I don'think that the game is at the level to be considered "unplayable for allmost all users" but it is also true that "it works fine only for a very limited number of users"
If we want to discuss if the game is playable or not we should also have to consider what every single player considers important for his game. We have 2 main kind of troubles in this game:
- the instability of the game/crashes
- several bugs which affect the story
and 1 minor kind (at least I think it is so)
- some missing objects/objects which don't work correctly
Correct me if I am wrong but I don't think someone would stop to play the game just because we haven't elven boots into the game.. It's annoying yes, but not vital, therefore let's concentrate on the first two points
I am a long time RPG player, rightly before RPG video games were born I was already a pen&paper RPG player. I am not the kind of player who cares about graphic or special effects 'cause I am mainly interested about the story, the plot and the life of the characters
Now..There is a huge portion of PC users who suffers of frequently crashes, some of them ,like me, managed to play the game lowering some settings.. The game is less enjoyable with lowered video settings or with sounds effect disabled but you can play it. If that was the only issue I suffered I could easily say that the game for me was playable.
But when you play a character and after 60 hours you are playing you managed to become king in your story, you reach the ending and you discover that another character is addressed to be king due to a bug...
When you romanced a character and you don't obtain the propers dialogues at the end, and you also discover that in the expansion some things concerning your LI don't trigger due to a bug...
When you let a character die and later in the expansion he reappears, talking to you as you were best buddies due to a bug....
In that moment, for me, the game is unplayable.
But there are also players for which is not enough to have a story which is 100% fine but that want also a stable game which doesn't crash every 5 minute. For these players the game is broken too...
If there are people who play on console or on some PC that for lucky don't crash (because trust me.. is a matter of luck not of minimal specs) and don't mind too much about these things, or they didn't notice them or they didn't meet them just because their story follows ways which allow them to avoid these bugs, they will always say that "the game is correct" but this is not completely true
If you side immediately in Orzammar with Harrowmont or Bhelen you won't encounter the bug breaking game which prevent you to continue the quest..
If you didn't romance Zevran you'll never have the problem of him speaking to you with the incorrect dialogue lines at the Gates of Denerim
This doesn't mean that your game works correctly, But just that in your in-game choices you didn't take any decision which could bring you to face these (bugged) situations. Therefore your game is bugged also for you becuase if tomorrow you'll begin a new playtrough and you will try one of these ways you'll have the same problems. And mine was just a couple of examples of all the affecting-story bugs we are suffering from the beginning....
Modifié par MaxQuartiroli, 04 juillet 2010 - 01:43 .