[quote]Costin_Razvan wrote...
Kal Sharok had a smaller army, no Golems and no Legion to aid it against the Darkspawn and you state that they are in a bad situation because of their lack of trade?[/quote][/quote]
That is a major reason, yes. No trade means no money to finance its war.
"With far fewer resources than Orzammar and no access to the surface,
Kal-Sharok has had to do some very questionable things to survive, and
now they are changed forever. "
[quote]Costin_Razvan wrote...
As for improving their condition...Bhelen already is, by giving them actually legitimate jobs that pay.[/quote]
So you shouldn't mind Harrowmont closing off trade then.
Pay with what? How can you want him to pay if you are suggesting that he pisses on trade which is Orzammar's lifeline?
The current wealth of Orzammar cannot be redistributed radically to feed the castless and ****** everyone off. There is a limit to how much you can control a society with the army, especially since the casteless are not the only ones who can fight. The best decision is to engage in a policy of productivity that would increase wealth, and thus give Bhelen enough ressources to reform and please most dwarves at the same time.
[quote]Costin_Razvan wrote...
If wealth from trade would be something that would solve the Dwarven problems, then why is it that Genitivi proclaims that Orzammar has a vast wealth, and yet they are on the Brink, and why is that?[/quote]
Because of failed institutions and traditions. No where did I say trade was the only solution, but it's a major part of "The" solution. The wealth acquired needs to be spent adequately and not distributed almosty solely amongst nobles, since surface merchants are pretty much excluded from Orzammar (but still patronised by Nobles). Bhelen is changing that and this is how trade will help improve Orzammar's position. Because wealth is a tool and if not used properly, it can be not only useless but in some cases even detrimental. Bhelen seems to know how to use it however.
[quote]Costin_Razvan wrote...
Because Orzammar is at war, a constant endless war which you cannot end nor can you ignore your enemy. I understand you believe in moderation...but at the end of the day Bhelen is a very radical leader for Orzammar who makes MILITARY reforms. Why the merchants want to support him is unknown and it is only speculation to say that he is going to depend on them as a power base.[/quote]
Bhelen is a visionary, not a short sighted warmonger like you make it out to be.
The merchants support him because of promise of trade, it's that simple.
In anycase, like I said before, I do not want to waste my time discussing your fictional depiction of a character for an ff I am not going to read. So whatever, to put it bluntly.
Modifié par KnightofPhoenix, 14 octobre 2010 - 10:14 .