Aller au contenu

Photo

The Best of Football - An ongoing discussion -


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
4117 réponses à ce sujet

#3626
Guest_Lathrim_*

Guest_Lathrim_*
  • Guests
I'd argue that extracting the best from the players in his disposal is the bare minimum a manager should be able to do. I don't intend to say Guardiola isn't good - he most definitely is a great coach. However, I do believe he is also overrated. The team he had is easily the best of the decade! Everyone was in form, Puyol and Xavi didn't fall out by the end of the season as they do now... 10/11 was outright magical. Things are very different now - Barcelona is showing signs of aging. Last season proved that.

That having been said, I see Barca improving as 13/14 goes on. Their biggest challenge is keeping their defenders and Messi safe from exhaustion and/or injuries. If Tata manages to do that, I think they'll go far this time.

Modifié par Lathrim, 17 octobre 2013 - 01:21 .


#3627
Druss99

Druss99
  • Members
  • 6 390 messages
I'd agree with Lathrim, Guardiola had three of the best players in the world playing at their peak, well maybe Messi's peak is still to come he is relatively young. But what competition was there for Barca when Guardiola was in charge? Real were splashing millions but hadn't really built a team, more a collection of individuals. United were having midfield issues. Arsenal were being Arsenal. Chelsea and Inter were waiting for luck to carry them. Juventus and AC Milan weren't what they once were. Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund were still building towards what they now are. PSG, Monaco and Man City weren't there yet. Who were really the competition for a team with the three best players in the world and the ability to tap up any player they want without any fear of punishment?

I'd argue that Guardiola saw the transition coming from the Xavi/Iniesta/Messi era and got out before the going got tough.

Not sure how it relates to United at all, other than Sir Alex got the best from a team that has gaping holes that need addressing.

Messi's early season injury might do Barca a lot of good. Neymar looked like he has shown he can step up without Messi when I saw them and it gives Messi a bit of a break already.

#3628
Guest_Lathrim_*

Guest_Lathrim_*
  • Guests

Druss99 wrote...
Messi's early season injury might do Barca a lot of good. Neymar looked like he has shown he can step up without Messi when I saw them and it gives Messi a bit of a break already.


Agreed. Those theoretical breaks might just prevent another humbling, too. I do think it'd be pretty funny to see Guardiola's Bayern do the same thing Heynckes' did to Barca last season, though. :P

#3629
Druss99

Druss99
  • Members
  • 6 390 messages
I generally find it amusing when anyone humbles Barca :P Except teams managed by Mourinho then it's just tedious. There's rumours that Barca have signed Hummels for next season.

Also rumours that United are signing Bruno Gomes today. Very highly rated young Brazilian striker. I think he is only 17 or 18, but half of Europe are after him apparently.

#3630
Guest_Lathrim_*

Guest_Lathrim_*
  • Guests
Well, if that's true (I'm not really sure just how likely that is), Dortmund are losing too many key players, too quickly. Götze's gone to Bayern, Lewandowski is almost there... all they have to do is lose Gündoğan and Reus.

Barcelona have also been linked to Ter Stegen, who plays for Borussia Mönchengladbach, by the way.

And speaking of Barca and goalkeepers, I love how Valdés is having the season of his career right when he decides it'll be his last for the club.

#3631
Guest_modjospinster_*

Guest_modjospinster_*
  • Guests
Well Guardiola did have a great team, with many players in great form, but that team was very similar to the one the year before. Rijkaard had a very good team, but Guardiola literally won everything in a couple years time. The fact that R. Madrid was doing poor is irrelevent because they don't play each other every weekend. I guess I won't be able to convince yall of how good this team was, but when I see teams these days try and play tiki-taka, they are all imposters of the real deal. Druss I hear what you are saying but it all sounds like excuses for why teams weren't that good or weren't challanges to Barca. Excuses are like butt holes. We all have them and they all stink.

How it doesn't relate to United??? Sir Alex is gone, same group of individuals, and they are currently 8 in the table. Barca won the league the year after Guardiola left. We all know Man U would be in the top 4 right now if Sir Alex was still in charge.

But alas! I am no longer interested in talking about how overrated you guys think Guardiola is, so I am dropping the matter.

I also agree that Messi's injury might help Neymar grow, even though I didn't know he was injured.

The other day I read an interview with Mourinho where he says that a club team can't just abandon the way its people play, and after watching the first half of Roma Napoli I could not help but agree. By the way, I think Benitez is doing ok with Napoli. I didn't think he was a good fit at Liverpool, but I thought the much better team during the first half was Napoli. The Italian style of football is more methodical. Its slower, but you can see the play starts from the defense. Roma were absolutely terrible, and I am saying that about a team which is one of my favorites clubs. I didn't watch the second half partly because I had homework to do, but also because they made me so angry to watch them!!! Terrible!!! They tried to play fast, to catch the other team on their heels I am guessing, but it just didn't work. As I try and hone my offense in bball, I know that I am trying to get the defenders to bite, to take the bate. I want them to go after me, so I can either go in with a move or pass it to an open teammate. Roma players would have the ball, no defenders pressing them, then pass it to a player who was well covered. WTF???!!!!!! If no one is guarding you, take it up field, if/when the defenders go in to press, then you pass it. Draw the defense away from someone else, so your teammates could then go to space, and as a unit, you all move upfield. I understand what Roma was trying to do. Play fast so the defense is trying to catch up to all the movements...but tsk tsk, the manager is a poor student. You don't start fast, you go upfield, it doesn't matter if the buildup is slow, but once you see that opening, once your teammate make the right run, then is when you act and go full speed. I'm a little more wary to describe how to attack, because what if I get the call to go learn from a top manager in Europe??? Can't give away all my secrets, right?? lol

Modifié par modjospinster, 20 octobre 2013 - 02:27 .


#3632
Druss99

Druss99
  • Members
  • 6 390 messages
8th in the table in October, not exactly that shocking. The greatest manager of all time is gone, Moyes was left with one world class player(maybe two with De Gea) and one good midfielder while almost every other team in the league spent big. Ferdinand looks like he is past it, Evans and Rafael were injured most of the season and Vidic is still trying to get back to his best. Then in attack Nani was injured, Valencia is actually better than he was last season, Rooney seems to be getting shoehorned in to please his ego which keeps Kagawa out of the side, but Welbeck already has scored more than last season and we have seen Januzaj come through and sign a new contract. Our administrative changes seemed to screw Moyes over in the transfer market too. That's a stark contrast to being handed Messi, Xavi and Iniesta. Two months into his first season is no time to say Moyes can't get the best from his players.

Roma won 2-0 despite losing Totti early to a hamstring injury, so they can't have been that terrible. Also Benitez won the Champions League with Liverpool, took them to 2nd in the league and had their most successful spell in years, that seems like a pretty decent fit.

Did anyone see Stefan Kiessling's(I've probably butchered the English spelling of that) ghost goal for Bayer Leverkusen? It was bizarre to say the least, I've actually been awarded several of those but usually from blasting the ball from an angle so hard it goes through the net and looks like it goes in. But seeing it happen in a professional game and how it happened is just so strange.

The Eto'o goal yesterday just shows how fast the game is, if the ref turns his head for a split second the rules can fall apart. You'd think one of the linsmen or the fourth official would have seen what happened. The keeper had the ball so someone must have been looking at him.

#3633
Guest_KnossosTNC_*

Guest_KnossosTNC_*
  • Guests
Wild weekend of European football. Hoffenheim being reminded to buy a better net. Juventus suffered a 15-minute moment of insanity. Zlatan showed he's made of rubber and magic. Eto'o committed daylight robbery, while Jose got sent off - again. Newcastle nearly beat Liverpool with a man down. Arsenal added two more entries to the highlight reels. God damn, I love this game.

Speaking of Arsenal, it continues to confound me what a difference a signing made. One minute they were losing to Villa, and it was all doom and gloom and "sign some friggin' players." Then Oezil came along, and all of sudden we witnessed the Giroud and Wilshere Show while Ramsey channelled Maradona. Watching Arsenal play like this, it... ...it... *sniff* ...brings a tear to my eye. Still, I'm not delusional; tougher tests are ahead, starting with Dortmund. But maybe, just maybe, can I dare to dream?

Overall, a nearly perfect sporting weekend for me (damn you, Real Madrid!). In particular, the latest stumble by Man United inspired my favourite quote of the weekend; a Twitter post something along the lines of "If Southampton are to compete for a Champions League place, they need to be beating these mid-table sides." Ouch.

Still, I think United are making a little bit more progress; the RVP-Rooney-Januzaj combo looked lively, and they were unlucky to not score a second goal. However, that gaping hole of a midfield is reaching crisis point; when you are letting Southampton dominate possession at your home turf, you know you have a depth problem in that area. Personally, they need someone to take charge of that midfield. Someone who will lay down the law and not let sides like West Brom and Southampton run wild in the middle of the park. Someone who can take the ball in his own half, and with one pass start orchestrating a dangerous-looking counter-attack. Someone who can look after business in the midfield, allowing players around him space and confidence to do their own things.

In short, they need Paul Scholes. Anybody got his mobile number?

Modifié par KnossosTNC, 20 octobre 2013 - 09:43 .


#3634
Guest_KnossosTNC_*

Guest_KnossosTNC_*
  • Guests
Truth be told, I'm a bit apprehensive about today's Dortmund game. They look like they haven't weakened a bit since last season's run to the final, and Arsenal are missing the steel (Flamini) they're going to need if things get tight.

On the other hand, Arsenal are playing at home. Hopefully the home crowd will give them a lift.

#3635
cato potato

cato potato
  • Members
  • 3 932 messages

Druss99 wrote...

8th in the table in October, not exactly that shocking. The greatest manager of all time is gone, Moyes was left with one world class player(maybe two with De Gea) and one good midfielder while almost every other team in the league spent big. Ferdinand looks like he is past it, Evans and Rafael were injured most of the season and Vidic is still trying to get back to his best. Then in attack Nani was injured, Valencia is actually better than he was last season, Rooney seems to be getting shoehorned in to please his ego which keeps Kagawa out of the side, but Welbeck already has scored more than last season and we have seen Januzaj come through and sign a new contract. Our administrative changes seemed to screw Moyes over in the transfer market too. That's a stark contrast to being handed Messi, Xavi and Iniesta. Two months into his first season is no time to say Moyes can't get the best from his players.


I agree with your analysis above. The struggle so far this season for your team has only managed to enhance Sir Furious's reputation even further - God knows how he won the league with that team.
I think the biggest issue was United being too cheap to buyout the final couple of months of Moyes's contract with Everton. That meant he coudn't get into the club in time to change the setup to his liking and gave him not enough time to bring in his players.

I've also read about ManU supposedly getting Mario Gomes from that Brazilian youth team. If they want him then they'll definitely get him, United have invested in that club and have first refusal on a few players - Gomes is one of them.
He is extremely highly rated but a lot of South American players with a lot of promise have struggled when they've moved to Europe.

I'd also like to take this opportunity to point out a couple of previous comments from me in this thread - Liverpool can't possibly challenge for the title this year & Arsene Wenger will be sacked before the end of the season.

I know nothing.

Modifié par cato_84, 23 octobre 2013 - 06:46 .


#3636
Druss99

Druss99
  • Members
  • 6 390 messages
^ Haven't heard anything about Gomes since then.

I think the cheapness problem may go a bit beyond Moyes contract, I suspect he wasn't given enough money to spend in the summer and was thus priced out of every move he tried to make. Then he wound up panic buying Fellaini at an inflated price.

Anyone see Rooney's latest utter stupidity? How he got away with that I'll never know.

#3637
Guest_KnossosTNC_*

Guest_KnossosTNC_*
  • Guests

Druss99 wrote...

^ Haven't heard anything about Gomes since then.

I think the cheapness problem may go a bit beyond Moyes contract, I suspect he wasn't given enough money to spend in the summer and was thus priced out of every move he tried to make. Then he wound up panic buying Fellaini at an inflated price.

Anyone see Rooney's latest utter stupidity? How he got away with that I'll never know.


Not surprised, to be honest. I've always respected his passion and work rate, but such a personality is always going to be prone to let his emotions get the better of him. To me, it was a straight red. Maybe the fact that it happened in the 8th minute had an influence and the referee didn't want to ruin the game by dishing out red so early? Maybe he was unsighted in some way? Either way, it is as the old saying goes; "he's a lucky, lucky boy."

Oh, and yay for Arsenal. What was Boruc thinking? Cracking Merseyside derby, brilliant. Put Mirallas in with Rooney in the "Lucky Boys Club." Tottenham being Tottenham again. Can't help but feel like if City could play away the same way they played at home, they would be title contenders right now. I don't think AVB's up for the sack yet, but Jol definitely is.

Phew! I think I wrapped that up pretty well.

#3638
Guest_modjospinster_*

Guest_modjospinster_*
  • Guests
Its good to see some people have posted! I was just about to pose the question....

What do yall think of the new france kits?

Posted Image

I think the color combinations look nice but the shirt looks to plain to me. I also don't like how its cut. Too much up top and it narrows a lot by the waist. and the green boots...just no. lol

ive always thought roma usually gets really nice kits

Posted Image

i dont really know wats going on in the picture though hehe

#3639
DragonRageGT

DragonRageGT
  • Members
  • 6 070 messages
Hi guys! Been busy but it is coming .. Brasil 2014!

And nobody play it like us! =))



#3640
Kaiser Arian XVII

Kaiser Arian XVII
  • Members
  • 17 286 messages
Oh wait.. half of the Brazil stadiums aren't rebuilt yet and only one month remained to 2014.

And I like the players of Portugal and the Germany as a whole team.

#3641
DragonRageGT

DragonRageGT
  • Members
  • 6 070 messages

Kaiser Arian wrote...

Oh wait.. half of the Brazil stadiums aren't rebuilt yet and only one month remained to 2014.

And I like the players of Portugal and the Germany as a whole team.


Few days to 2014 but six months to the WC opening. No worries. No one has the "jeitinho" like us as well! lol  They will be ready.

#3642
Guest_Lathrim_*

Guest_Lathrim_*
  • Guests
So, I heard Ashley Young is scoring goals. Young. Scoring. What is this?!

#3643
Druss99

Druss99
  • Members
  • 6 390 messages
Not just goals, absolute rockets. He was utter turd right up until the second he scored the first one too. I dunno what's gotten into him.

Only a couple of weeks until the madness of the January transfer window and chairmen are panicking, trying to get new managers in before it all begins, to try and give them time to use it. I wouldn't be surprised to see a couple more sackings in the next few weeks.

Credit to Moyes, he hasn't set the world on fire, but there's players that Sir Alex couldn't get anything out of last season that Moyes is getting a steady improvement from. Mostly Tony V and he's got Welbeck scoring again.

Modifié par Druss99, 22 décembre 2013 - 11:02 .


#3644
Guest_KnossosTNC_*

Guest_KnossosTNC_*
  • Guests
What a season so far. It's so tight at the top that Liverpool, who were top of the table at Christmas, are now fifth and six points behind. If they're still in the title race as they claim, then even United, Tottenham and Newcastle who are only within three points behind have to be in the conversation, as unlikely as that all sounds. Meanwhile, just two points separates the top three. Madness. Looking forward to today's games.

#3645
cato potato

cato potato
  • Members
  • 3 932 messages

KnossosTNC wrote...

What a season so far. It's so tight at the top that Liverpool, who were top of the table at Christmas, are now fifth and six points behind. If they're still in the title race as they claim, then even United, Tottenham and Newcastle who are only within three points behind have to be in the conversation, as unlikely as that all sounds. Meanwhile, just two points separates the top three. Madness. Looking forward to today's games.


I can't see United winning the title this year, just getting in the top 4 will be tough. Although they just got knocked out the FA cup by Swansea so they don't have a lot else to concentrate on.

I'm starting to hope Arsenal win but if Man City's away form gets closer to their home form then they'll be unstoppable.

Sad to hear Eusebio passed away today. A truly legendary player.

#3646
Kimosabe

Kimosabe
  • Members
  • 1 162 messages
Indeed sad news of Eusebio's passing away, he played way before my time but for players like him that doesn't matter, everybody knows who he was.

Another piece of news: Lewandovski moves to Bayern..
There was a lot of speculation last year but I was happy that he didn't do it, in my opinion it is an idiotic move. Sure, Bayern is the best club in the world at the moment but they already have 2 teams worth of players who can win the Bundesliga.. In Dortmund he could do something, in Bayern he is just another player. You only have to look at Gotze for proof of that..

The Premier League definitly is intersting this year with Liverpool doing very well and United being rubbish. I kinda hope Arsenal picks the title this year out of sheer spite for Van Persie and because I really don't like those billionaire playtoys like City..

The first half of this season has been interesting to say the least here in The Netherlands.
for about 10 matches or so PEC Zwolle, a club that normally fights against relegation stood in the top 3 and on occasions even on top.
And up until that point, maybe 8 points separated the 1st from the 16th place..
Pretty much everyone is beating everyone else.. one round you lose 5-1 against a relegation candidate and the next you win 2-0 against a championship contender..

PSV is laughable this year, after 18 matches they have 27 points and are 7th. If it wasn't for the sudden turn around 2 matches ago they wouldn't even be in the top 10.. Plus, to add injury, they totally fcked up in Europe. They needed only 1 point to advance to the next round against some unknown eastern European club and they couldn't even manage that..

At the moment, Ajax in first with Vitesse on the same points and Twente and Feyenoord following on 3 and 4 points. 5 points separate the 6th from the 13th place and 3 points is the difference between direct relegation and avoiding even the playoffs for it..
So it should be an interesting second half when they resume.

Modifié par Kimosabe0, 06 janvier 2014 - 12:21 .


#3647
Kaiser Arian XVII

Kaiser Arian XVII
  • Members
  • 17 286 messages
RIP Eusebio. I never knew him, just I'h heard his name many times.

PSV doesn't have many great players, so one shouldn't expect much from them... worse is Werder Bremen. Their best player is Aaron Hunt right now! Imagine what a great team Bremen is ... (compare it with the time when Klasnic, Klose, Borowski, Mertersacker and other great players were there. Ten years ago: 2004).

Hail Arsenal... Keep me proud!

Real Madrid, Keep up the good work!

At the moment, Bayern is p*ssing me off. Now they've got Lewandowski from Dortmund. Bayern is actually dumbing down every other team in Bundesliga >:(

@DragonRageGT, cool.

#3648
Guest_KnossosTNC_*

Guest_KnossosTNC_*
  • Guests

cato_84 wrote...

I can't see United winning the title this year, just getting in the top 4 will be tough. Although they just got knocked out the FA cup by Swansea so they don't have a lot else to concentrate on.

I'm starting to hope Arsenal win but if Man City's away form gets closer to their home form then they'll be unstoppable.

Sad to hear Eusebio passed away today. A truly legendary player.


Yup, just as I posted that, United went and lost to Tottenham and then two subsequent games in FA Cup and League Cup, and are out contention again. This really is a "blink and you'll miss it" kind of season.

Yeah, one does get a feeling that the title is Man City's to lose - as long as they kind fix their away form.

And yeah, RIP Eusebio. He was well before my time, but even I have heard of his performance against North Korea at the 66 World Cup. Legendary.

Modifié par KnossosTNC, 11 janvier 2014 - 04:51 .


#3649
modjospinnin

modjospinnin
  • Members
  • 49 messages
Saw the second half of United's games against Swansea.

I mean, what can I say that hasn't been said before? However, I was very impressed by number 44 on the left. Very good awareness and heads up. His cross to that one guy was on a platter, but he didn't convert. Welbeck is easily the main striker, he should have a load of goals already. I don't think the current manager really has the chops. How is Rafael still the starter. I never thought he was good enough.

I've seen even less of the spanish league...but from the little I have seen CR7 seems to be finally turning up.

I've seen even less of calcio italiano.

World Cup this year, can't wait.

Still can't believe Qatar was able to buy themselves a WC. Its in an 3ffing desert!!!!!!

Modifié par modjospinnin, 13 janvier 2014 - 05:05 .


#3650
Kaiser Arian XVII

Kaiser Arian XVII
  • Members
  • 17 286 messages
@modjospinnin, deal with Qatar!

I'm only able to watch European championship league matches and Bundesliga mostly. Other matches may be shown by TV channel managers decision (saturday-sunday matches).

Surely Ronaldo should win that prize over Messi this year. Ronaldo was really great the whole year.