Some Geth wrote...
Geth001 wrote...
M1tt3ns wrote...

You mean, if you take three screenshots from gritty military shooters with lip-service to realism and make sure all the screenshots are set to the exactly same scenario (being greviously wouned, with much of the screen being blocked) they'll look similar? Why, that's almost an argument!
If all you do is play crappy mainstream military shooters, then yes, you're going to notice that a lot of them play the same. Likewise, if you watch a lot of corny action movies, you're going to realize that almost all of them involve a muscely white guy murdering tons of terrorists with absolutely atrocious aim.
There are plenty of phenomenal shooters that don't even come close to fitting in this mold, you just have to look past the gigantic posters all over Gamestop. Check out Metro 2033, the Half Life series, or the STALKER series.
Or hell, if you want a game with decent shooter gameplay and RPG elements, check out Resident Evil 4 (I will punch anyone who calls this survival horror), or Alpha Protocol (which has stealth elements too!)
Likewise, if you only play the Final Fantasy series and other mainstream JRPGs, you're going to be convinced that the entire RPG genre is based off of taking teenagers with terrible haircuts to a variety of locales with schizophrenic technology advancement so they can angst about some girl.
I like this post but I must say the old Final Fantasy games 1 to 6 and 9 are not like that
.
it's funny, those you mention are also the games of the series without the Emo protagonists who "can't do anything" and is just generally embarrassing and useless. i like FF5 and 6 expecially.
FF7-12= the Emo saga. FF13 was a fresh gust of change from that path, but enought about that. i agree with that post too. the snobs on this forums are only right about the shooters (or simulators, god-sims, RTS, Sport, Music and other game genres) if they pick and choose and pretend the rest doesn't exist. it's petty and pathetic and it royally pisses me off.
M1tt3ns wrote...
Yes, there certainly are a
lot, but they're diamonds in the rough. Most shooters are like the ones
pictured and that's what gives shooters a bad name. I'm not knocking on
shooters. I enjoy them a lot. I think you should take a step back and
read my whole post before you react with so much passion against
something I never said.
To reiterate, my reason for not liking
shooters as much these days is that they've become mostly 'crappy
mainstream military shooters'. There's few that are unique or
interesting. I'm not saying they're not there. I'm just saying that for
every good one out there, there's a handful of bad ones.
last year, we saw MW2 and Killzone representing mindless shooters. on the other side of the bench we had Call of Pipryat (which is debatably more of an RPG without a skillsystem) and on the action shooter front we had Uncharted 2 which was more of a platformer. I hope we can agree that you're bashing the quickpaced Multiplayer of MW2, because i saw very little to nothing of the stereotypical Muscle soldier which appears in GoW and KZ.
I'm fumbling here because i don't keep up with the shooter genre much, but i'm starting to think that many on this forum would remaing ignorant in order to bash rather than to take a genuine look at the redeeming games.
I own MW2, i'm mediocre at it. i enjoyed the short and expensive as hell story. i hated the price. i got bored of GoW and KZ but was totally immersed in Uncharted 2. CoP bores me but Metro's atmosphere (alike to Stalker, ironically) fascinates me.
there is more to judging a game than from what perspective it is played and wether or not a diceroll or choices direct the gameplay and story. I am not talking to you directly now, but i find it horrible that half or more of this forum (in order to kiss ass at bioware... but missing since they seem to value humility.) claim supperior intelligence which makes them capable of loving "Hardcore" RPG's, but at the same time being so thick skulled that they assume that ALL shooters must be mindless splatfests of german kids screaming. I don't know what their problem is... they can't keep up with the pace? they think it's for lower lifeforms? i don't know, but the signal they send is that of unfounded supperiority, prejudice and generalization. a classic case of "you see one ****, you've seen them all" which is an idiotic view to have.
I'm passionate, I'm pissed, I'm a gamer on a mission... i want biggotry out of these forums... and my weapon will have to be the intellect they claim to have and my words... or i could just retreat and try to duck when they fire?
again, not entirely directed at you because you have sense enough to recongize that it's not the genre that makes the game... it's, hilariously enough, the game. So, please don't take this as a hit at you. i just kind of, went on a stream of thought inspired by what you wrote.
Modifié par BomimoDK, 30 juillet 2010 - 02:36 .