In Exile wrote...
Why? To begin with - whether or not the child grows up to be anything other than human is up-in-the-air, and there needs to be at least a good 20 year span to actually have an adult to do anything about. Beyond that, it isn't entirely clear that the child is an abomination. If you buy what Morrigan is saying, they're trying to preserve an old god because there is something special about being an old god - but depending on your story choices that never happens.
All I'm saying is this: BioWare has said repeatedly that Morrigan's story isn't over and that we haven't seen the last of her. Now for those of us that had our PCs go through with the DR, it would make for a much more compelling story IMO to have the Warden who did the DR be the one dealing with Morrigan should she surface in a future story.
I'm not saying you go to hunt down and kill Morrigan and the OGB; I'm not saying you hunt down Morrigan to live happily ever after- I'm saying that if BioWare wants consequences for actions to be the heart of what Dragon Age is all about, should Morrigan resurface it makes sense for the Warden, who has a prior history with her, to be the one dealing with whatever she is up to , OGB or otherwise.
In Exile wrote...
So now you're saying DA3 should tell everyone: if you were a Male Warden you slept with Morrigan. No choice about it. If this wasn't your playthrough ever, we've re-written your choice. If you were a female Warden you convinced Alistair to do it (maybe you watched - kinky...).
I'm not saying that at all. They should recognize the choices as appropriate. What I'm saying is that if you did the DR I'd think it would make for a more compelling narrative if the Warden was the one to deal with Morrigan should she come back into DA's stories. Even if you refused the DR but still had your Warden live, if Morrigan came back I think that Warden would possibly be able to have a greater insight into Morrigan than some other hero PC like Hawke.
In Exile wrote...
Also - why should the Warden have normally died? Certainly the taint could have killed him good, but plausibly Alistair or [Secret Character] could have taken the final blow instead. Which just means that in 20 years time you go insane from the taint.
I'm saying that without Morrigan's Ritual, A warden will have to die- it doesn't necessarily have to be your Warden as it could be Loghain or Alistair. My point is that by possibly taking up the Ritual, NO warden needs to die and that is something that has never happened before. Given the whole emphasis on the Grey Wardens living with a death sentence over their head, I'd personally have liked to have seen this consequence of the DR explored more. For all we know, the DR may have affected the Warden in some other way- not unlike how Fiona reacted after being subject to magical influence in The Calling.