86 réponses à ce sujet

[Christmas Ape]

Quaay wrote...

Curious how Most Requested for ME3 was chosen, did people only get to vote for one person or were they ranked ?

The last question was a list of all the squadmates from both games with radio buttons, and it asked you to choose 4 or 5.

[Quaay]

Ahh thanks. That would've been hard to narrow down to just 4 or 5 for me.

[Christmas Ape]

Quaay wrote...

Ahh thanks. That would've been hard to narrow down to just 4 or 5 for me.

You and me both. There are very few I don't want to come back.

[Ieldra]

jtav wrote...
I must be the only person on the forums who hates Garrus...

Not so. You are one of the 13 "hate" votes (if you voted that way), I am one of the 9 "dislike" votes. We should feel special

[Estelindis]

Interesting! Thanks for all that hard work.

[Siansonea]

Well, it's official. Tali is literally the lowest-common-denominator male LI. I'm so surprised. Not.



Great work on the poll and in presenting the results. Much appreciated.

[Christmas Ape]

Siansonea II wrote...

Well, it's official. Tali is literally the lowest-common-denominator male LI. I'm so surprised. Not.

Great work on the poll and in presenting the results. Much appreciated.

Awww, muffin. You gonna make it, what with not having any luck telling people what to like and all?

[CroGamer002]

I wonder did smudboy participate?

[Water Dumple]

I like the way this turned out. If it's representative of the entire ME2 vocal community and BioWare pays attention to it, a lot of my favorite characters might be coming back.

Most Requested for ME3: Garrus
Other highly requested characters include: Tali'Zorah, Legion, Wrex and Mordin in that order.

The exact five characters I voted for. I'd be content without Wrex and Mordin, but I'd be very sad if any of the other three (Legion, Garrus, or Tali) was left out. Thanks for taking the time to set up this survey and compile the results.

[JulianP]

Arrrgh, can't believe I actually missed the voting! Thanks for the work, and especially for providing the raw data!

[Xette]

You can still vote. The thread is around here with the link. I'm still getting heaps of votes every day so you can still chip in if you like

Maybe when I get up to a few thousand in a couple of months I'll repost the results to see if anything's changed.



I've come across quite a few Garrus haters on devart, so I know they're around. I actually expected more of them, tbh.

The forums I visited besides this one include: Gamespot (GameFAQs) PC and XBOX 360, Neoseeker, Steam, Mass Effect Forums, devArt (briefly before they locked my post for 'not promoting discussion) > and one or two others tha I unfortunately... uh... lost.

[Cerrydd]

m14567 wrote...

Also somewhat interesting is the distribution for TIM, remarkably even distribution. It is surprising to me since I would have thought he would have been a more polarising figure.

I think it depends on how people interpreted the poll. Some 'hate' TIM for who he is, some 'love' TIM for this.

I think TIM and Morinth are both great characters, but everything they do rubs me the wrong way so they're the only two that got a 'hate' vote from me. The title said 'popularity survey' so I took it that way, the rest of the characters got a 'neutral' or higher vote from me. It takes a lot to ****** me off

Anyway, thanks for gathering this information. I'm pleased to see Grunt is quite well-liked

[Collider]

I've come across quite a few Garrus haters on devart, so I know they're around. I actually expected more of them, tbh.

Really? I never noticed that on deviantart.

[D4rkFire]

Collider wrote...

I've come across quite a few Garrus haters on devart, so I know they're around. I actually expected more of them, tbh.

Really? I never noticed that on deviantart.

http://fc07.devianta...ian_by_criz.jpg

How can't you not like this?

Modifié par D4rkFire, 27 juillet 2010 - 01:05 .

[V-rex]

I had guessed Tali was going to win, she always does, but still at least the poll came out quite well and had good variety overall. I am still quite annoyed that Ashley didn't get a high percentage of 'likers' but at least 96 love and 266 like is still better than nothing.

Admittedly it does still suck to be in the minority about this but hey, at least I'm not alone so that's something.

[V-rex]

Still at least I'm glad she's not the least popular and that at least 163 people also want her back in Mass Effect 3. Whatever, I'm still happy with the end result.

[Spornicus]

V-rex wrote...

I had guessed Tali was going to win, she always does, but still at least the poll came out quite well and had good variety overall. I am still quite annoyed that Ashley didn't get a high percentage of 'likers' but at least 96 love and 266 like is still better than nothing.
Admittedly it does still suck to be in the minority about this but hey, at least I'm not alone so that's something.

Yeah, I was hoping Ashley would do better, but it could've been worse. It just shows that while some of our likes are popular, there are also some that are unique to us.

[Xette]

Collider wrote...

I've come across quite a few Garrus haters on devart, so I know they're around. I actually expected more of them, tbh.

Really? I never noticed that on deviantart.

It's not all of them, just a much higher number than here I think. And they aren't alwasys noticeable unless you talk to them because not many people do fan art of characters they hate, so you don't even realise it.

[ADLegend21]

Man so much Jacob hate. tsk tsk.

[fantasypisces]

 So the final standings, in order, for those just scanning through the thread, to return as crew members in ME3 are:

Garrus
Tali
Legion
Wrex
Mordin
Liara
Thane
Miranda
Grunt
Kasumi
Ashley
Samara
Jack
Kaidan
Zaeed
Jacob
Morinth


that seems about right to me. Although I still don't know for the life of me how Legion is so popular. Personally I voted: Liara, Garrus, Miranda, Mordin, Tali as my five. Tali was only there because she has been in the first two, so should keep it going.

Modifié par fantasypisces, 28 juillet 2010 - 05:16 .

[fantasypisces]

mrsph wrote...

V-rex wrote...

Still at least I'm glad she's not the least popular and that at least 163 people also want her back in Mass Effect 3. Whatever, I'm still happy with the end result.

I like Ashley a lot (she is my second favorite female LI next to Tali) and I think the problem with her popularity right now is her horrible, horrible portrayal on Horizon. Also the fact people over exagerrate her "racism" is probably not helping.

I don't think you can over exaggerate "racism", your either racist or your not. And she is racist. We dealt with it extensively in my cultural anthropology classes.

[Spornicus]

fantasypisces wrote...

mrsph wrote...

V-rex wrote...

Still at least I'm glad she's not the least popular and that at least 163 people also want her back in Mass Effect 3. Whatever, I'm still happy with the end result.

I like Ashley a lot (she is my second favorite female LI next to Tali) and I think the problem with her popularity right now is her horrible, horrible portrayal on Horizon. Also the fact people over exagerrate her "racism" is probably not helping.

I don't think you can over exaggerate "racism", your either racist or your not. And she is racist. We dealt with it extensively in my cultural anthropology classes.