Has Bioware ever let me down?
Only once. At least when it comes to the games I have played.
- The Baldur's Gate series was and remains one of the best RPG experience ever.
- Neverwnter Nights is their one game I never got into. It was mostly multiplayer, and I never got into its modding community. I have no illusion, based on what I've seen since, that it was probably a mistake to move on and never look back at NwN and try and give its multiplayer/modding aspect a change. But I expected a BG-style campaign, and it just wasn't there.
- KOTOR I loved. One of my favourites, excellent work.
- Jade Empire I also loved. The whole Wuxia RPG is something I completely embraced, and the story was excellent. I want JE 2.
- When Mass Effect came out, I was enraptured. I loved the Science Fiction RPG style. In the years sense, I've come to understand its significant flaws with pacing and its failings as a shooter, but it certainly did not let me down when it came out.
- Dragon Age is one of the best game I ever played, if not my favourite. Not only did this NOT let me down, but whenever I play it I cannot help but remark how well-polished a game it is. A landmark achievement if there ever was one, and the delays in releasing it clearly showed in its incredible polish and excellent design (be it gameplay, ergonomics, and storyline).
- Mass Effect 2 deserves all the praise it received, and resolved all the flaws I perceived in ME1. A truly excellent game, and the best storytelling in any game to date. The 3PS element was excellent, though I would have liked more RPG elements there, I must admit it is much more fun than ME1.
- Awakenings I enjoyed greatly, it was a great expansion, and quite frankly I am mystified by most of the complaints I have read about it. It certainly felt like a complex expansion to me, and I got 30 hours of gameplay out of it, which is what ME1 was in the first place. It certainly had more bugs than Dragon Age, but I think most people who complain about bugs in Awakenings are using Dragon Age as their baseline, when in fact Dragon Age was very exceptionally bug-free for a modern computer game (likely due to its extensive delays). Awakenings didn't get pushed back several times, and so it's as bugged as most modern games are. Still, I enjoyed it thouroughly.
As for Dragon Age 2?
I don't mind the Shepards-style protagonist, for one thing the canon one has Duncan's Beard, which is a Blessing From Above. My worries are about things we just don't have any data. Is the art-style cartoonie? Are they killing the hardcore RPG aspects that made Dragon Age exceptional in this day and age (and surely contributed to its surprising success, proving there was still a market for hardcore RPGs)? Is the combat style going the way of Diablo?
We just don't know.
Maybe, just maybe what they're doing is merging the best RPG aspects of Mass Effect (stunning storytelling and cinematics) with the hardcore RPG features of Dragon Age. If so, we will be blessed indeed.
But even so, Bioware has consistently shown itself to making masterful RPGs, so I am not really worried about not enjoying DA2. I'm just hoping we don't lose what made DA such a nostalgic experience for me.
Oh, and one note concerning something I read in this thread:
the very idea that having a completely new protagonist means that DAO was meaningless is _completely ridiculous_. A game's meaning is NOT defined by whether or not there is a sequel to continue the same story. That's ludicrous. DAO was about how your hero defeats the 5th Blight before it even gets completely started, saving Ferelden in the process and sparing Thedas at least a decade of warfare (or maybe even a century... some Blights took a LONG time to defeat). THAT is the story, and that is its meaning, and your character's part in Thedas' history is resolved, and he/she is now known as one of the greatest heroes in Thedas' history. It doesn't need a direct sequel to give it meaning.
Would Rocky have been a meaningless movie if they had not made Rocky 2? Is Schindler's List without meaning because they haven't made Schindler's List 2?
No. DAO has its own meaning, and it is resolved. DA2 is another story within Thedas, with perhaps some relations (for example, maybe the antagonist is lovely Flemeth).
Thank you.
Itkovian