Wowlock wrote...
She is young,beautiful , manipulative , seductive , doesn't care about love , more into the intimate stuff.
That can explain it.
In Exile wrote...
Svest wrote...
All it is is an alternate ritual. Besides, as i said it took me 5 min to come up with something slightly plausable, how long do you think it would take a real writer to come up with something good? Not very. You are right in that I'm pulling stuff out of my ass. I'm not a writer and you guys are nitpicking what the hell do you expect?
It's slightly plausible in the same way my laser beam from space scenario is plausible: there are few things that explicitly contradict it, since you seem to reject reasonable inference as a possible critique.
Since what you did was actually good or plausible in any meaingful sense of the word, whether or not a real writer could even do it is up for debate.
We're not nitpicking. We're saying the idea is bad. You could re-animate Shakespeare and it wouldn't do you much good.Actually, if you paid attention to the story in game we do have very strong indication of that. Or how do you explain the AD's sould going to Morrigan's child when you perform the normal DR? The warden is still closer to the AD, yet somehow the soul goes to Morrigan. If you accept "magic" as the answer to this, then what's wrong with accepting it as the answer to the other problem?
According to David, what was supposed to happen is that the soul first goes to the Warden, and then goes to the baby. The Warden is a conduit, so to speak, and it is through that the Warden lives. Since this was cut for a variety of reasons, David said players are free to imagine what they like... but that is the authorial intent.
So we are right back to what I said responding to your first point.
And I don't accept "magic" as an answer to anything. Magic, in RPGs, is nothing like "poof" magic. It has rules; it's like metaphysical engineering.
Tirigon wrote...
Wowlock wrote...
She is young,beautiful , manipulative , seductive , doesn't care about love , more into the intimate stuff.
That can explain it.
Wouldn´t that make everyone like her?
At least in Real Life the girls with these characteristics are usually the ones with the most lovers......
Svest wrote...
LOL so what you're saying is that when you do the DR the old god's sould first goes into the Warden and then into Morrigan. Hmm where have I heard that before? Ohh yeah that's exactly what I said would happen for my proposed ritual too.
So why is it you are fine with the magic doing it one way but not another? You are making no sense. Just because you personally don't want the god child story line to continue (and I might even agree with you there) doesn't mean there doesn't exist a plausable way for it to happen.
You have rejected the idea of a god child outright and therefore will nitpick to find any flaw, no matter how minor, in any explanation offered for how it could happen. At least Ryzaki's nitpicking is amusing, you're just spouting nonsense.
Wowlock wrote...
She is young,beautiful , manipulative , seductive , doesn't care about love , more into the intimate stuff.
That can explain it.
Modifié par Ahisgewaya, 21 juillet 2010 - 08:50 .
Tirigon wrote...
Wowlock wrote...
She is young,beautiful , manipulative , seductive , doesn't care about love , more into the intimate stuff.
That can explain it.
Wouldn´t that make everyone like her?
At least in Real Life the girls with these characteristics are usually the ones with the most lovers......
Ryzaki wrote...
Tirigon wrote...
Wowlock wrote...
She is young,beautiful , manipulative , seductive , doesn't care about love , more into the intimate stuff.
That can explain it.
Wouldn´t that make everyone like her?
At least in Real Life the girls with these characteristics are usually the ones with the most lovers......
There's a difference between liking someone and wanting to screw them. I'm sure she'd get a lot of the latter and but not so much of the former. Not many people like a b****.,
Ahisgewaya wrote...
See, that's just it though. She didn't come off as a **** to me, just a very strong woman who sees no reason for love. Everything she does is practical and makes sense. If you take the time to actually, you know, be nice to her then she becomes a more interesting character, but she's never a normal person. That would be impossible with her upbringing, power, and intelligence. I really don't get why more people don't like her.
Modifié par Quinnzel, 21 juillet 2010 - 09:13 .
Quinnzel wrote...
Ahisgewaya wrote...
See, that's just it though. She didn't come off as a **** to me, just a very strong woman who sees no reason for love. Everything she does is practical and makes sense. If you take the time to actually, you know, be nice to her then she becomes a more interesting character, but she's never a normal person. That would be impossible with her upbringing, power, and intelligence. I really don't get why more people don't like her.
The bit that really made me love Morrigan is when, after shes told you the tale regarding the Mirror she stole (which Flemmeth destroyed) and you find one like it in Orzammar, giving her it she sounds truly thankful, and sad at the life she doesnt know, and is perhaps a small moment of genuine charecter redemeption for those that didnt already like her (IMO anyway)
Im totally biased in anycase. Claudia Black in anything makes me go all fuzzy inside.
In Exile wrote...
Svest wrote...
LOL so what you're saying is that when you do the DR the old god's sould first goes into the Warden and then into Morrigan. Hmm where have I heard that before? Ohh yeah that's exactly what I said would happen for my proposed ritual too.
No, you came up with some stupid "Morrigan is a sniper!" theory and she secretly carried out this elaborate blood magic ritual (according to David, that was what the ritual was supposed to be - it was cut to sex for the purpose of brevity) against his will.
Your theory is terrible not becaue it involves the soul going into the Warden and then into the baby through the power of the ritual, but because you want some contrived BS scenario where this always happens.
To be blunt: your attempt at a retcon is what is stupid, not David's process.So why is it you are fine with the magic doing it one way but not another? You are making no sense. Just because you personally don't want the god child story line to continue (and I might even agree with you there) doesn't mean there doesn't exist a plausable way for it to happen.
What the hell are you talking about? I happen to love the gold child, and actually hoped DA2 would go the voiced protagonist route not with Hawke, but with god child. I just want a cannon ending instead of a stupid ending.You have rejected the idea of a god child outright and therefore will nitpick to find any flaw, no matter how minor, in any explanation offered for how it could happen. At least Ryzaki's nitpicking is amusing, you're just spouting nonsense.
Or you could just be wrong. Yeah, let's go with you being wrong, since you apparently base all of this on my hating a character I like.
Modifié par Svest, 21 juillet 2010 - 11:14 .
would probably be pretty lame.
Modifié par Who is that Masked Man, 22 juillet 2010 - 12:37 .
Quinnzel wrote...
Aaaand naow all the fangirls come out to gloat *Gets hitting stick* lol, though Im finally glad to know (and really some of the speculation in this thread...totally out there)
SDNcN wrote...
Quinnzel wrote...
Aaaand naow all the fangirls come out to gloat *Gets hitting stick* lol, though Im finally glad to know (and really some of the speculation in this thread...totally out there)
The Ultimate Defense: "So Alistair, whose better in bed, Morrigan or the Warden?."
Retour en haut
