Tootles FTW wrote...
I think the disconnect here in regards to the Harkin situation comes down to the fact that I don't view it as torture. Torture is disturbing (and possibly involves nipple clamps) but the Harkin scene, for me, wasn't torture - it was a justifiable roughing up on par with any cop movie. It's not the "correct" response when viewed in hindsight by most rational, law-abiding citizens, but Harkin is hardly a figure that elicits sympathy considering that he just tried to murder you. We've seen Shep (albeit Renegade Shep) behave in a similar fashion, and even Captain Anderson in ME1 punches out an unarmed Udina; but in these instances I don't think we're meant to think too much about it, since we're not supposed to like these characters and thus it's "okay" for them to suffer.
I love that scene. It resonates even more for me if I imagine (RP) Shepard told Garrus about Harkin sleazily hitting on her back in Chora's Den in ME1, during one of their talks or something. It makes it more like, "THIS is what you get for hitting on my girlfriend, dirtbag!"

- I must admit to finding Garrus' aggressiveness sexy on a fantasy level
(I agree with Tootles on the Harkin scene). Would I want him to get
violent with Shep? Of course not, but some fantasies are meant to STAY
fantasies. The potential for aggressiveness in a man is a turn on to
quite a few women, but that doesn't mean they actually want the violence to happen to them.
It's the bad boy appeal, and yes, it's very primal. Harkens back to the
image of the typical dominant male. So if it works with a human male, it
would also work with a turian male.
This, too. /ardent nod
Collider wrote:
If there some stupid option like siding with the Reapers or something, I
guess Garrus would "betray" Shepard then ;/
I would certainly hope so. I would lose most, if not all, of my respect for Garrus if he just went all doe-eyed over what Shepard wanted, all the time. It would wreck his awesome personality for me.