18744 réponses à ce sujet

[Daginu]

good night tali thread, Keelah'Selai


Dat every thing

Modifié par Daginu, 06 août 2010 - 05:46 .

[Collider]

Phil725 wrote...

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

It's true. It doesn't lead to any meaningful discussion. And it annoys people.

I've actually had some intelligent discussion on the topic in the past.  I was more referring the threads extremely fanatical response at the slightest mention. 

Then again, I'm on record as saying pretty much everyone takes pretty much everything too seriously

Not fanatical, just doesn't make the thread appealing. Does more bad than good.

[RiptideX1090]

nitefyre410 wrote...


TalI: Shhh no close your  eyes its  surprise

Shephard: *Blindfold*  What are planning 

Tali:  Now if I  told you it would not be a surprise.. . Okay you take off  the blindfold 

*Shephard  see Tali and Slave Girl Quarian both in the bed*    

Tali: Happy Anniversary  

Yeah...

This used to be a lot more fun about five thousand pages ago.

Let's not do that again. Minds out of the gutter.

I've actually gotten better lately... I'd like to keep that way. Let's move on now...

[Snazzy Penguin]

mikethor007 wrote...

Phew. Thanks for understanding.

No problem. I am still new to the thread, my bad, I'll avoid such mistakes in the future.

[Phil725]

nitefyre410 wrote...
*snip*
Shephard is going to have a very  happy anniversary 

TalI: Shhh no close your  eyes its  surprise

Shephard: *Blindfold*  What are planning 

Tali:  Now if I  told you it would not be a surprise.. . Okay you take off  the blindfold 

*Shephard  see Tali and Slave Girl Quarian both in the bed*    

Tali: Happy Anniversary  

This seems like about the time that Shep would wake up

[huntrrz]

Collider wrote...

RiptideX1090 wrote...

Collider wrote...
Can we talk about something else?

Can you come up with an interesting topic?

Yes. I would like to discuss what Tali would have done in the following areas:

Genophage Cure Data
Sidonis
Jacob's Father
Aresh

1.  Keep the data for future use.  The Krogan are too dangerous to hand it over to them now, but Wrex is making great progress.
2.  Let Garrus kill him.  Quarians don't have the death penalty, but Sidonis is not a Quarian and she'd defer to Turian ethics.  (And he betrayed his 'crew'.)
3.  Maximum penalty.  A ship's captain betrayed his crew(!!!).  If not execution, exile on the planet (which, with the hunters about is pretty much execution anyway).
4.  Confined for medical treatment.

Modifié par huntrrz, 06 août 2010 - 05:52 .

[RiptideX1090]

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

It's true. It doesn't lead to any meaningful discussion. And it annoys people.

I've actually had some intelligent discussion on the topic in the past.  I was more referring the threads extremely fanatical response at the slightest mention. 

Then again, I'm on record as saying pretty much everyone takes pretty much everything too seriously

Not fanatical, just doesn't make the thread appealing. Does more bad than good.

Only because some people can be a bit abrasive about it.

But I agree. Nothing good will come of talking about it.

Moving on.

[mikethor007]

Phil725 wrote...

This seems like about the time that Shep would wake up

With Mordin blowing a vuvuzela in his ear.

[Collider]

huntrrz wrote...

Collider wrote...

RiptideX1090 wrote...

Collider wrote...
Can we talk about something else?

Can you come up with an interesting topic?

Yes. I would like to discuss what Tali would have done in the following areas:

Genophage Cure Data
Sidonis
Jacob's Father
Aresh

1.  Keep the data for future use.  The Krogan are too dangerous to hand it over to them now, but Wrex is making great progress.
2.  Let Garrus kill him.  Quarians don't have the death penalty, but Sidonis is not a Quarian and she'd defer to Taurian ethics.  (And he betrayed his 'crew'.)

I'm not sure she'd defer to Turian ethics. But I agree. She'd probably let Garrus kill Sidonnis. In that she trusts Garrus' judgment.

3.  Maximum penalty.  A ship's captain betrayed his crew(!!!).  If not execution, exile on the planet (which, with the hunters about is pretty much execution anyway).
4.  Confined for medical treatment.

I think Tali would just leave on the island. Not worth leaving the gun, I think.

[Phil725]

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...
*snip*
I've actually had some intelligent discussion on the topic in the past.  I was more referring the threads extremely fanatical response at the slightest mention. 

Then again, I'm on record as saying pretty much everyone takes pretty much everything too seriously

Not fanatical, just doesn't make the thread appealing. Does more bad than good.

I'd argue the normal response does more harm to the thread than the topic itself.  While I couldn't care less about what other people on a message board think of me, one of the normal associations made with this thread is extremely close minded.  And people freaking out at the mention of a femShep/Tali romance only adds to that feeling.

I'm of the belief that if you don't want to discuss something intelligently, don't comment on it.

[Snazzy Penguin]

RiptideX1090 wrote...

Yeah...

This used to be a lot more fun about five thousand pages ago.

Let's not do that again. Minds out of the gutter.

I've actually gotten better lately... I'd like to keep that way. Let's move on now...

Topic for Discussion to move on up out of the gutter (to the east side):  Geth and Quarian Co-existence.

[mikethor007]

Runescapeguy9 wrote...

mikethor007 wrote...

With Mordin blowing a vuvuzela in his ear.

That picture has so many things about it that would ****** me off...

That noise alone would be enough, but I know what you mean.

[RiptideX1090]

Phil725 wrote...

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...
*snip*
I've actually had some intelligent discussion on the topic in the past.  I was more referring the threads extremely fanatical response at the slightest mention. 

Then again, I'm on record as saying pretty much everyone takes pretty much everything too seriously

Not fanatical, just doesn't make the thread appealing. Does more bad than good.

I'd argue the normal response does more harm to the thread than the topic itself.  While I couldn't care less about what other people on a message board think of me, one of the normal associations made with this thread is extremely close minded.  And people freaking out at the mention of a femShep/Tali romance only adds to that feeling.

I'm of the belief that if you don't want to discuss something intelligently, don't comment on it.

I agree Phil.

But... for the sake of keeping things... civil.

Let's not do this.

[mikethor007]

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

Topic for Discussion to move on up out of the gutter (to the east side):  Geth and Quarian Co-existence.

Careful with this one too. Volatile.

[Phil725]

Snazzy Penguin wrote...
*snip*
Topic for Discussion to move on up out of the gutter (to the east side):  Geth and Quarian Co-existence.

Will be rather easy I think.  I believe that getting Rannoch back is a panacea for pretty much everything.  No reason to hate the geth once peace is made.

[Snazzy Penguin]

mikethor007 wrote...

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

Topic for Discussion to move on up out of the gutter (to the east side):  Geth and Quarian Co-existence.

Careful with this one too. Volatile.

Seems I'm getting a crash course in what not to mention tonight lol.

Modifié par Snazzy Penguin, 06 août 2010 - 05:51 .

[mikethor007]

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

Seems I'm getting a crash course in what not to mention tonight lol. Censored.

No, No. I said careful. Can be discussed, but kinda easy to get people incensed.

[nitefyre410]

RiptideX1090 wrote...

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...

It's true. It doesn't lead to any meaningful discussion. And it annoys people.

I've actually had some intelligent discussion on the topic in the past.  I was more referring the threads extremely fanatical response at the slightest mention. 

Then again, I'm on record as saying pretty much everyone takes pretty much everything too seriously

Not fanatical, just doesn't make the thread appealing. Does more bad than good.

Only because some people can be a bit abrasive about it.

But I agree. Nothing good will come of talking about it.

Moving on.

   

@Collider(Who is now in bed from last post) OMG  less appealing HOW... what because its talk about SEX.....  What is that such a dirty word SEX...  

 You know  what Rip your right  lets move  on before I post a five page long rant how people on internet message boards need to get over themselves. 

[Collider]

Phil725 wrote...

Collider wrote...

Phil725 wrote...
*snip*
I've actually had some intelligent discussion on the topic in the past.  I was more referring the threads extremely fanatical response at the slightest mention. 
Then again, I'm on record as saying pretty much everyone takes pretty much everything too seriously

Not fanatical, just doesn't make the thread appealing. Does more bad than good.

I'd argue the normal response does more harm to the thread than the topic itself.  While I couldn't care less about what other people on a message board think of me, one of the normal associations made with this thread is extremely close minded.  And people freaking out at the mention of a femShep/Tali romance only adds to that feeling.

I'm of the belief that if you don't want to discuss something intelligently, don't comment on it.

I don't really have a problem with F!Shepard and Tali. The thing is, the discussion as displayed was giggling over the thought of lesbians, hardly an intellectual venture. That is not going to lend itself to intelligent discussion. I frequent this thread as well, and gutter talk pretty much never leads to anything meaningful. And it does annoy people, and not just me.

One of the reasons why the thread has improved is because people have raised issue about the contents. That is what I am doing right now.

[Phil725]

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

mikethor007 wrote...

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

Topic for Discussion to move on up out of the gutter (to the east side):  Geth and Quarian Co-existence.

Careful with this one too. Volatile.

Seems I'm getting a crash course in what not to mention tonight lol.

That topic is hardly one of the more volatile ones.  Only topic involving the geth that gets heated is the Morning War itself.

[RiptideX1090]

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

mikethor007 wrote...

Snazzy Penguin wrote...

Topic for Discussion to move on up out of the gutter (to the east side):  Geth and Quarian Co-existence.

Careful with this one too. Volatile.

Seems I'm getting a crash course in what not to mention tonight lol.

It's just that most of the people on right now all have very contrasting opinions, and everyones abit touchy.

That, and Collider is fond of arguing for arguement's sake.

Actually. You know what? I'm out. Gonna go write... or something...

I know if I stay, it's just going to end badly.

'night, Talithread.