Aller au contenu

Photo

Remains - rewrite


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
13 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages
This short story is companion to Ichor and Run.

Recently rewritten in the middle to reflect feedback.


Remains

 

People think, because I don’t speak much, that I have nothing to say.  People think that silence means simple. I am neither simple nor have nothing to say, I just care not to speak.

When they first brought the Qunari warrior into the tower, he didn’t speak much either. Found prone on the banks of Lake Calenhad, the healers were at a loss for how to help him. His physical injuries were only slight but he seemed unable to even support his own weight. Though they explored every hair on his strange body and discussed the problem late into the night, the Qunari’s condition remained the same.

I was asked to bring him books from the library. It didn’t help.

“Jerron. Bring the Qunari a book.”

“Jerron. Try some Ferelden history this time or perhaps a story.”

“Jerron. Read aloud to the Qunari. Can you manage that?”

After a time, the healers visited the Qunari less frequently and I was his foremost carer. Given his apparent disinterest in his surroundings and treatment, I was able to make detailed drawings of his anatomy for the Tower’s records. After more time had passed, he became aware of my ministrations, if still not the books piled next to his bed.

The first words he spoke were to me. “Do you feel shame?”

I don’t feel anything. “No.”

 

People think, because of what I am, that I must have been weak. People think I would have become an abomination.  Perhaps I would never have been a Great Mage, whispered awe following me along hallways, but I
know I had sufficient power to wield magic. I would have been no abomination.

Often, it is Ellin who finds books for me to take to the Qunari. She meets my gaze now.

“Hi Jerron. Do you think our visitor would like this book about crafting herbal poultices?”

“You look well, Jerron. Has the Qunari taken to reading yet?”

“Jerron! What a beautiful day it is outside. Care to accompany me finding herbs for our visitor?”

There was a time when Ellin would avoid my eye as well as me entirely. The power of my youthful adoration her made her uneasy. As the brightest, and most beautiful, apprentice she commanded the young men as easily as she commanded magic.

I must, I must keep this fire burning. Two, no three apprentices have given up. I can join them and rest. No I mustn’t. Ellin’s fire still burns and so does Nate’s. She is looking at him again. Why is she looking at him?

So tired. I can’t stay awake.

I know how to forget my fatigue. My herbal knife. Aaargh. The pain. The pain is all I know. The pain. And yet, my fire burns.

Ellin is looking at me. Her fire is extinguished and I have won the trial of endurance. I am weak.


I remember the pride I felt as she looked at me, astonished and impressed, how they all looked at me, even as I know I will never feel pride again.  When the First Enchanter discovered the cuts on my arms I knew I would be in trouble. I didn’t know that the trouble would be the Rite of Tranquility.

“You will be late for your meeting with Enchanter Matthias, Ellin.” His interest in Ellin is more than for her duties as a Circle Mage.

“Oh, you are right. Will you help me prepare, Jerron?”

She does not know why I am what I am but she knows I am no longer something to be feared. I no longer feel the sting of her rejection.



 

People think, because of what I am, that I was scared. People think that in order to protect others, mages need to be protected from themselves. I know I had courage enough to see battle and strength enough to prevail.

As the Qunari began to take some food and water, he started suffering nightmares and delusions. He would even fall out of bed with a mighty thump.

“Jerron. Could you check on the Qunari?”

“Jerron. The Qunari is disturbed again. Perhaps another book.”

Sometimes, the Qunari would tell me a little of his homeland as I attended to him. Often he would ask me if I dreamed. I remember dreams, though few that were frightening. He asked me if I felt safe in the tower and if I was ever scared.

One night, he gripped my arm, met my gaze and whispered, “I see you have lost your sword too.”

The next I heard, he was gone.

 

“Tranquil” is also how people describe a still pond. They will leave it undisturbed, save to gaze at it from time to time, as into a mirror. Whether or not there is life teeming below the surface of the water is unimportant to all but those wanting to eat fish.

When one is made Tranquil, much is lost but much also remains. The memory of my modest ambition is not something I dwell on, but it is still with me. The idea that I once had potential enough to become a passable mage also lingers. I might no longer love Ellin but her beauty is more plainly obvious to me now than it ever was.

It is true that I rarely speak aloud. Yet, I feel no sadness. I am content to serve and wait out my remaining days.   

Modifié par Firky, 21 juin 2010 - 03:31 .


#2
Gilgamesh1138

Gilgamesh1138
  • Members
  • 1 915 messages
As always Firky! I love your stories with other characters in which Sten is a thread. Wonderul, and creative. Really hit home with Sten's comment to the Tranquil, "I see you lost your sword too." Fantastic! I hope there will be more! I need to give this a shout out on FF.net. Thanks for sharing with us all. ^_^

#3
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages
Thankyou. (At least I know one person is reading.) I have a couple more in mind - when I get time.

I think I'm improving but I still struggle with the middle sections. :(
And the action bits.

Modifié par Firky, 20 juin 2010 - 10:51 .


#4
Shadow of Light Dragon

Shadow of Light Dragon
  • Members
  • 5 179 messages
I agree with Gil, the "I see you lost your sword too" line really stood out. Nice!



I think it would be really hard writing from the POV of one of the Tranquil for any length of time, because what they are makes them so dispassionate. It would mean deliberately removing a lot of emotion from what they do/think...I'd probably be forced to write flashbacks of times when the character could still feel things to strike up a contrast. You write of past events here, but do it all from the Tranquil perspective so that it still feels (intentionally?) dry.



It might have been interesting to see that middle section from Jerron's POV before he was made Tranquil, discovering the blood magic, getting weakened, being being caught and having the Rite done on him so we could more personally experience the strength of his emotions (rather than just seeing them named), but if your intention was to write it all from the mind of the Tranquil I think you did it well. :)



Nice short story :)

#5
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages
You make a good point. I was aiming at dispassionate but probably hit boring.

Hmmm. I think I might try the middle again -Maybe a conversation with Ellin in the present. But, yeah, I'd still have to describe the past. Yeah, maybe a flashack.

I'll have a try. Thanks for feedback.

Modifié par Firky, 21 juin 2010 - 02:27 .


#6
Gilgamesh1138

Gilgamesh1138
  • Members
  • 1 915 messages
You didnt' hit boring at all. I found the story intriguing. I liked it very much. You could put it in the middle as Shadow suggested. And a convo with Ellin was something I was going to suggest. LOL! Got distracted playing on an MMO with hubby.

#7
Shadow of Light Dragon

Shadow of Light Dragon
  • Members
  • 5 179 messages
Not boring so much as not engaging, maybe? But like I said it's probably hard to achieve that when writing dispassionately. Dry can still be interesting. :)

#8
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages
OK. Have re-written it. It's shorter, but I do admit to liking short short stories - and if you are ever going to make a short one, a Tranquil provides the opportunity.

He is the 2nd paragraph bit (as it was originally) for comparison....

People think, because of what I am, that I must have been weak. People think I would have become an abomination. Perhaps I would never have been a Great Mage, whispered awe following me along hallways, but I know I had sufficient power to wield magic. I would have been no abomination.

When the First Enchanter discovered the cuts on my arms I thought I would be in trouble. I didn’t know that the trouble would be the Rite of Tranquility. Blood Magic is something whispered about after lights out in the first year of apprenticeship, not discussed openly. It is as if the Enchanters fear the mere mention of such a thing might inspire their apprentices to explore the forbidden magics.

I discovered the power of my blood quite by accident, trying to capture the attentions of Ellin. As one of the brightest apprentices, and beautiful, she commanded the respect of both her peers and teachers. I was an average student with skills sufficient to progress but not to shine. She would generally avoid my gaze, made uneasy by the power of my obvious adolescent longing.

One time, however, she looked me directly in the eye. It was during a demonstration of endurance. Each apprentice was quietly maintaining a small fire atop their desk for as long as they were able. A few had given up and were resting. I felt as if I could continue no longer until I saw Ellin glance over at another boy and smile. Desperate then to outlast at least this one competitor, I unsheathed the pocket knife I had been using to gather herbs and cut my hand.

I only intended to use the pain as distraction against my encroaching fatigue but something else happened that I never quite understood. My blood flowed freely and the fire burned effortlessly. Soon everyone had surrendered
to exhaustion including Ellin, last of all. She turned to me in astonishment as her fire was extinguished and I was gripped with pride. I may never feel that pride again but I remember the feeling nonetheless.

As time passed, I used my blood to enhance my abilities more often but was ultimately left feeling physically weak. The object of my affection soon lost interest in my modest achievements too.

Ellin meets my gaze now, when I am called to assist her in her duties as a Circle Mage. She does not know why I am what I am. She simply knows that I am no longer something to be feared. I no longer feel the sting of
her rejection.

Modifié par Firky, 21 juin 2010 - 03:26 .


#9
Gilgamesh1138

Gilgamesh1138
  • Members
  • 1 915 messages
I didn't think your story was not engaging. I have to agree to disagree with Shadow. I have read stories where I give up half way through. Yours is certainly not one of them. None of them have been. I just don't see what you are both seeing apparently. *shrugs* I found it enjoyable.

#10
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages
There was definitely something wrong with paragraph 2 though. Do you think I've improved it now Gil? It makes more sense to me now anyway.

#11
LadyAly

LadyAly
  • Members
  • 2 153 messages
I have read the first version yesterday and now the improved one - and the second one is more logical.

But a very nice and enjoyable short story :) Hope to read more from you soon.

#12
Gilgamesh1138

Gilgamesh1138
  • Members
  • 1 915 messages
I think you did improve it! As LadyAly said it makes more sense! *hugs LadyAly*



So yes, it does help!

#13
Shadow of Light Dragon

Shadow of Light Dragon
  • Members
  • 5 179 messages

Gilgamesh1138 wrote...

I didn't think your story was not engaging. I have to agree to disagree with Shadow. I have read stories where I give up half way through. Yours is certainly not one of them. None of them have been. I just don't see what you are both seeing apparently. *shrugs* I found it enjoyable.


Maybe I'm choosing my words poorly. XD I find it hard to connect with characters that don't feel anything--which is what a Tranquil is. So while I still found the story and the main character interesting (and certainly didn't give up halfway through ;)), my interest was more clinical than personal. I didn't feel for the character as much as I thought I could have, because the character's own feelings were always distant.

Maybe that's what helps the 'lost sword' remark stand out, though.

It definitely works as a short story, or even a codex-style 'book'. :)

#14
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages
@LadyAli. Thanks for the feedback. I'm taking "logical" as a high compliment because that is one of the things I was aiming for - I imagined someone without emotions would have a highly organised and logical way of thinking and expressing himself.



@Gilgamesh (I often play Gilgamsh in Civ IV, btw) Thanks. I am bad with middles, so I'm glad to have improved it.



@SoL. Hmmm. I was trying to make the reader feel for him.... I'll have a think. Maybe I can tweak it. Thanks again.