39010 réponses à ce sujet

[Yankee23]

LadyDamodred wrote...

tool_bot wrote...

yukidama wrote...

I don't even like baseball, I just don't like the Yankees xD

Do you hate the Yankees or Yankee fans? Me I like the Yankees (more or less) but can't stand Yankee fans.

Both!  I mean, uh, nothing to see over here.  Oh, look!  An NBA team we can all get behind!

[snip]

Ah well, in the case of our...geographic areas...it is a mutually expected and longstanding tradition. Look the size of that...sword!

Modifié par Yankee23, 16 octobre 2010 - 04:08 .

[TotoroTori]

Reika wrote...

LadyDamodred wrote...

TotoroTori wrote...

Reika wrote...
*snip*

so many naughty thoughts are running in my head right now from this image

Just that image, eh?  Uh-huh.  Sure thing, dear.  *whistles innocently*

It's the eyebrow.

oh yes it is!

[Lady Jess]

Sarah1281 wrote...

Reika wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...

Reika wrote...

Those are some great shots, Lady Jess.

Haha Jaina would set her own grandmother on fire if she told her she shouldn't be with Alistair.

Fire works, though Marlana would probably gut anyone who tried to do the same. Or if she was feeling really evil, poison them with something slow and painful.

I'm sure Alistair would react great to that.

If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

[Giggles_Manically]

@Lady Jess.

Alistair pretty much sees Wynne as his grandma though.

I would have liked a banter where Wynne tries to scare the LI away from the warden.

[Sarah1281]

Lady Jess wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Reika wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...

Reika wrote...

Those are some great shots, Lady Jess.

Haha Jaina would set her own grandmother on fire if she told her she shouldn't be with Alistair.

Fire works, though Marlana would probably gut anyone who tried to do the same. Or if she was feeling really evil, poison them with something slow and painful.

I'm sure Alistair would react great to that.

If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Which is exactly why he goes off on Eamon for trying to make him king where he'd probably lose the woman he loved, the Landsmeet for not being willing to accept him with the woman he loved, Anora for not being the kind of person he can just comfortably sit back and watch take the throne and thus cause him to lose the woman he loves, the woman he loves for putting him on the throne and forcing him to feel a need to end the relationship...

[Lady Jess]

Sarah1281 wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Reika wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...

Reika wrote...

Those are some great shots, Lady Jess.

Haha Jaina would set her own grandmother on fire if she told her she shouldn't be with Alistair.

Fire works, though Marlana would probably gut anyone who tried to do the same. Or if she was feeling really evil, poison them with something slow and painful.

I'm sure Alistair would react great to that.

If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Which is exactly why he goes off on Eamon for trying to make him king where he'd probably lose the woman he loved, the Landsmeet for not being willing to accept him with the woman he loved, Anora for not being the kind of person he can just comfortably sit back and watch take the throne and thus cause him to lose the woman he loves, the woman he loves for putting him on the throne and forcing him to feel a need to end the relationship...

*shrugs* he's been king in most of my games and never lost the woman he loves, so I don't know what you're going on about there. Or are you going off into "doesn't happen in the game" land again and assuming it'll happen without any real basis in fact?

edit: seriously, Grey Warden ending...he's with the woman he loves.
Single ruler...he's with the woman he loves
Cousland/Queen ending...ditto!
Married to Anora, Hardened, hey guess what, he can still be with the woman he loves look at that!

Modifié par Lady Jess, 16 octobre 2010 - 04:18 .

[KnightofPhoenix]

Lady Jess wrote...
If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Of course, who doesn't love to have a sadistic maniac for a lover?

[LadyDamodred]

Sarah1281 wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...
If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Which is exactly why he goes off on Eamon for trying to make him king where he'd probably lose the woman he loved, the Landsmeet for not being willing to accept him with the woman he loved, Anora for not being the kind of person he can just comfortably sit back and watch take the throne and thus cause him to lose the woman he loves, the woman he loves for putting him on the throne and forcing him to feel a need to end the relationship...

The decision to end the relationship is his, not Eamon's or any elses, no matter what pressures he may have felt.  He knows this, and doesn't attempt to blame someone else for it.

[Sarah1281]

Lady Jess wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Reika wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...

Reika wrote...

Those are some great shots, Lady Jess.

Haha Jaina would set her own grandmother on fire if she told her she shouldn't be with Alistair.

Fire works, though Marlana would probably gut anyone who tried to do the same. Or if she was feeling really evil, poison them with something slow and painful.

I'm sure Alistair would react great to that.

If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Which is exactly why he goes off on Eamon for trying to make him king where he'd probably lose the woman he loved, the Landsmeet for not being willing to accept him with the woman he loved, Anora for not being the kind of person he can just comfortably sit back and watch take the throne and thus cause him to lose the woman he loves, the woman he loves for putting him on the throne and forcing him to feel a need to end the relationship...

*shrugs* he's been king in most of my games and never lost the woman he loves, so I don't know what you're going on about there. Or are you going off into "doesn't happen in the game" land again and assuming it'll happen without any real basis in fact?

No, I'm saying that I don't believe Alistair would be even remotely okay with the woman he loved hurting or killing people because they're threatening to tear the two apart.

I also don't see how what happens in most of your games has anything to do with REAL IN-GAME POSSIBILITIES. In all games, Eamon suggests making Alistair king. In all games, the Landsmeet would never accept a non-HNF with the king (regardless of if Alistair became king or not). In all hardened games he's not particularly thrilled with Anora as queen. In all games where Alistair is king and romancing the Warden, she puts him on there. In all unhardened games w/out a HNF where he's king the relationship ends and in hardend games without a HNF where he isn't taked into being a mistress. I'm not making anything up or going off with no basis in fact. I honestly do not believe he'll go around setting anyone on fire or poisoning them if him being king forces him to seperate from his love and thus was being sarcastic. Which I really shouldn't have had to explain.

[Sarah1281]

LadyDamodred wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...
If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Which is exactly why he goes off on Eamon for trying to make him king where he'd probably lose the woman he loved, the Landsmeet for not being willing to accept him with the woman he loved, Anora for not being the kind of person he can just comfortably sit back and watch take the throne and thus cause him to lose the woman he loves, the woman he loves for putting him on the throne and forcing him to feel a need to end the relationship...

The decision to end the relationship is his, not Eamon's or any elses, no matter what pressures he may have felt.  He knows this, and doesn't attempt to blame someone else for it.

Yeah. I know.

[Lady Jess]

Sarah1281 wrote...
No, I'm saying that I don't believe Alistair would be even remotely okay with the woman he loved hurting or killing people because they're threatening to tear the two apart.

I also don't see how what happens in most of your games has anything to do with REAL IN-GAME POSSIBILITIES. In all games, Eamon suggests making Alistair king. In all games, the Landsmeet would never accept a non-HNF with the king (regardless of if Alistair became king or not). In all hardened games he's not particularly thrilled with Anora as queen. In all games where Alistair is king and romancing the Warden, she puts him on there. In all unhardened games w/out a HNF where he's king the relationship ends and in hardend games without a HNF where he isn't taked into being a mistress. I'm not making anything up or going off with no basis in fact. I honestly do not believe he'll go around setting anyone on fire or poisoning them if him being king forces him to seperate from his love and thus was being sarcastic. Which I really shouldn't have had to explain.

Because he doesn't LOSE THE WOMAN Sarah, that is NOT a fact in the game unless you CHOOSE it to be a fact in the game.

Modifié par Lady Jess, 16 octobre 2010 - 04:25 .

[Giggles_Manically]

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...
If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Of course, who doesn't love to have a sadistic maniac for a lover?

RAISES HAND.

[Sarah1281]

Because he doesm't LOSE THE WOMAN Sarah, that is NOT a fact in the game unless you CHOOSE it to be a fact in the game.

You're still missing the point. I am not saying "It is a fact in game that Alistair will romance the Warden and lose her (no choice about gender of the Warden either)." Why are you fixating on that?



The parts you highlighted as an example? That's not me insisting that it's a fact in the game. That's me giving an example of how, if these people do play a part in trying or succeeding in taking the woman he loves from him, he does not go around hurting or killing them. This wasn't brought up to advocate dumping Alistair or to insist that's the only right way to play. That was brought up just in response to you saying that he would have no problem with you hurting or killing people for trying to end the relationship. I feel if he would be fine with it then he'd probably act the same way. Alistair disapproves of pretty much any remotely evil thing you can do in the game so I don't see how anyone can believe that be would be all right with evil acts because they're in the name of love.

[LadyDamodred]

Sarah1281 wrote...

LadyDamodred wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Lady Jess wrote...
If someone was trying to take away the woman he loved...I'm sure he'd whole heartedly approve and then some

Which is exactly why he goes off on Eamon for trying to make him king where he'd probably lose the woman he loved, the Landsmeet for not being willing to accept him with the woman he loved, Anora for not being the kind of person he can just comfortably sit back and watch take the throne and thus cause him to lose the woman he loves, the woman he loves for putting him on the throne and forcing him to feel a need to end the relationship...

The decision to end the relationship is his, not Eamon's or any elses, no matter what pressures he may have felt.  He knows this, and doesn't attempt to blame someone else for it.

Yeah. I know.

My point was that your comparison wasn't analagous.  Obviously, I should have made that more clear.

[KnightofPhoenix]

People are seriously arguing about whether Alistair would approve of his girl killing her own grandmother because she said the two shouldn't be together? Chill people.

Or don't, It's entertaining.

[TotoroTori]

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

People are seriously arguing about whether Alistair would approve of his girl killing her own grandmother because she said the two shouldn't be together? Chill people.

Or don't, It's entertaining.

No you shouldn't ill her for disapproving but you can prove her wrong. And no Alistair doesn't even approve of killing Isolde (when it involved saving Connor) so why would he approve of killing Wynne of a stupid arguement?

[Reika]

In my case, my warden wouldn't kill someone for saying something. Only if they acted on it and she perceived they were a threat. Of course it entirely depends on when they tried to act on it. Early on in the relationship she wouldn't have reacted too badly because she was still in semi-denial about her feelings. She also hadn't gone through numerous instances of hell that just warped her reactions to things.



After all the major plot points but before the landsmeet? Depending on what they did, it might not be pretty. But again, it'd have to be actions, not words.

[KnightofPhoenix]

@ Tori.
I might not think much of Alistair (at all), but I don't think I need to be told that he wouldn't approve of Wynne's murder.

Seriously thread. Why so serious?

Modifié par KnightofPhoenix, 16 octobre 2010 - 04:39 .

[Lady Jess]

Sarah1281 wrote...

Because he doesm't LOSE THE WOMAN Sarah, that is NOT a fact in the game unless you CHOOSE it to be a fact in the game.

You're still missing the point. I am not saying "It is a fact in game that Alistair will romance the Warden and lose her (no choice about gender of the Warden either)." Why are you fixating on that?

The parts you highlighted as an example? That's not me insisting that it's a fact in the game. That's me giving an example of how, if these people do play a part in trying or succeeding in taking the woman he loves from him, he does not go around hurting or killing them. This wasn't brought up to advocate dumping Alistair or to insist that's the only right way to play. That was brought up just in response to you saying that he would have no problem with you hurting or killing people for trying to end the relationship. I feel if he would be fine with it then he'd probably act the same way. Alistair disapproves of pretty much any remotely evil thing you can do in the game so I don't see how anyone can believe that be would be all right with evil acts because they're in the name of love.

LMAO I honestly can't believe you. You take something said in jest, twist it into something to argue that it's OOC for Alistair to approve of. Really? People can't even JOKE in here without you latching onto it and lecturing us about how it isn't within Alistair's character, or isn't right for some other litany of reasons. It gets really old, seriously.

[Lady Jess]

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

@ Tori.
I might not think much of Alistair (at all), but I don't think I need to be told that he wouldn't approve of Wynne's murder.

Seriously thread. Why so serious?

Apparently not everyone has heard the old jokes

"i'd sell my firstborn/give my right arm/sell out my own mother/slap my own grandmother" before...lol

[mellifera]

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

@ Tori.
I might not think much of Alistair (at all), but I don't think I need to be told that he wouldn't approve of Wynne's murder.

Seriously thread. Why so serious?

Well, except when he gets the killing blow on her when Wynne attacks over Morrigan xD He doesn't approve but he doesn't disapprove or spare her from a taste of sheild bash hehe

[Lady Jess]

yukidama wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

@ Tori.
I might not think much of Alistair (at all), but I don't think I need to be told that he wouldn't approve of Wynne's murder.

Seriously thread. Why so serious?

Well, except when he gets the killing blow on her when Wynne attacks over Morrigan xD He doesn't approve but he doesn't disapprove or spare her from a taste of sheild bash hehe

That is a very good point! And that's an argument over an apostate he doesn't like AT ALL. So what if she picked a fight over your relationship, and he was at love? And she got all obsessively "mommY' about it and decided you better quit seeing him or else...and it led to battle. I think he'd be right there with a shield bash too.

[Sarah1281]

Lady Jess wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Because he doesm't LOSE THE WOMAN Sarah, that is NOT a fact in the game unless you CHOOSE it to be a fact in the game.

You're still missing the point. I am not saying "It is a fact in game that Alistair will romance the Warden and lose her (no choice about gender of the Warden either)." Why are you fixating on that?

The parts you highlighted as an example? That's not me insisting that it's a fact in the game. That's me giving an example of how, if these people do play a part in trying or succeeding in taking the woman he loves from him, he does not go around hurting or killing them. This wasn't brought up to advocate dumping Alistair or to insist that's the only right way to play. That was brought up just in response to you saying that he would have no problem with you hurting or killing people for trying to end the relationship. I feel if he would be fine with it then he'd probably act the same way. Alistair disapproves of pretty much any remotely evil thing you can do in the game so I don't see how anyone can believe that be would be all right with evil acts because they're in the name of love.

LMAO I honestly can't believe you. You take something said in jest, twist it into something to argue that it's OOC for Alistair to approve of. Really? People can't even JOKE in here without you latching onto it and lecturing us about how it isn't within Alistair's character, or isn't right for some other litany of reasons. It gets really old, seriously.

I'm not a fangirl. At all. For anything. I don't really understand how much is genuine and how much is exaggerating for effect here. I've never been very good at telling if people are being serious or joking or even trolling on the internet if there isn't an appropriate emoticon. I'm sorry if that's bothering you and you think I'm trying to lecture you and cause problems.

[KnightofPhoenix]

To suggest that Morrigan needs him for that is heresy.



She needs no one. Except me.

Modifié par KnightofPhoenix, 16 octobre 2010 - 04:58 .

[Lady Jess]

Sarah1281 wrote...

I'm not a fangirl. At all. For anything. I don't really understand how much is genuine and how much is exaggerating for effect here. I've never been very good at telling if people are being serious or joking or even trolling on the internet if there isn't an appropriate emoticon. I'm sorry if that's bothering you and you think I'm trying to lecture you and cause problems.

It has nothing to do with being a "fangirl" or not.  You just have a really bad habit of instantly jumping to a conclusion and insisting on sticking with it. Which would be a great thing if it were the right conclusion:P