Archereon wrote...
Evolution33 wrote...
This is the issue I have with the fantasy world as a whole. Length seems to equate to depth in the minds of a lot of people. Are the characters in a 700 page fantasy novel any more or less deep than say the characters in the under 200 page Great Gatsby? The gatsby characters are some of the depst in modern literature and some of them barely appear. Shear intensity in story telling can do more to develop a character than spending lots of time with them. A one dimensional character given 1000 lines of dialog will remain one dimensional, but a dynamic character can grow in less than a sentence.
No offense to the Bioware writers, but I don't think they, nor most other available modern writers, have it in them to make characters as in depth as in Origins with the number of lines they'll be alotted if the budget is stretched over 20 characters.
Most of the characters in DA:O weren't that deep to me. Some of them had interesting back stories and the like, but most of them were simple archetypes. Alister is the naive hero (and even hardening him doesn't change him that much), Morigan is the snarky outcast from society, Leliana is a person with a troubled past trying to make right, Sten is a duty bound soldier, and on and on. The deepest character to me is Loghain and he is also the one that the least amount of time is spent with. The way he changes through his dialog show that he is the most dynamic of all characters.
The amount of dialog and writing devoted to a character doesn't make thm any more or less deep. The emotions and feelings and how they react to the events around them is what makes them deep. Imagine that one of your characters is a battle hardenned warrior that is only alive when on the battlefield. A few short lines of dialog express this to you when you recruit them. Then while walking through a village they see their country men taking infants from a mother's arms and bashing their skulls against rocks and salting the fields to destroy the future of their rival land. This warrior then expresses their dismay and knew contempt for their country. They say how they never understood the true horrors of war because they were always on the frontlines faced off in noble combat against other warriors. They are no changed in some fashion and are a deeper character for it. It isn't so much about the amount of words given to a charactor but the intensity and meaning of those words.