29107 réponses à ce sujet

[ciaweth]

Aislinn Trista wrote...

 
Garrus and FemShep - Give Me A Sign

I made this for all the Garrus/FemShep fans out there.  I'm a huge Garrus fan, myself.  [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/love.png[/smilie]

Anyway, let me know what you think.  I'm rather happy with how it turned out.  Featuring my Paragon Adept, Aislinn Shepard.

Nicely done!

[ReluctantMind]

I just watched How to Train Your Dragon on DVD. There is a part early on where the mangler misfires and beans a viking and Hiccup says "A slight calibration error" and I could not help but think "If only Garrus were there, he could handle it".

[Evelinessa]

SurelyForth wrote...

I did not know that you could Paragon/Renegade him. I know I chose a mixture of responses, mostly because my Paragon has a willful streak and isn't opposed to knocking some heads when need be. But she tried to take Dr. Saleon into custody. How can you tell if he's gone to either side? By whether or not he says something about trying to become a Spectre?

I agree that the romance scene was better then an actual sex scene.

From what I remember of the first game I ended up renegading him because I picked mostly the bottom choices(I told him what he wanted to hear) but I tried to save Dr. Saleon and I still ended up renegading him. So it's whatever you do more of. If you renegade him then his last conversation says he's going to try to become a spectre and if you paragon him he says he's going to try to go back to C-Sec(thats what I read but I haven't paragoned him yet).

[Eliantariel]

I think the romance scene was well done - funny and toughtful at the same time - the only thing that I don't like is the end: first you are in the mood "ahhh Garrus *melt*" and then after a short black screen it changes suddenly to "argh.. TIM!"...



I could watch Shepard and Garrus endlessly, but ok, the game must go on....

[Evelinessa]

Eliantariel wrote...

I think the romance scene was well done - funny and toughtful at the same time - the only thing that I don't like is the end: first you are in the mood "ahhh Garrus *melt*" and then after a short black screen it changes suddenly to "argh.. TIM!"...

I could watch Shepard and Garrus endlessly, but ok, the game must go on....

Thats why I watch the romance scene on youtube all the time.

At first I was disapointed with the scene because I ended up reading spoilers and alot of people were unhappy with it. But once I saw the scene it was really touching and I haven't seen the other romances yet but I know this will be my favorite(he's my favorite character and the romance feels so natural, and I wanted to romance him in the first game).

[GuardianAngel470]

My fic is also here on Bioware for those who don't have a fanfiction.net account and can't comment.

I enjoy hearing comments on my work, please comment.

Link in my sig, both for bioware forums and fanfiction.net

Modifié par GuardianAngel470, 19 octobre 2010 - 07:56 .

[GuardianAngel470]

Evelinessa wrote...

SurelyForth wrote...

I did not know that you could Paragon/Renegade him. I know I chose a mixture of responses, mostly because my Paragon has a willful streak and isn't opposed to knocking some heads when need be. But she tried to take Dr. Saleon into custody. How can you tell if he's gone to either side? By whether or not he says something about trying to become a Spectre?

I agree that the romance scene was better then an actual sex scene.

From what I remember of the first game I ended up renegading him because I picked mostly the bottom choices(I told him what he wanted to hear) but I tried to save Dr. Saleon and I still ended up renegading him. So it's whatever you do more of. If you renegade him then his last conversation says he's going to try to become a spectre and if you paragon him he says he's going to try to go back to C-Sec(thats what I read but I haven't paragoned him yet).

I pretty much always renegaded him. Sometimes you can't solve a problem the orthodox way and you have to improvise. 

[Eliantariel]

Of course it is mostly the hard way staying with the rules and following orders and sometimes this can led to situations where a criminal escapes due to formal errors or so - but in ME1 Garrus really seemed to be on a revenge trip with no regard to the damage that he could cause for innocents. And with doing so - even if he tracks down a criminal - is it really worth to risk or kill several innocent people for this?



He admits in the end, that one of his reasons to hunt down Dr. Heart was that he escaped during his watch - so this seemed to be something like a personal affront to him. The paragon way is to calm him down and in ME2 you see that (either because of paragons Sheps teaching and/or his own finding) he and his team tried to avoid civil victims.

[Evelinessa]

GuardianAngel470 wrote...

Evelinessa wrote...

SurelyForth wrote...

I did not know that you could Paragon/Renegade him. I know I chose a mixture of responses, mostly because my Paragon has a willful streak and isn't opposed to knocking some heads when need be. But she tried to take Dr. Saleon into custody. How can you tell if he's gone to either side? By whether or not he says something about trying to become a Spectre?

I agree that the romance scene was better then an actual sex scene.

From what I remember of the first game I ended up renegading him because I picked mostly the bottom choices(I told him what he wanted to hear) but I tried to save Dr. Saleon and I still ended up renegading him. So it's whatever you do more of. If you renegade him then his last conversation says he's going to try to become a spectre and if you paragon him he says he's going to try to go back to C-Sec(thats what I read but I haven't paragoned him yet).

I pretty much always renegaded him. Sometimes you can't solve a problem the orthodox way and you have to improvise. 

I want to try to paragon him but I have such a hard time telling him stuff he doesn't want to hear(the paragon answers).I'm too nice and I will probably never be able to play renegade.

Eliantariel wrote...

Of course it is mostly the hard way staying with the rules and following orders and sometimes this can led to situations where a criminal escapes due to formal errors or so - but in ME1 Garrus really seemed to be on a revenge trip with no regard to the damage that he could cause for innocents. And with doing so - even if he tracks down a criminal - is it really worth to risk or kill several innocent people for this?

He admits in the end, that one of his reasons to hunt down Dr. Heart was that he escaped during his watch - so this seemed to be something like a personal affront to him. The paragon way is to calm him down and in ME2 you see that (either because of paragons Sheps teaching and/or his own finding) he and his team tried to avoid civil victims.

Thats cool that it makes a difference but I thought he still says that even if you renegade him? In my first playthrough I renegaded him but I tried to save Dr.Saleon.  The only difference I heard of is if you tried to kill Dr.Saleon without offering to bring him in then in ME2 if you try to talk Garrus down on his Loyalty Mission he calls you out on what you said in the first game.

[Eliantariel]

Yes I think he always tells you that he and his team spared civils even if you renegaded or paragoned him in ME1 - this is why I wrote it could be his own finding and/or with help from Shepard (if paragon, not if renegade).



But I would like to know what exactly Garrus says to Shepard if he was not present at Dr. Saleons death. Maybe I can find it on youtube because I always took Garrus with me in ME1 (well - how could I not?) and therefore he was present on my playthroughs when Dr. Saleons life ended.

[Evelinessa]

Eliantariel wrote...

Yes I think he always tells you that he and his team spared civils even if you renegaded or paragoned him in ME1 - this is why I wrote it could be his own finding and/or with help from Shepard (if paragon, not if renegade).

But I would like to know what exactly Garrus says to Shepard if he was not present at Dr. Saleons death. Maybe I can find it on youtube because I always took Garrus with me in ME1 (well - how could I not?) and therefore he was present on my playthroughs when Dr. Saleons life ended.

I tried looking for a video but I haven't found anything. I read what he said before. I think I remember reading that he says something like he "wished he could have been there" but I don't know what he says exactly. I would feel so bad not taking him. Maybe you'll have better luck finding a video.

In my first playthrough of ME2 I also had him kill Sidonis. I didn't know if I would still get his loyalty and the paragon in me wanted to warn him but I let him take the shot. Then later after I finished that playthrough I watched what happens if you let him live and I felt really bad. I guess I'm going to keep that playthrough the "Renegade Garrus" playthrough and do it differently next time.

I hope that in ME3 if you renegade/paragon Garrus it makes a big difference.

Edit:
Fixed typos

Modifié par Evelinessa, 19 octobre 2010 - 09:21 .

[GuardianAngel470]

Evelinessa wrote...

Eliantariel wrote...

Yes I think he always tells you that he and his team spared civils even if you renegaded or paragoned him in ME1 - this is why I wrote it could be his own finding and/or with help from Shepard (if paragon, not if renegade).

But I would like to know what exactly Garrus says to Shepard if he was not present at Dr. Saleons death. Maybe I can find it on youtube because I always took Garrus with me in ME1 (well - how could I not?) and therefore he was present on my playthroughs when Dr. Saleons life ended.

I tried looking for a video but I haven't found anything. I read what he said before. I think I remember reading that he says something like he "wished he could have been there" but I don't know what he says exactly. I would feel so bad not taking him. Maybe you'll have better luck finding a video.

In my first playthrough of ME2 I also had him kill Sidonis. I didn't know if I would still get his loyalty and the paragon in me wanted to warn him but I let him take the shot. Then later after I finished that playthrough I watched what happens if you let him live and I felt really bad. I guess I'm going to keep that playthrough the "Renegade Garrus" playthrough and do it differently next time.

I hope that in ME3 if you renegade/paragon Garrus it makes a big difference.

Edit:
Fixed typos

I renegade him in ME1 and paragon him in ME2. While I respect that he took my advice to heart he needed to know what "too far" looked like.

[kglaser]

Eliantariel wrote...
But I would like to know what exactly Garrus says to Shepard if he was not present at Dr. Saleons death. Maybe I can find it on youtube because I always took Garrus with me in ME1 (well - how could I not?) 

Exactly.  What is the point of recruiting him, hearing him out about Saleon, and then leaving him behind?  I never even thought about it before...it's one of those things I should try For Science, but then again, if my motives were all scientific, I should also try not recruiting him in the first place, for the same reason--and that's never gonna happen in my house.

[aznsoisauce]

Aislinn Trista wrote...

 
Garrus and FemShep - Give Me A Sign

I made this for all the Garrus/FemShep fans out there.  I'm a huge Garrus fan, myself.  [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/love.png[/smilie]

Anyway, let me know what you think.  I'm rather happy with how it turned out.  Featuring my Paragon Adept, Aislinn Shepard.

This was wonderful. :happy: Nice, high quality clips from the game. I'm not a big fan of the song, but it definitely worked. Thanks for sharing~!

[Eradyn]

I should say that paragon is not necessarily "good," "right," or even "best." ;p



That aside...if you leave him out of the Saleon mission, he's upset but ultimately accepts it. I saw the vid a looong time ago, though, so I can't give any specifics. Maybe we'll get lucky and find it in the depths of youtube?

[fallele]

@ Evelinessa: the second option was the correct one.  i couldn't find a cookie so here's Garrus with a cupcake instead





great...now i've made myself hungry.

[kglaser]

Eradyn wrote...

I should say that paragon is not necessarily "good," "right," or even "best." ;p

That aside...if you leave him out of the Saleon mission, he's upset but ultimately accepts it. I saw the vid a looong time ago, though, so I can't give any specifics. Maybe we'll get lucky and find it in the depths of youtube?

I don't want to look for it...it just seems wrong. 
Just as it seems wrong to me not to bring Liara to Noveria (especially after I heard Garrus suggest it)...I'm not a big fan of hers, but it just makes logical sense.  Same with Garrus and Saleon.

eta:  mmm fallele, cupcakes

Modifié par kglaser, 20 octobre 2010 - 03:49 .

[GuardianAngel470]

kglaser wrote...

Eradyn wrote...

I should say that paragon is not necessarily "good," "right," or even "best." ;p

That aside...if you leave him out of the Saleon mission, he's upset but ultimately accepts it. I saw the vid a looong time ago, though, so I can't give any specifics. Maybe we'll get lucky and find it in the depths of youtube?

I don't want to look for it...it just seems wrong. 
Just as it seems wrong to me not to bring Liara to Noveria (especially after I heard Garrus suggest it)...I'm not a big fan of hers, but it just makes logical sense.  Same with Garrus and Saleon.

eta:  mmm fallele, cupcakes

I take people that tactically make the most sense. I also didn't use biotics in ME1 after a rather unfortune occurrance involving me, a stasis, a warp, and two dead biotic squadmates, one of which was Liara.

Let's just say that no one will ever call him fat...

[fallele]

I found this while brousing the internets (kudos to the original creator of this though)

Garrus' reaction to all of us i believe.

also a little off topic:
Tali: Commander Shepard, Commander Shepard
FShep: What's up Tali?
Tali: I think i've found the cure to the Genophage encrypted in these files!
FShep: . . . . ummm that's great Tali
Tali: So do you want me to decrypt them and give a copy to...
Wrex: DECRYPT THEM....NOW!
Tali:  Okay it says...
Tali: Drink....more
Tali: . . . .Mountain Dew
FShep/Wrex/Tali: . . . . . .
Wrex:. . . . .  God Damn It!

Modifié par fallele, 20 octobre 2010 - 08:36 .

[Loki330]

Evelinessa wrote...


At first I was disapointed with the scene because I ended up reading spoilers and alot of people were unhappy with it. But once I saw the scene it was really touching and I haven't seen the other romances yet but I know this will be my favorite(he's my favorite character and the romance feels so natural, and I wanted to romance him in the first game).

Paragon/Jack's is very sweet, and if you think the rejection for Garrus is harsh, even people who dislike Jack have mentioned in the comments section (for the upload I saw) they felt horrid at her reaction. Tali's always makes me laugh at the end (and not because it's badly done, just by what happens)


One thing that did strike me when I saw (unspoilered, yay!) Garrus' scene was the poses/actions mirrored a work aimo (yes, the great aimo of deviantart fame) had done that if my memory serves, was done several weeks before the game. Specifically the forehead touching.

[silentstephi]

aznsoisauce wrote...

Aislinn Trista wrote...

 
Garrus and FemShep - Give Me A Sign

I made this for all the Garrus/FemShep fans out there.  I'm a huge Garrus fan, myself.  [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/love.png[/smilie]

Anyway, let me know what you think.  I'm rather happy with how it turned out.  Featuring my Paragon Adept, Aislinn Shepard.

This was wonderful. :happy: Nice, high quality clips from the game. I'm not a big fan of the song, but it definitely worked. Thanks for sharing~!

Nice video!  The clips were good, though the song isn't one I'm familiar with.
Told the story pretty well though. XD

[ciaweth]

Loki330 wrote...
One thing that did strike me when I saw (unspoilered, yay!) Garrus' scene was the poses/actions mirrored a work aimo (yes, the great aimo of deviantart fame) had done that if my memory serves, was done several weeks before the game. Specifically the forehead touching.

I'm not seeing any forehead-touch-Garrus work in Aimo's gallery with a date that precedes the release of ME2.  Am I missing one?

[Loki330]

ciaweth wrote...

Loki330 wrote...
One thing that did strike me when I saw (unspoilered, yay!) Garrus' scene was the poses/actions mirrored a work aimo (yes, the great aimo of deviantart fame) had done that if my memory serves, was done several weeks before the game. Specifically the forehead touching.

I'm not seeing any forehead-touch-Garrus work in Aimo's gallery with a date that precedes the release of ME2.  Am I missing one?

I'm probably wrong then-I wouldn't be surprised....ah sod it, I'll dig it up.

(much rummaging later)
Here we go. That was uploaded onto devientart on the 4th of January, and ME2 was released (In america and the EU) on the 26th.

[ciaweth]

Ooh! I was missing one. Thanks.

[Sable Rhapsody]

Eradyn wrote...

I should say that paragon is not necessarily "good," "right," or even "best." ;p
 

Which is why I play Paragade  I actually ended up getting the "confused" dialogue from Garrus in ME1, where I neither Paragoned nor Renegaded him.  It was pretty funny, actually, and remarkably in-character for my Shep.  I had some Renegade responses to him in dialogue, one or two Paragon ones, and tried to take Saleon into custody.  Poor Garrus was so confuzzled.

My Shep tried to nurture a sense of perspective in Garrus, get him to see the bigger picture and understand the consequences of his actions in that context.  For example, she agreed that bringing in Saren "by the book" was just not on given how dangerous Saren was, but tried to take in Saleon since doing so would expose any associates, put him on trial, give his victims some closure, etc.  It didn't work too well, but hey, she tried