Skyline_Stanza wrote...
*snip*
Oh, before I forget, I've wanted to ask you this, sage. What's Kaidan's appeal? I just...well, couldn't find him interesting, even though I took the time to learn about his history and viewpoints on galatic politics and aliens in general. I'm not hating him as a character, I'm just curious to know why you think Mr. Alenko holds a special place in Kyrie's heart.
oh wow. well, to keep it as short as possible, i actually didn't even notice kaidan the first time i played ME1, but then, i missed over half of the game - i did no side quests. as soon as the aliens showed up, i ditched the humans (like so many people do - bad sage!) i thought he was the red-shirted ensign and was surprised he lasted so long. the second game i actually went and talked to him and was surprised to find a very funny and nuanced character. then i realized there was a romance written in and i was intrigued enough to follow it with that femshep. since then, all my femsheps either romance him or i stop playing them.
as i tried to indicate in my fanfic, kyrie likes him primarily because he sees her as HER. together they are able to be real and human. i think that's what i find so compelling about their story. it's really just about two people who are caught between duty and reputation, but inside that shell is a real person that gets ignored. add in that kyrie - like kaidan - is a messy past and he's the first person who isn't intimidated by her and she's a goner. it think it's sweet. and despite admitting that asari are attractive, kyrie is definitely into men, which is hard because she tends to scare the h*ll out of them.
i actually think that the games do a good job making LIs who are good matches for femshep. i mean, really, who could keep up with her? i think garrus, liara, and thane can. liara is sweet, and i think she and femshep have a special something. garrus and thane, too.
i guess i liked kaidan best because he wasn't a perfect fit and there was this tension there to me between the two of them about who is really "in charge." i dunno if i'm imposing traditional gender roles or what, but i feel like kaidan has a slightly "old fashioned chivalry" sort of vibe and i actually like that. femshep can be overwhelming, but kaidan doesn't take any crap from her - he also seems to want to protect her, even as he knows she can handle herself. while i initially hated the way he "second guessed" every dang thing shepard did (or seemed to), i later came to appreciate the honest opinion. i think
this chapter pretty much summed up where i think their relationship was before the attack on the normandy. after...dunno. i'm waiting on BW for closure, since i'm holding out hope kaidan/femshep will get the same love liara/femshep did.
but i will be the first to acknowledge that kaidan is a really hard character to get to know. you pretty much have to play femshep and romance him to see the more nuanced sides of his introverted character. he's really funny in a deadpan, sarcastic way, and his relaxed confidence and complete calm under fire is almost uncanny. basically, he's the kind of person who makes for a good long-term friend, not the flashy kind of person who draws attention to himself at the party. he's more the guy in the corner nursing the same beer all night long that shepard ends up getting a ride home with and then he manages to score her number and a coffee date as he drops her off.
huh. didn't i write that into my fanfic? i swear i did, or something like it.
edit: oh, and pretty much taking kaidan and liara as your squad = awesome. some of the BEST banter evar, kaidan at his funniest, and lots of things flying around and glowings of blue. it is the best squad ever.
well, anyhow. that probably meshes as much with the kaidan thread as it does here. if you want more answers, ask there. you'll get flooded with them.
Modifié par sagequeen, 29 octobre 2010 - 02:51 .