Quething wrote...
That reminds me! I had another question for you all! :happy:
How do you guys think of the different Shep origins? Did they all happen, like in DA:O, and only one of them was Shepard? Or is there only ever one of those combinations per universe?
More explicitly: if your Shep is a Sole Survivor, what happened at Torfan and Elysium? We know the Alliance still won those battles and won them resoundingly, since both victories are important to galactic politics and reflected in quests and dialogs that exist in every game (the Blitz especially, though that may just be my bias speaking). Was there still a Hero and a Butcher in a Sole Shep's universe?
I sort of tend to think there should be; it feels to me like saying "those battles would have gone just as well without Shep" otherwise, which diminishes her relevance and protagonist cred a lot. Plus, if the other scenarios still exist, than any given Shep wasn't the only choice, but the best of several possible human candidates, which also does a lot to establish her competence.
If so... are all three of them N7? Do they know each other? What does Hero!Shep think of the Butcher? Does Sole!Shep ever look around and wonder why she got picked over these other two famous Alliance heroes when all she did was survive?
If not, what did happen in the fights that Shepard wasn't there for?
I look at it like this: Whichever history my Shepard has is the only one that follows the canon exactly. The others are different. If my Shepard is a sole survivor, the War Hero background in that universe changes. Instead of one hero who wins the Star of Terra, the breach in Elysium's defenses was held by a small, understrength squad of maybe three or four Marines. Each of them was awarded a high military decoration, much like the Silver Star in current US Military decorations, but not quite the Star of Terra that a single marine would have merited.
The Butcher of Torfan is much the same in the actual battle, but similar to Major Kyle, that squad leader was later found to be suffering from PTSD, and quitely released from military service and sent to a mental health ward to recover.
The Sole Survivor, if not Shep, survived the thresher maw attack, but was wounded to the point where s/he was medically discharged from service, albeit with an honorable discharge. Again, s/he needed treatment for PTSD.
This way, the histories of the in-universe battles remain largely the same, but of slightly lesser impressiveness, which makes Shepard the clear front-runner for Spectre consideration. In this manner, Shepard is among a group of impressive human Alliance marines, but clearly first among equals. Shepard is special, but not outstandingly so.
I'm actually working on my first Ruthless playthrough. I have some headcanon work to do on her before I introduce her to y'all, but so far, she's an interesting character to play. I feel like I'm jumping from femShep to femShep sometimes, but all of my previous femSheps had something about them that just didn't fit how I want my Mass Effect story to go. Rani turned out to be too renegade, and Katrina's Sole Survivor status just
does not work in my head for ME2's story. I just can't see how a sole survivor would
ever work for Cerberus, given the events on Akuze, and so I wound up retiring her without finishing my ME2 playthru.
My current Shep is a Colonist/Ruthless Paragade. She lost it on Torfan and let her past rule her present, and she deeply regrets that her actions lead to the deaths of so many in her unit. I just finished Feros in ME1, haven't done any other story missions yet. I'll try to remember to get some screenies so I can properly introduce her to this thread.
Modifié par khevan, 09 octobre 2011 - 07:29 .