271 réponses à ce sujet

[Forst1999]

If it would just be about who i don't like it would be Zaeed, Grunt and Jack. But it should be:

Samara: She is old and will see it as her responsibility as a Justicar to die for someone else.

Thane: He is dying already.

No.3: Grunt would propably enjoy it. Legion might be reloaded, who knows? Mordin is pretty old too.

[Fiery Phoenix]

LMAO!! Jacob's name is glowing in every single post here!

[Kikaimegami]

This all depends on the situation.

For the Suicide Mission in ME2 (if I absolutely have no other alternative than having some people die because I'd rather everyone survive):

Jacob - Snore city, doesn't bring anything beneficial to the squad that someone else can't do and do better, he creeps my FemShep right the hell out, he keeps coming to brief new squadmates--goddamnit man, you are not my XO, get back to the Armory and do your friggin job.

Thane - He's dying anyway so I'd give him a noble death fighting against the evil in the galaxy so he truly can leave the galaxy a better place than he found it.

OPTIONAL: Legion - As long as he does a backup before we head out, then I'd be willing to cut the material loss and pick him up in geth space later after he downloads to a new platform.

OPTIONAL: Miranda - If she wont step down as XO because everyone on my boat knows Garrus is really my XO, and I have this sinking feeling that despite her "quitting" Cerberus if you destroy the Collector base, she's still a TIM spy.

OPTIONAL: Samara - It just seems rather cruel that she has to live for another 500 years or more with her guilt and sadness. I'm not giving her pity, but like Thane, I'd like to give her a chance to die a noble death.


Some dramatic event in ME3 where it's the difference between sacrificing someone for the greater good or accepting defeat at the hands of the Reapers (or a high personnel cost to win):

Ashley/Kaiden - I'm sorry, but you betrayed me. Even Tali, who absolutely loathes Cerberus with every fiber of her being, was willing to give me the benefit of the doubt.

Garrus - If the event that requires a sacrifice is extremely important, I want someone I can trust to get the job done, even if they're going to die, holding the line/planting the bomb/etc. Garrus has proven that despite knowing that he will die (Omega), he will fight to the bitter end for what he believes in.

Thane - For the same reasons mentioned before, plus I know that he's willing to follow through his mission even if it means he will die. He's a very honorable individual.

OPTIONAL: Legion - As before, if he backs himself up beforehand, the material cost is inconsequential. Plus, I'd trust him to do his job to the best of his ability no matter what the circumstances are.

Modifié par Kikaimegami, 21 juillet 2010 - 01:57 .

[hottomali]

FieryPhoenix7 wrote...

LMAO!! Jacob's name is glowing in every single post here!

I quite liked Jacob's character, he is tough, brave & skilled in battle, the human equivilent of Garrus. so i am quite suprised he is so pupular for the death list, maybe its his bravery that makes him the ideal lemming ?

[Mondo47]

Well, Thane's dying anyway...

Samara's led a full life and seems very pragmatic about death.

And Ash. B*tch pissed me off with all her 'I don't trust bugeyed monsters' bullsh*t one too many times.

[Fiery Phoenix]

mashavasilec wrote...

Calling Jacob human equivalent of Garrus is a heavy risk indeed..

But the... Oh wait, there IS no prize for that!

[Kikaimegami]

Given slightly different circumstances and assuming that we don't mean my CanonShep playthrough:

Morinth - I only spared you because you'd be useful in battle, possibly moreso than your mother given your unique talents. It doesn't mean that I have to like you or believe that you deserve to live.

Mordin - Your life is more or less over, might as well go out with a bang! (This is assuming I had him destroy the genophage cure data, because if I asked him to keep it, I'd want him to survive).

Zaeed - Man, I don't care about your need for revenge. We do. Not. Sacrifice. Civilians.

[Kikaimegami]

Mondo47 wrote...

And Ash. B*tch pissed me off with all her 'I don't trust bugeyed monsters' bullsh*t one too many times.

No doubt. She is so friggin racist.

[Collider]

Thane - I love this guy, but he's already set for an early death. He's brave and would take death honorably.



Samara - Her code has her ready to give her life for innocents. She's lived longer than all of the squad. I think she would take her death with courage.



Zaeed - He's cool and everything, but he's just a merc - and one who is morally questionable.



Legion - If his data is saved, he's not really "dying."



Everyone surviving ftw, though

[Collider]

Mordin's 30 yo

[Kikaimegami]

mashavasilec wrote...

 This thread will soon come to flamewar, mark my word. I hope it will burn in fire, just like all other similar threads <_<

It wouldn't be so bad if everyone gave a summary of their reasoning like myself and Collider did, for example.

[Kronner]

Tali

Jacob

Garrus

[Yana Montana]

Kikaimegami wrote...

Mondo47 wrote...

And Ash. B*tch pissed me off with all her 'I don't trust bugeyed monsters' bullsh*t one too many times.

No doubt. She is so friggin racist.

Argh!

[LorDC]

0) Considering that Legion can always be restored from backup I'll leave him.

1) Thane - he is going to die anyway.

2) Samara - don't like that arrogant b!tch. Or Morinth - she is sociopathic b!tch.

3) Jack - one more sociopathic b!tch.

[Kikaimegami]

Yana Montana wrote...

Argh!

-facepalmsnip-

What? That certainly isn't the reason why I'd let her die, but she is totally racist in ME1. Sure, she starts getting over it, but that's only after she has already rubbed me the wrong way.

[Yana Montana]

Kikaimegami wrote...

Yana Montana wrote...

Argh!

-facepalmsnip-

What? That certainly isn't the reason why I'd let her die, but she is totally racist in ME1. Sure, she starts getting over it, but that's only after she has already rubbed me the wrong way.

Listen, I don't want this thread to turn into debate war, but this is so dumb of you to say. I am out.

[Costin_Razvan]

Is it dumb? I like Ashley, but she IS a racist.

[AntiChri5]

Ash isnt a racist, deal with it.

[Costin_Razvan]

Right, cause comparing Aliens to Dogs isn't racism, sure believe that if you will.

[wulf3n]

Costin_Razvan wrote...
Is it dumb? I like Ashley, but she IS a racist.

I wouldn't say she is racist.

With regards to Garrus, she understandably has a mistrust of Turians, given the events of the First contact war most humans do.

With regards to Wrex, he's a merc, he has no loyalty, no allegiance, he could be gathering intel on us for all we know.

Yes she doesn't trust aliens, but since she's never actually worked with them, how can you expect her to. 

[wulf3n]

Costin_Razvan wrote...
Right, cause comparing Aliens to Dogs isn't racism, sure believe that if you will.

That's just taken out of context.

edit:if anything, she's saying that she believes that aliens would consider humanity to be like dogs, and would sacrifice us for their own survival

Modifié par wulf3n, 21 juillet 2010 - 02:30 .

[Yana Montana]

Costin_Razvan wrote...

Right, cause comparing Aliens to Dogs isn't racism, sure believe that if you will.

Shepard and Turians call Hanar (stupid) jellyfish, so they are all racists? 

Modifié par Yana Montana, 21 juillet 2010 - 02:34 .

[AntiChri5]

Lets go make a seperate thread to discuss Ash's views, shall we?