[Jedi Master of Orion]

I tend not to be very interested in human nationalist/space racist dialogue options. Even for a renegade character. The most I've done so far is to speak somewhat agressively about humanity earning a place in the Citadel to Kaiden and then agree with him about aliens being essentially the same as us, I also never killed Wrex so far, I considered doing it once or twice, but just felt it was worth keeping him around.

Modifié par Jedi Master of Orion, 01 juin 2010 - 09:16 .

[CalJones]

Hmm that's interesting about Kenn - I always thought that Harrot shutting him down would leave him penniless and stranded. That's definitely not the case, then?

[SnakeStrike8]

I can never bring myself to side with Samara over Morinth.

Samara's sworn to your service, she's done nothing at all as yet to injure/hinder/betray me, and Morinth just tried to mindrape me.

I can never see the justification for picking Samara over Morinth other than 'It's the renedage option'. Even my primarily Renegade characters see no sense in doing that.

[CalJones]

Likewise. I did side with Morinth briefly to get her power, then reloaded. (I also did have one chat with her on the Normandy but I didn't like her really - she's not very likeable). Killing Samara is something an evil character, rather than a renegade, would do.

[Rzepik2]

- I can't do anything against Tali.

- I'm ALWAYS blowing up the Geth base.

- .... and of course I'm headbutting Uvenk.every time. We have to respect local traditions.

[Zack56]

I can't hurt Tali. period. The one time I did just to see what would happen in a renagade run, I physically felt sick for the rest of the day.



I can't let Harrot take over Kenn's shop.



I can't NOT shoot Verner in the foot.



Everything else is fair game. Some other things might bother me but these will make me physically ill if I do them.

[Cra5y Pineapple]

Zack56 wrote...

I can't hurt Tali. period. The one time I did just to see what would happen in a renagade run, I physically felt sick for the rest of the day.

Do you me emotionaly? I don't remember the regenade pop-up for *punch Tali* XD
No but really she's one of my favourite characters. I agree. Tali, along with Garrus and Legion, are all characters I find difficult to be mean to.

I will always do regenade Pop-ups because 10/10 times they're funny as hell.

Modifié par Cra5y Pineapple, 01 juin 2010 - 10:00 .

[DPSSOC]

I can't give Veetor to Cerberus, anything else is fair game but that's the one thing I can't do. Ok I also can't romance Tali, and I've tried, just can't bring myself to do it.

[Xenon]

 Things I've never brought myself to do:

-Side with Jack in the catfight
-Get Shepard killed
-Get Miranda killed
-Have Morinth survive (Twice I chose her over Samara, and twice she was killed in the suicide mission, both intentionally)
-Expose Tali's father at the trail. Only once did the trail end with exile.
I've completed basically every other possible choice, at least that I can remember.

[Aggie Punbot]

SnakeStrike8 wrote...

I can never bring myself to side with Samara over Morinth.
*snip*
I can never see the justification for picking Samara over Morinth other than 'It's the renedage option'. Even my primarily Renegade characters see no sense in doing that.

Do you mean you can't bring yourself to side with Morinth over Samara?

[Dean_the_Young]

Funily enough, I can't bring myself to do the reverse: I can't side with Samara over Morinth, even if I am a Paragon: Samara's too code bound, and anything I do (paragon or not) that conflicts with that code will eventually lead her to have to get me, one of these days.



Plus, she kills more people than Morinth anyway, so in terms of numbers I'm giving the galaxy a better deal.