Tirigon wrote...
tmelange wrote...
I would still like to know how two things--cinematics and famous voice actors--impact the project budget of an RPG.
I don´t know about cinematics, but voice acting is one of the most
expensive parts in creating the game,
Is there a report out there that says the majority of people who buy RPGs would rather have cinematics and famous voice actors rather than increased choice and more in-depth story options?
I don´t know if there is a report, but the success of ME2 compared to ME1 is a sign, isn´t it?
I enjoy the voice acting, I just think we could forego using regular actors. I mean, it did not make one iota difference to me that Flemeth was voiced by Captain Janeway. I'd rather the money go to the writers, so they can write more dialogue and story.
I don't think I would hold ME2 up as a sign that increased cinematics increases sales. I think the improved marketing of ME2, the better reviews, and the increased emphasis on the shooter aspects and improved fighting increased sales. After all, ME2 hasn't done any better than DAO. I would argue, instead, that if ME2 hadn't gutted its traditional RPG elements, and was able to give us a shooter (with cinematics) with DAO (or witcher) -level RPG story elements in equal measure, it would have increased sales by a large margin.It would have done what it should have done: captured the shooter PLUS RPG market, instead of just substituting out segments and ending with a marginal (almost negligible) bump in market share.
After all, if ME2 --a dual genre game -- didn't DOUBLE sales over DAO -- a single genre game -- what was the purpose, other than to *substitute* out customers? It could be argued that BW is making the mistake of a lifetime by developing DA2 in the ME2 mold, if there aren't enough new fans to replace the ones that will defect. There isn't a secondary category in play to indemnify BW against that potentiality as was the case with ME. Now, if they changed DA2 into a hybrid RPG/Action/Adventure a la Assassin's Creed...god forbid, LOL