jtav wrote...
Iedra and I are going to argue about interspecies romance forever, aren't we? My attitude is that it's already canon, so who am I to complain or worry about it overmuch when writing? The game is full of complete nonsense anyway. It's a bit like complaining about ER's lack of medical accuracy.
It's not only that it's complete nonsense. That's bad enough, but for me, the main appeal of SF has always been that it can show how strange the universe is if you leave the perspective of the average human mind behind. It can challenge you to adjust your perspective, for distances are almost incomprehensible, realistic time frames for all sorts of activities are measured in decades, centuries or even millenia, and biology is comprehensible to a scientist, but otherwise highly variable, indicating that, for instance, the value systems we build our societies on are by no means universal. SF brings home to you all those uncomfortable facts we humans tend to ignore in our everyday life. Now, what the creators of the ME universe did is exactly the opposite: they introduced technologies that contract and fix time so that travelling to another star system is like travelling to a neighboring city today, and set up biology in a way that our preconceived notions of both romance and ethics apply cross-species (with the exception of the geth). It goes so far that Tali refers to herself as a woman in one romance conversation. Well, she's no woman. She's a female quarian. For me, things like this reduce the appeal of the ME universe considerably.
From that viewpoint: what I would have liked to see is an interspecies romance that is actually a challenge to the human perspective, with an alien who's recognizably non-human in both mindset and appearance, so that a romance is not just a matter of "dem hips" or suchlike, but attraction needs to find another carrier. Or a romance where you're going to be surprised in a rather unpleasant way, for instance if the "asari mind control" hypothesis turned out to be true, and in reality the asari looked really strange. OK, that would create a whole bag of other plausbility problems, but you get the idea...
(Yeah, it seems we're going to argue about this forever

)
Modifié par Ieldra2, 20 juillet 2010 - 02:13 .