Aller au contenu

Photo

Best Origin? Worst Origin Story?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
242 réponses à ce sujet

#201
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

I like the Dwarf Noble for coming off like the most competent badass right off the bat. Fights lots of darkspawn, and is the newly crowned commander of all of armies of Orzammar. And the Paragon Aeducan traveled a similar path in his day, by uniting the Thaigs to fight darkspawn. From a military perspective, it's one that makes more sense than others.

 

Dalish is cool to me because it's like a crash course into DA lore. You encounter darkspawn, eluvian, undead, human/elf relations, etc..

 

The more I think about it, human female is cooler than male. As a male, Alistair basically steals your thunder. He has the better plot. As a female, you're more involved in his plot (if you wish to be).


  • luna1124, KaiserShep et DarthGizka aiment ceci

#202
CoM Solaufein

CoM Solaufein
  • Members
  • 1 555 messages

I've started a new game after years of not playing DA. I always liked the female thief city elf story which is what I'm using now.



#203
Finnn62

Finnn62
  • Members
  • 641 messages

I'd say for me, anyways:

 

Best: Dwarf Noble

 

Worst: City Elf



#204
FlashyShooter

FlashyShooter
  • Members
  • 11 messages

When I first played this game I played Human Noble. I kind of wish there were other options than just noble or mage but I think that's one of the better origins.

 

Like: Dwarf Noble, City Elf, Human, Mage

 

Didn't like as much: Dwarf Commoner, Dalish Elves

 

I think all the origins are all relatively good I wish there was a couple more or the origins would effect the story more. Gorim was a really cool character I wish he could be obtained as a companion.

 

I liked Fergus too but he just presumably dies he would have been a cool character.



#205
Pateu

Pateu
  • Banned
  • 1 004 messages

Human Noble and Mage are tied, in my opinion.

 

Worst? Uh... Dalish Elf, I guess.



#206
blaidfiste

blaidfiste
  • Members
  • 1 407 messages

I played them all and don't think that there are any bad ones.  My favorite has to be female city elf for the "Well, I didn't want to get married anyway." line.



#207
Dabrikishaw

Dabrikishaw
  • Members
  • 3 240 messages

The Origin I like the most is the Human Noble.

 

The Origin I had the most fun with is the Dwarf Noble.

 

The Origin I have the least fun playing is the Dalish Elf.



#208
LostInReverie19

LostInReverie19
  • Members
  • 719 messages

I played the Dalish Elf first so that origin will always have a special place in my heart. I'm not sure why so many people don't enjoy it as much. However, my favorite is the Mage origin, because I love me some mages. If I had to pick a least favorite, it would be Dwarf Commoner, but really, I love all the origin stories. 



#209
Vienna

Vienna
  • Members
  • 121 messages

My favourite is Dwarf Commoner. The fact that you go from a crime lord's (essentailly) slave and just before you are sent off to be executed, you are recruited into the order pledged to protect the world from the Darkspawn. Not only that, you save the world and become a Paragon. Essentially you become a living god to the dwarves. It's such a great feeling.

 

My least favourite is probably the Magi origin. Playing as a mage in Origins just feels weird to me, even though I can't play anything else in DA2. The origin itself is pretty boring for me. The City Elf would be my second least favourite, but it very nicely demonstrates the race relations betweens humans and elves in the Dragon Age universe. The Magi origin really doesn't do much other than set up Jowan and the Circle Tower. Which, frankly, Jowan and the Tower were pretty well established even without playing the Magi origin.



#210
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

My favourite is Dwarf Commoner. The fact that you go from a crime lord's (essentailly) slave and just before you are sent off to be executed, you are recruited into the order pledged to protect the world from the Darkspawn. Not only that, you save the world and become a Paragon. Essentially you become a living god to the dwarves. It's such a great feeling.

 

My least favourite is probably the Magi origin. Playing as a mage in Origins just feels weird to me, even though I can't play anything else in DA2. The origin itself is pretty boring for me. The City Elf would be my second least favourite, but it very nicely demonstrates the race relations betweens humans and elves in the Dragon Age universe. The Magi origin really doesn't do much other than set up Jowan and the Circle Tower. Which, frankly, Jowan and the Tower were pretty well established even without playing the Magi origin.

 

The interesting thing about Jowan is the symbolism. Not so much the character. The allure of Freedom, and the price and caution you might learn from being too hasty about it. They are making you aware that "Freedom" isn't the only thing to think about with mages (you don't have to believe it, but it's a possibility). That this is an entirely different setting than D&D or whatever. We have a lot of preconceptions about magic in RPGs, but it's different here. And Jowan's story is a good intro to the basic dangers.



#211
Lhawke

Lhawke
  • Members
  • 189 messages

Dwarf commoner origin is my favourite. The only one of my wardens who I felt genuinely wanted to join the order when first meeting Duncan and couldn't believe her  luck when he appeared just in time. It actually made a change to have a warden who didn't have a revenge or tragedy thing going on.

Human noble my least favourite, simply because the reason for being recruited seemed a little ridiculous considering the circumstances. I'm pretty sure my noble would have stabbed Duncan in the back and stayed.

 

The rest of the origins I think are all pretty good and the city elf female characer with the cocky voice set is just perfect.



#212
Undead Han

Undead Han
  • Members
  • 21 101 messages

Best: Human Noble

 

Worst: Dalish Elf


  • Jeffonl1 et Dabrikishaw aiment ceci

#213
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

 

The rest of the origins I think are all pretty good and the city elf female characer with the cocky voice set is just perfect.

 

Nothing tops female Dwarf cocky, I think (it's Jack from ME).

 

But yeah, I think the commoner is the one where I feel more grateful for the Wardens. I also feel it affected my family in a real sense. The other origins have an air of loss or unfinished business.



#214
Nuclear

Nuclear
  • Members
  • 755 messages
I'll have to say Dwarf Noble for me.

Dalish is hands down the worst.

#215
Endurium

Endurium
  • Members
  • 2 147 messages

My favorite is the Mage Origin. I agree Jowan is a point against it (waaa waaa waaa) but I feel at home there since I tend to see myself living in a sorcerer's tower in another life.

 

Least favorite is Dalish Elf; extremely short and I'm saddled with a doofus companion.

 

The rest are okay but I can't relate to them so I only tried them once each.



#216
Arisugawa

Arisugawa
  • Members
  • 770 messages

In order of preference:

 

1) Human Noble - It is the only origin in which Highever is actually visited, despite being mentioned throughout the game. It gives a reason for us to care what happens to Arl Howe and context as to why he is present at so many of Loghain's interactions. It gives crucial significance to Nathanial's character in Awakenings. If one is so leaning, it also provides the player the opportunity to ascend to power.

 

2) City Elf - This the only origin where my character truly wanted to become a Warden. Regardless of which gender you play, this is a horrific origin and becoming a Warden is a welcome escape from a scenario that otherwise would have been terribly messy. It also makes the Alienage story near the end of the game a much better affair than it is otherwise.

 

3) Dalish Elf - I don't particularly like the Dalish, but my feelings on this have changed in the time since I originally played it. It introduces the Eluvians, does a good job of making the loss of one's clan feel heartbreaking, and it helps make the Brecialian Forest section slightly more interesting. You get additional interaction with Velanna in Awakenings and it provides immeasurable context for the Dalish in Dragon Age 2.

 

4) Mage - This used to be my third favorite. The return to the Tower becomes a nightmare since you are familiar with most of the people involved. It gives some additional interaction with Cullen, which depending on how you feel about him might be a positive. I was never bothered by Jowan's role in this - I think it helps towards understanding his role in the Arl of Redcliffe chapter and he never got on my nerves. It also gives some additional meaning to your interactions with Morrigan and Wynne, and ties you slightly to Hawke in Dragon Age 2.

 

5) Dwarf Commoner - Almost as pressing as City Elf, but then it just fell flat. The unfortunate truth is that it didn't move me, and thus I found it hard to care.

 

6) Dwarf Noble - Regardless of the politics, regardless of the context it gives during the Orzammar chapter, regardless of everything that should make this enjoyable, I despised it. The whole thing is a railroad job; at no point after speaking with Bhelan would I have simply just ignored everything until the next day. I would have found Triann and we would have had words - and something different would have happened. I was furious when the game didn't give me that option, and even more furious when the remaining events played out as they did. It's the only origin where I never completed Ostagar. Deleted the character and started over with a different origin.


  • Jeffonl1 aime ceci

#217
bazzag

bazzag
  • Members
  • 3 147 messages

In order of preference:

 

Human Noble: Gives immeasurable background for Howe, making it one of the best origins that continue throughout

 

Dwarf Noble: Love all the politics that goes on, and returning to orzammar to find you have a kid (if male and screwed the noble hunters). Also love the romance you have with Gorim if female.

 

City Elf (female): Love the Harrowing story, which is exasperated more when female, what with being kidnapped yourself and the ill fated rescue attempt from your betrothed

 

Dwarf Commoner: Love being lawless in this one, regardless of whether you enjoy being a rapscallion or not, and interacting with rita upon your return to Orzammar

 

Mage: This is the first one where I kind of feel meh. I like the extra stuff we get with Cullen, as its the only origin story where you'll get Cullens full story arc. I enjoy being in kinloch hold, and i even dont mind Jowan. Its the rest of it. Especially the origin conclusion with Jowan at redcliffe. Still, this origin does make me want to visit Aeonar in inquisition or a future DA title.

 

Dalish Elf: I honestly think this one sucks. Its the shortest and is the one that feels a bit rushed. I do enjoy the whole dalish thing in it, and the fact that its the same clan in DA2, and the eluvian and its cave are mentioned in awakening and have importance in DA2, but thats it. I certainly think the origin conclusion with Tamlen is the worst.


  • Dabrikishaw aime ceci

#218
superkoolstud

superkoolstud
  • Members
  • 37 messages

Dwarf Noble
Human Noble
Dwarf Commoner
Mage
Dalish
City Elf



#219
Saberchic

Saberchic
  • Members
  • 2 997 messages

This is hard since my favorite seems to switch between 3 of them, but if I had to pick....

 

Best: Mage or Dalish (couldn't choose. LOL)

 

Worst: City Elf (no contest on this one)



#220
Cypher0020

Cypher0020
  • Members
  • 5 128 messages

Best: dwarf commoner/city elf tie for me

 

Worst: Dalish

 

Not horrible, but I just think it's most...detached from all the other origins, since they're all tie/have a stake in the main quests



#221
Guest_john_sheparrd_*

Guest_john_sheparrd_*
  • Guests

Best: Human Noble

Worst: Everything else



#222
franciscoamell

franciscoamell
  • Members
  • 794 messages

Best is def Dwarf Noble. With City Elf in second. And Dwarf Commoner is my personal favorite. :3

 

I think I agree with you that Dalish is the worst. I still like it, but eh. Kinda eh about Human Noble too tbh.



#223
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

Best: Human Noble

Worst: Everything else

 

You don't even have a 2nd or 3rd place? lol



#224
Catche Jagger

Catche Jagger
  • Members
  • 461 messages
My favorite would have to be the Magi origin (though that may be because it was my first). I thought the opening in the Fade was really cool and it kind of reminded me of being a Jedi (don't really know why). I do think that the choice about helping or revealing Jowan was a bit annoying (especially because I accidentally ended up selling him out) but overall, I still prefer it to the others.
  • DarthGizka aime ceci

#225
Dova

Dova
  • Members
  • 519 messages

Best: Dalish.

Worst: Dwarf Commoner & Noble.