Aller au contenu

Photo

Why all the Hawke hate?


105 réponses à ce sujet

#26
aries1001

aries1001
  • Members
  • 1 752 messages
If we go back 12 years or so, to the release of Baldur's Gate (the first one), you had a fixed protagonist as well. There was only one origin story (you'd grown up in Candlekeep) - and then stuff happened.



The story was also about you, the main protagonist's story in the game.It was very deep and rich, I remember.



As for Hawke being human and from Lothering, it seems that yes, there could be (is) probably a story reason why the main character is described this way in DA2. Bioware apparently want to tell Hawke's story through certian events that happened in he past, but now being retold in the present via us living (gaming) Hawke's story.



I'm getting a fairly good vibe about this game - an adventure game vibe that is. Not a la Oblivion but more like The Longest Journey and Syberia and the new Sherlock Holmes games.


#27
Drewcifer

Drewcifer
  • Members
  • 1 messages
I agree, way to be optimistic. Because I doubt Bioware would stray from the customizable race/character features unless they had a really good story to tell. Posted Image I'm very excited for this game

#28
Chibi Elemental

Chibi Elemental
  • Members
  • 775 messages

Rubbish Hero wrote...

Tsai Zhou wrote...

Rubbish Hero wrote...

He sounds like a wrestler and sounds like he plays like Shepard.
What's not to hate?


How is she like shep? (yes I am calling hawke a girl cause thats who she is going to be for me) so far the only similarties between the two is the dialouge wheel and the more I hear about that the more I am liking it, last few things I heard was the tonality was going to be represented in the small frase by an icon. Vary different then just a simple paragon or renegade response that could be any tone really. 

The whole voiced protagonist thing is also sort of funny, I remember when DAO was coming out and there was no voice acting for the main char that there were doomsays then as well. In either case this was yet another situation where the developer wanting to tell a different story was doomed if they did doomed if they did not. Also david gaider (lead writer) has said in multiple posts (I am not going to link them you can use the handy search function for that) that he feels he is telling a lot more indepth story then he could have ever in DAO. Which imo is what is really important. Playing the story your way.

So really all I am saying is DA2 has a lot of potential and those who are bashing hawke really need to hold onto their rocks just a while longer. I am sure DA2 is going to be a riot to play, as long as her voice actor is going is good as well.


Mass Effect.


Oi its ok I understand that all you see is masseffect mass effect. *pats* you get a candy for it. 

however I do not see it being completely that way, not yet at least, it really depends on the choises we are given, but if you want to convince me that it is masseffect DA2 style then please explain your view in more then just 2 words as I have.

#29
Alisaunder

Alisaunder
  • Members
  • 11 messages
Actually one entertaining way around all of this that I feel might appease most people is if you have say 8 options in a game for team members then enable it so that you can play any of the possible team members as if they were the main character.
 
First time you play the game Play as Hawk, then after you beat the game, play it again only play as one of the other potential party members. Instead of hawk encountering them and recruiting them you could encounter Hawk and recruit him for your mission. What was his primary mission might not be your primary mission each team member usually has some sort of Loyal or main goal as well. Make that your main goal and still make the games main goal Hawks.
 
It would still be very fun. Everyone could play from a different origin each time and you could see the story evolve from a different perspective. You could still use the voice overs, and still have fixed dialog interactions with the other characters based on personality types.

Posted Image

#30
Tooneyman

Tooneyman
  • Members
  • 4 416 messages
There is no Hawke hate. I have a new quote for everyone. ALL HAIL THE HAWKE!

#31
Alisaunder

Alisaunder
  • Members
  • 11 messages
Everytime I hear Hawke now I think of Hawke in that old Buck Rogers series with Gill Gerard. LOL!

#32
Hepahaestion

Hepahaestion
  • Members
  • 2 messages
I don't care about, nor for, any character in any game; thus I do not care who the hell Hawke is. In RPGs they are merely pack mules and skill vehicles. I hate it when "Character interaction" is tauted on games; the only things I care about are the combat, skill system & exploration. Provided they do these well, things should be okay.

Modifié par Hepahaestion, 12 juillet 2010 - 05:07 .


#33
TSamee

TSamee
  • Members
  • 495 messages

Tooneyman wrote...

There is no Hawke hate. I have a new quote for everyone. ALL HAIL THE HAWKE!


Oh YES. :o

#34
MaxQuartiroli

MaxQuartiroli
  • Members
  • 3 123 messages
Don't worry...
Check this forum after a couple of months from the release of the game and then you'll see it full of topics like "Hawke in DA3" and "Please Bioware let us keep Hawke for DA3"
People change opinion so quickly...

Modifié par MaxQuartiroli, 12 juillet 2010 - 05:09 .


#35
Chibi Elemental

Chibi Elemental
  • Members
  • 775 messages

Hepahaestion wrote...

I don't care about, nor for, any character in any game; thus I do not care who the hell Hawke is. In RPGs they are merely pack mules and skill vehicles. I hate it when "Character interaction" is tauted on games; the only things I care about are the combat, skill system & exploration. Provided they do these well, things should be okay.


Not everyone is about the game play, some people actually play games for their story, just like some people read comic books for the art.

#36
Kohaku

Kohaku
  • Members
  • 2 520 messages

MaxQuartiroli wrote...

Don't worry...
Check this forum after a couple of months from the release of the game and then you'll see it full of topics like "Hawke in DA3" and "Please Bioware let us keep Hawke for DA3"
People change opinion so quickly...


You're wrong.

It'll be, "Hawke in ME3" and "Hawke as Squadmate/LI in ME3". Think broader.

#37
Wishpig

Wishpig
  • Members
  • 2 173 messages
Personally I think Hawke looks awesome. I do mean visually...



He screams bad ****. I could never play as default character in any RPG where you can alter appearance. I always like to make the main character my own. For example, I could never bring myself to play as default Shepard in ME.



However, I look forward to playing default Hawke just cause DAMMIT he looks cool.

#38
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages
It's not hate, but thus far I haven't heard anything that interested me about the character.  I don't like playing humans, for one thing.  The Cousland story was fine, but if that was all I had, it would not have held my interest nearly as much as DAO has done.

However, I do realize we haven't heard much about the character yet and what we've heard seems geared towards getting FPS-happy males interested in the game.

#39
MaxQuartiroli

MaxQuartiroli
  • Members
  • 3 123 messages

However, I do realize we haven't heard much about the character yet and what we've heard seems geared towards getting FPS-happy males interested in the game.


I am totally the opposite of a FPS-happy male player, but I am interested in the game the same...

#40
Chibi Elemental

Chibi Elemental
  • Members
  • 775 messages

Addai67 wrote...

It's not hate, but thus far I haven't heard anything that interested me about the character.  I don't like playing humans, for one thing.  The Cousland story was fine, but if that was all I had, it would not have held my interest nearly as much as DAO has done.

However, I do realize we haven't heard much about the character yet and what we've heard seems geared towards getting FPS-happy males interested in the game.


I can understand not liking to play humans, when I heard you could not select your race and was limited to only playing humans I was red in the face screaming at Bioware XD I loved playing my dwarf to much. But this is a different game, I would be more upset if the game was named Dragon age orgins 2 but alas it is named just Dragon age 2, so it really is just a different game.

But I think hawke is going to be awesome regardless.

#41
Herr Uhl

Herr Uhl
  • Members
  • 13 465 messages

Addai67 wrote...

It's not hate, but thus far I haven't heard anything that interested me about the character.  I don't like playing humans, for one thing.  The Cousland story was fine, but if that was all I had, it would not have held my interest nearly as much as DAO has done.

However, I do realize we haven't heard much about the character yet and what we've heard seems geared towards getting FPS-happy males interested in the game.


Kind of like the violence trailer.

#42
alb84

alb84
  • Members
  • 6 messages
I don't hate Hawke... I just simply don't care about his life ^^' XD



What I want is a REAL SEQUEL !!! a continuation for your origins characters, not a quick and default story :S but it seems that the warden story is ended :S a bad thing in my opinion

#43
Master Shiori

Master Shiori
  • Members
  • 3 367 messages
Some people don't like the idea of playing from a third-person perspective. Some grew attached to their DA:O Warden and wanted to continue using him/her.

Personaly, I don't hate Hawke. In fact my attitude towards him can best be described as indifferent right now.
I know very little about him other than a few scant details.
Once I've had a chance to play the game itself and see what the story is like and what Hawke is like, I'll be able to decide whether I like him or not.

Modifié par Master Shiori, 12 juillet 2010 - 05:36 .


#44
Tooneyman

Tooneyman
  • Members
  • 4 416 messages

TSamee wrote...

Tooneyman wrote...

There is no Hawke hate. I have a new quote for everyone. ALL HAIL THE HAWKE!


Oh YES. :o


Or my PErson favorite. ALL HAIL TO THE HAWKE!

Modifié par Tooneyman, 12 juillet 2010 - 05:36 .


#45
Wishpig

Wishpig
  • Members
  • 2 173 messages

alb84 wrote...

I don't hate Hawke... I just simply don't care about his life ^^' XD

What I want is a REAL SEQUEL !!! a continuation for your origins characters, not a quick and default story :S but it seems that the warden story is ended :S a bad thing in my opinion


We knew that the Warden's story prob wouldn't countinue. The devs strait out told us, way back before DA:O was released, that the main character wouldn't necessarly transfer to future sequels. They made that very clear and never hid it or promised otherwise.

#46
Tooneyman

Tooneyman
  • Members
  • 4 416 messages

Wishpig wrote...

alb84 wrote...

I don't hate Hawke... I just simply don't care about his life ^^' XD

What I want is a REAL SEQUEL !!! a continuation for your origins characters, not a quick and default story :S but it seems that the warden story is ended :S a bad thing in my opinion


We knew that the Warden's story prob wouldn't countinue. The devs strait out told us, way back before DA:O was released, that the main character wouldn't necessarly transfer to future sequels. They made that very clear and never hid it or promised otherwise.


Yes, but they should have told us they wouldn't keep the races either. Thats the part which is BULL! and I state this with utmost hate!Posted Image I'm going to be killing puppies because of this. Starting with this one.
Posted Image

#47
MaxQuartiroli

MaxQuartiroli
  • Members
  • 3 123 messages

Tooneyman wrote...

Yes, but they should have told us they wouldn't keep the races either. Thats the part which is BULL! and I state this with utmost hate!Posted Image I'm going to be killing puppies because of this. Starting with this one.


As I asked in another topic would you really like to see something like NWN2? Where you could choose your race and then you begin the game as a son of an ELF? Well I played 2 characters the first one was a DROW and second was a DWARF. Quite silly, don't you think so?

I think they forced you to play as a human for a reason, maybe that playing another race won't fit well with the story they had in their mind

My advice therefore is to wait to see the reason for this choice, and only after that we should discuss if they were right or not..

Modifié par MaxQuartiroli, 12 juillet 2010 - 06:11 .


#48
Tooneyman

Tooneyman
  • Members
  • 4 416 messages

MaxQuartiroli wrote...

Tooneyman wrote...

Yes, but they should have told us they wouldn't keep the races either. Thats the part which is BULL! and I state this with utmost hate!Posted Image I'm going to be killing puppies because of this. Starting with this one.


As I asked in another topic would you really like to see something NWN2? Where you could choose your race and then you begin the game as a son of an ELF? Well I played 2 characters the first one was a DROW and second was a DWARF. Quite silly, don't you think so?

I think they forced you to play as a human for a reason, maybe that playing another race won't fit well with the story they had in their mind

My advice therefore is to wait to see the reason for this choice, and only after that we should discuss if they were right or not..


I will and I hope its good. I don't care about the character of hawke. I don't care that hes voiced and I don't care hes not a warden. I care I can't play as another race and actually the way they set it up was ok. I owned that game and I like it. Posted Image  You were found out in the woods. It was ok, they set it up for you that way. They could have still had time to make the story with the other races. Just I don't think two years is enough time to put those other parts into the game. Sucky but true. I'm still irritiated about it and now I'm killing these puppies!

Posted Image

#49
Majin Paul

Majin Paul
  • Members
  • 527 messages
I think most of the people that are getting angry have heard about the whole single race and vioced character and assuming that there's not much more for them to customise, I think Bioware should release character customisation news as soon as they can so that the fans calm down and (hopefully) start to get excited about the game.

I don't understand why people are getting annoyed about race myself, even included it either would limit you or not make sense after they explained that Hawke was a survivor of Lothering, if you were a Dwarf, you'd most likely have to be a trader and you'd be casteless, being an Elf wouldn't make sense because the non-dalish elves only live in cities where they can be protected can't they?

And Qunarri wouldn't make sense either because the codex entry on Sten (I think it's Sten, not the entry for Lothering) that says he is the strangest thing the people of Lothering have seen.

#50
Tooneyman

Tooneyman
  • Members
  • 4 416 messages

Majin Paul wrote...

I think most of the people that are getting angry have heard about the whole single race and vioced character and assuming that there's not much more for them to customise, I think Bioware should release character customisation news as soon as they can so that the fans calm down and (hopefully) start to get excited about the game.
I don't understand why people are getting annoyed about race myself, even included it either would limit you or not make sense after they explained that Hawke was a survivor of Lothering, if you were a Dwarf, you'd most likely have to be a trader and you'd be casteless, being an Elf wouldn't make sense because the non-dalish elves only live in cities where they can be protected can't they?
And Qunarri wouldn't make sense either because the codex entry on Sten (I think it's Sten, not the entry for Lothering) that says he is the strangest thing the people of Lothering have seen.


Actually there were elves in Lothering! HERE!

http://dragonage.wik.../wiki/Lothering

Look under the characters and You will see trapped family they were elves! OWNED!

Modifié par Tooneyman, 12 juillet 2010 - 06:35 .