Modifié par yukidama, 03 décembre 2010 - 07:52 .
lastpatriot wrote...
The part that just got me was where Shep says how Kaidan knows her and that she would only be working with Cerberus if there wasn't another option. Kaidan's response just didn't appear in character. After all they went through together, you would think he would trust the women he loved to at lease consider that what she was doing was the right thing.
His response just struck me as shallow.
kraidy1117 wrote...
Horizonendingwriting was poopy.
Modifié par Chignon, 03 décembre 2010 - 07:57 .
yukidama wrote...
I think this is more of a general question, but has anyone played a Ruthless Shepard as a paragon? I kind of have some ideas for my character's RP, but how does it work in the game?
Very succinct. I agree.kraidy1117 wrote...
Horizon ending was poopy.
Modifié par cgrimm54, 03 décembre 2010 - 07:59 .
Chignon wrote...
lastpatriot wrote...
The part that just got me was where Shep says how Kaidan knows her and that she would only be working with Cerberus if there wasn't another option. Kaidan's response just didn't appear in character. After all they went through together, you would think he would trust the women he loved to at lease consider that what she was doing was the right thing.
His response just struck me as shallow.
He's just supposed to trust her because she tells him to? You have to consider that Shepard is the one who turns up out of nowhere after two years of being believed to be dead without ever contacting him even though she had a chance to and she turns up with Cerberus on top of that. Cerberus who conducted more than questionable experiments and operations in ME1 if you recall.
But I agree with you on one point; namely that his response was somewhat out of character. My take on this is that if Kaidan would have listened to what Shepard had to say, he would have understood what she was trying to do. He is a very sensible person after all. If he had listened there would have been no reason to be mad at him, though - not one that I can think of now anyway - and thus no shove towards the "more compelling" LIs of ME2.
EDITkraidy1117 wrote...
Horizonendingwriting was poopy.
JamieCOTC wrote...
Some dialogue was knocked out of the ball park, but other parts were like cat sh*t on a hot summer day.
JamieCOTC wrote...
Chignon wrote...
lastpatriot wrote...
The part that just got me was where Shep says how Kaidan knows her and that she would only be working with Cerberus if there wasn't another option. Kaidan's response just didn't appear in character. After all they went through together, you would think he would trust the women he loved to at lease consider that what she was doing was the right thing.
His response just struck me as shallow.
He's just supposed to trust her because she tells him to? You have to consider that Shepard is the one who turns up out of nowhere after two years of being believed to be dead without ever contacting him even though she had a chance to and she turns up with Cerberus on top of that. Cerberus who conducted more than questionable experiments and operations in ME1 if you recall.
But I agree with you on one point; namely that his response was somewhat out of character. My take on this is that if Kaidan would have listened to what Shepard had to say, he would have understood what she was trying to do. He is a very sensible person after all. If he had listened there would have been no reason to be mad at him, though - not one that I can think of now anyway - and thus no shove towards the "more compelling" LIs of ME2.
EDITkraidy1117 wrote...
Horizonendingwriting was poopy.
A lot of Shepard's dialogue was poopy. Some dialogue was knocked out of the ball park, but other parts were like cat sh*t on a hot summer day.
I loved Horizon, until we met VS, then everything went to hellChignon wrote...
lastpatriot wrote...
The part that just got me was where Shep says how Kaidan knows her and that she would only be working with Cerberus if there wasn't another option. Kaidan's response just didn't appear in character. After all they went through together, you would think he would trust the women he loved to at lease consider that what she was doing was the right thing.
His response just struck me as shallow.
He's just supposed to trust her because she tells him to? You have to consider that Shepard is the one who turns up out of nowhere after two years of being believed to be dead without ever contacting him even though she had a chance to and she turns up with Cerberus on top of that. Cerberus who conducted more than questionable experiments and operations in ME1 if you recall.
But I agree with you on one point; namely that his response was somewhat out of character. My take on this is that if Kaidan would have listened to what Shepard had to say, he would have understood what she was trying to do. He is a very sensible person after all. If he had listened there would have been no reason to be mad at him, though - not one that I can think of now anyway - and thus no shove towards the "more compelling" LIs of ME2.
EDITkraidy1117 wrote...
Horizonendingwriting was poopy.
Modifié par kraidy1117, 03 décembre 2010 - 08:10 .
Chignon wrote...
My take on this is that if Kaidan would have listened to what Shepard had to say, he would have understood what she was trying to do. He is a very sensible person after all. If he had listened there would have been no reason to be mad at him, though - not one that I can think of now anyway - and thus no shove towards the "more compelling" LIs of ME2.
I still think the option of asking can asari mate with other asari takes prize for the most stupid line in the seriesShenzi wrote...
@Jamie - There were multiple spots in ME2 where I literally facepalmed over Shepard's dialogue.
![=]](https://lvlt.forum.bioware.com/public/style_emoticons/default/sideways.png)
I don’t know that his response was out of character. Kaiden always struck me as sensible for the most part but also very naive, idealistic and of course loyal to the Alliance. Working with Cerberus would be against everything he stands for and believes in. I don’t think he would approve even if he did let you explain. It’s also not the only time he gets pissed off and talks in that tone to shep. If you take him with you to face Saren and then opt to let the council die for whatever reason he very definitely disapproves (unless you renegade him)Chignon wrote...
lastpatriot wrote...
The part that just got me was where Shep says how Kaidan knows her and that she would only be working with Cerberus if there wasn't another option. Kaidan's response just didn't appear in character. After all they went through together, you would think he would trust the women he loved to at lease consider that what she was doing was the right thing.
His response just struck me as shallow.
He's just supposed to trust her because she tells him to? You have to consider that Shepard is the one who turns up out of nowhere after two years of being believed to be dead without ever contacting him even though she had a chance to and she turns up with Cerberus on top of that. Cerberus who conducted more than questionable experiments and operations in ME1 if you recall.
But I agree with you on one point; namely that his response was somewhat out of character. My take on this is that if Kaidan would have listened to what Shepard had to say, he would have understood what she was trying to do. He is a very sensible person after all. If he had listened there would have been no reason to be mad at him, though - not one that I can think of now anyway - and thus no shove towards the "more compelling" LIs of ME2.
Modifié par Manic Sheep, 03 décembre 2010 - 08:20 .
Didn't whoever you asked that kind of give you the 'WTF?' face?kraidy1117 wrote...
I still think the option of asking can asari mate with other asari takes prize for the most stupid line in the seriesShenzi wrote...
@Jamie - There were multiple spots in ME2 where I literally facepalmed over Shepard's dialogue.
It's during a conversation with Liara in ME, one of the options is to ask her that question, thankfully it's optonal, but still.....cgrimm54 wrote...
Didn't whoever you asked that kind of give you the 'WTF?' face?kraidy1117 wrote...
I still think the option of asking can asari mate with other asari takes prize for the most stupid line in the seriesShenzi wrote...
@Jamie - There were multiple spots in ME2 where I literally facepalmed over Shepard's dialogue.
I don't remember who it was...
ADLegend21 wrote...
Maybe this is because I played me2 first, but I liked working with Cerberus more than working with the Alliance. The council held you back and didn't beleive you even when you had evidence to suggest that they should, TIM comes right out and says "the reapers are back, we need to stop them" no BS involved, just calculated risks and challenged for shep. Just like Shepard said in me1 I beleive "the council can kiss my ass!" I do wish the vs survivr could have been persusded to join you though cuz that'd be amazing.
Because, you know, Asari definitely weren't able to breed until they met other species... And to think Shepard graduated from N7 and is the best humanity had to offer...kraidy1117 wrote...
It's during a conversation with Liara in ME, one of the options is to ask her that question, thankfully it's optonal, but still.....cgrimm54 wrote...
Didn't whoever you asked that kind of give you the 'WTF?' face?kraidy1117 wrote...
I still think the option of asking can asari mate with other asari takes prize for the most stupid line in the seriesShenzi wrote...
@Jamie - There were multiple spots in ME2 where I literally facepalmed over Shepard's dialogue.
I don't remember who it was...
Modifié par cgrimm54, 03 décembre 2010 - 08:22 .
ADLegend21 wrote...
Maybe this is because I played me2 first, but I liked working with Cerberus more than working with the Alliance. The council held you back and didn't beleive you even when you had evidence to suggest that they should, TIM comes right out and says "the reapers are back, we need to stop them" no BS involved, just calculated risks and challenged for shep. Just like Shepard said in me1 I beleive "the council can kiss my ass!" I do wish the vs survivr could have been persusded to join you though cuz that'd be amazing.
More so if you talked to Avina and you knew about the genophageyukidama wrote...
The dialogue with Wrex about the genophage had me facepalming so hard I think my hand temporarily melded to my head. Shepard has some moments where her foot is so far into her mouth she can kick her own kidneys.
Retour en haut