You don't have to be anti-alien to be pro-human, this "us against them" philosophy is
very ultra-nationalist. Humanity, for all of its strengths, didn't find world peace before making contact with other alien civilizations. It was only when humanity realized that there were other races with even more differences than the other human cultures they've been fighting for millenia did they put their troubles aside and form the Systems Alliance. Figure after you dominate every other race out there (either militarily or economically), then what? Go back to fighting each other again? Because that's what fits the pattern.
Miranda wants what is best for humanity because she can identify with that, having been designed to be "the perfect woman." That doesn't equate to fear or mistrust or dislike of the other races - quite the contrary:
"We'd be lucky to have you, too many join Cerberus out of simple xenophobia."
She sees other races as something to aspire to, good competition, something to overcome largely through humanity's own means. She envies Mordin and his time with the STG, she finds asari culture beautiful, and on Omega she finds disgust with all the races living there - not just batarians and vorcha. And it isn't as if she agrees with everything Cerberus does (something
many fans grossly overlook): Jack and the Teltin facility, breaking Cerberus protocol to help Jacob with his father, the Collector Base, etc. If she didn't disagree she never would've left Cerberus at all and Liara probably wouldn't have remarked on how much Miranda had changed. I was a bit dissapointed in BW that they didn't follow up on Miranda's feelings about TIM trapping Shepard and the team on the Collector ship. She was very vocal that TIM wouldn't do that to them, I'm curious if she would've approved or not after hearing TIM's confession or would've felt it more as a betrayal.
And for those of you who don't understand what nationalism or ultra-nationialism are here's the
wiki page which has both definitions as well as some other definitions of ultra-nationialism:
dictionary-online,
dictionary.com,
answers.com, a few well thought out
essays on ultra-nationialism and you start to get the idea. So pick your poison.
Modifié par aeetos21, 07 février 2011 - 04:55 .