103 réponses à ce sujet

[snfonseka]

smecky-kitteh wrote...

here is a link tali thread

OMG... 8547 pages .

[Shadowomega23]

snfonseka wrote...

smecky-kitteh wrote...

here is a link tali thread

OMG... 8547 pages .

Actually more then that in total that is the 4th version of the thread, as the other where closed down due to page lenght.

[JohnnyBeGood2]

Shadowomega23 wrote...

JohnnyBeGood2 wrote...

JeanLuc761 wrote...
Wasn't there a thread with EXACTLY this title and question about a month ago? I swear, some people just don't think to use the search bar.

Haven't got it to work for me yet.

JeanLuc761 wrote...
4) She's attractive in a psuedo-exotic way (and was designed as such).

I find that a surprising statement... I haven't seen her face yet.
??

Jean Luc has a thing for hips.

hehe, that brings something up for me. Her body shape is not what I would have called "appealing to the human eye".
Discuss?

[snfonseka]

Mystranna Kelteel wrote...

2) My meaning was that Liara fought to reclaim Shepard's body. Tali went about her own business and moved on. Which one is more loyal? That's my only point.

Completly agree with you, she is the one who really cared for Shepard (LI or not) !

[Shadowomega23]

JohnnyBeGood2 wrote...

Shadowomega23 wrote...

JohnnyBeGood2 wrote...

JeanLuc761 wrote...
Wasn't there a thread with EXACTLY this title and question about a month ago? I swear, some people just don't think to use the search bar.

Haven't got it to work for me yet.

JeanLuc761 wrote...
4) She's attractive in a psuedo-exotic way (and was designed as such).

I find that a surprising statement... I haven't seen her face yet.
??

Jean Luc has a thing for hips.

hehe, that brings something up for me. Her body shape is not what I would have called "appealing to the human eye".
Discuss?

Honestly I didn't notice her feet till the second playthough, though noticed the legs on the first playthough and it kind of me scratching my head. As for her hands well it didn't effect my thinking. I have seen strange Alien creatures sence the 80s so I have seen quite abit of body types. Everything from three chicken legged to things with no legs and move around by slidding like a slug ot slithering like a snake. I know people says she has chicken feet or chicken like legs but the only thing That I see as close to that is that of frogs, but instead of hinging left and right they hing front to back.

[Shadowomega23]

*Double Post*

Modifié par Shadowomega23, 01 juillet 2010 - 05:14 .

[thesuperdarkone]

Beware if you say anything bad about tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge against the talimancers soon...

[Inquisitor Recon]

Good luck sir. Want a loaded revolver for when you do go in? They are on sale today.

[Shadowomega23]

thesuperdarkone wrote...

Beware if you say anything bad about tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge against the talimancers soon...

I saw your post didn't see anyone baiting you, as for revenge good luck with that cause that might anger the great Woo Man and might loss posting rights. As for Biase opinion that is kind of the point, everyone has an opinion and their opionion is their view thus being Biase. So your view on "Talimancers" is Biased because its your view of them. As a side note you fail a bbcode.

Modifié par Shadowomega23, 01 juillet 2010 - 05:31 .

[Christmas Ape]

In b4 "This conversation should be lost in the Tali-themed chatroom thread" lock.

[JohnnyBeGood2]

thesuperdarkone wrote...
Beware if you say anything bad about tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge against the talimancers soon...

Look, they can be overly defensive, but if you get baited, don't take it. Say what you have to say and move on.

[Captain Jazz]

Count the dimensions. That's right, there are three (unlike Ashley "Do you see how I like poetry? Doesn't that make me deep?" Williams) the same is true of Garrus and Mordin.

thesuperdarkone wrote...
Beware if you say anything bad about
tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do
everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a
biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is
what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge
against the talimancers soon...

It's very easy to see trolling in innocent disagreement when you see the same "omg Tali sucks chicken feet!" posts constantly... besides, what bad is there to be said about Tali?

Modifié par Captain Jazz, 01 juillet 2010 - 05:47 .

[langelog]

Tali is an alien, I don't find her attractive at all, her hips are disgustingly wide, she has three fingers and two giant toes, and strange growths out of the back of her legs. She is likley bald because her species is definiley not mammal and there is no room for hair in those masks. Her ass is rectangular and oblong, while Miranda's is a definite 10. If you look at her shoulders and compare them to her arms, she looks too skinny, her arms are so thin, and thats not even her arm, its a sleeve covering her arm increasing width slightly, which means her arms are even bonier. Basically her anatomy is quite repulsive, and seeing what she looks like underneath that suit would probably scar you for life, which is why Bioware and EA agreed to cut to black during her romance scene. I don't hate Tali, but as to why so many fan boys obsess over her is beyond me.

PS: I really don't care if I get flamed, I merely offered my opinion.

Modifié par langelog, 01 juillet 2010 - 06:05 .

[Shadowomega23]

JohnnyBeGood2 wrote...

thesuperdarkone wrote...
Beware if you say anything bad about tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge against the talimancers soon...

Look, they can be overly defensive, but if you get baited, don't take it. Say what you have to say and move on.

Actually he is doing the baiting, and failing. But it is never a good idea to go fishing in an area full of piranha.

[JohnnyBeGood2]

Captain Jazz wrote...
Count the dimensions. That's right, there are three (unlike Ashley "Do you see how I like poetry? Doesn't that make me deep?" Williams) the same is true of Garrus and Mordin.

thesuperdarkone wrote...
Beware if you say anything bad about
tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do
everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a
biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is
what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge
against the talimancers soon...

It's very easy to see trolling in innocent disagreement when you see the same "omg Tali sucks chicken feet!" posts constantly... besides, what bad is there to be said about Tali?

wow Captain... what is this? Don't prove him right by doing this... (then again I guess you can if you feel upset... no side can complain then - you're flaming each other...)

Modifié par JohnnyBeGood2, 01 juillet 2010 - 05:53 .

[Captain Jazz]

JohnnyBeGood2 wrote...

Captain Jazz wrote...
Count the dimensions. That's right, there are three (unlike Ashley "Do you see how I like poetry? Doesn't that make me deep?" Williams) the same is true of Garrus and Mordin.

thesuperdarkone wrote...
Beware if you say anything bad about
tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do
everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a
biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is
what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge
against the talimancers soon...

It's very easy to see trolling in innocent disagreement when you see the same "omg Tali sucks chicken feet!" posts constantly... besides, what bad is there to be said about Tali?

wow Captain... what is this? Don't prove him right by doing this... (then again I guess you can) oh well.

The first part is a reply to the topic, the second is an explanation of why anyone saying anything bad about Tali is accused of trolling... what am I proving him right about?

[JohnnyBeGood2]

Captain Jazz wrote...
The first part is a reply to the topic, the second is an explanation of why anyone saying anything bad about Tali is accused of trolling... what am I proving him right about?

This is heavy risk and there is no priiiize.
(excuse the glib answer)

[langelog]

I believe your proving that Tali fans get overly pissed if anything bad is said about Tali.

Modifié par langelog, 01 juillet 2010 - 05:59 .

[Mr.BlazenGlazen]

Mystranna Kelteel wrote...

JeanLuc761 wrote...
To answer your question, people like Tali so much for multiple reasons:
1) She's extremely well written and has an intriguing backstory/conflict.
3) Along with Garrus, she's the only squadmate to return and remain loyal to Shepard in Mass Effect 2. True loyalty and friendship goes a long way.

1) I would disagree. I don't think she's well-written. She's written very one-sidedly; basically she's forced into liking Shepard regardless of how she was treated in ME1.  Either way, "well-written and intriguing" is a judgment call. I found her Trial plot rather contrived and unrealistic.
3) That's bullcrap. Liara is a lot more loyal by default for actually saving Shepard's life after death. Tali ran away. Say what you will about Liara in ME2; the only reason Tali and Garrus are there are as fan service tokens.

Tali is only "sweet" if you cater to her whims. Show her any kind of defiance, no matter how logical and moral your decision is, and she turns into a petulant little brat. She really is quite selfish and two-faced.

Obvious troll is obvious. And if Liara was so loyal despite saving shepard i love the part where she completely blows you off in the game all because of the shadow broker. Ashely/Kaiden kind of moved on from shepard in a way. That kind of makes sense. Really only Wrex has a good reason not to join shepard's team again. Tali and Garrus on the other hand joins because they are already somewhat friends or old comrades to shepard already.

[Captain Jazz]

langelog wrote...

Captain Jazz wrote...
The first part is a reply to the topic, the second is an explanation of why anyone saying anything bad about Tali is accused of trolling... what am I proving him right about?

I believe you're proving that Tali fans get overly pissed if anything
bad is said about Tali.

...maybe I'm proving that people read anger in emotionally neutral words?

Modifié par Captain Jazz, 01 juillet 2010 - 06:00 .

[MTN Dew Fanatic]

thesuperdarkone wrote...

Beware if you say anything bad about tali, as I have experience with this, as they will flamebait you and do everything they can to accuse you of being a troll, and tali fans are a biased group so you won't get an accurate opinion from them, which is what this thread is mostly composed of. P.S. I will have my revenge against the talimancers soon...

You must act soon, very soon or they will get you first.

[Eternal Density]

langelog wrote...

Tali is an alien, I don't find her attractive at all, her hips are disgustingly wide, she has three fingers and two giant toes, and strange growths out of the back of her legs. She is likley bald because her species is definiley not mammal and there is no room for hair in those masks. Her ass is rectangular and oblong, while Miranda's is a definite 10. If you look at her shoulders and compare them to her arms, she looks too skinny, her arms are so thin, and thats not even her arm, its a sleeve covering her arm increasing width slightly, which means her arms are even bonier. Basically her anatomy is quite repulsive, and seeing what she looks like underneath that suit would probably scar you for life, which is why Bioware and EA agreed to cut to black during her romance scene. I don't hate Tali, but as to why so many fan boys obsess over her is beyond me.

PS: I really don't care if I get flamed, I merley offered my opinion.

I'm a bit of a Talimancer (I pop into The Thread from time to time) and I can't really disagree with that.  I guess we just have a different point of view and choose to see all that in a different light.
I must, however, disagree with your spelling of merely. 

[hangmans tree]

I think most loyal is Ash/Keidan - depending on who died on Vermire. If self sacrefice is not the highest act of loyalty I dont know what is.



I liked Talis design better (to Liaras). Furthermopre Liaras donut-face was never attractive for me.



With the new recruitement I think Samara may have the highest loyalt rate...plus the oath she made.

[langelog]

This thread is simply becoming a fight over blame as to who the trolls are, I don't see any trolls, I see people offering their honest opinions, too bad it's so hard to see others opinions, harsh as they may be to some, others see the sound arguments that back them. Although they're not all good, I'll admit that, most have good points.