Aller au contenu

Photo

Why Teyrn Loghain is the deepest character in Dragon Age


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
12857 réponses à ce sujet

#1076
DragonRacer13

DragonRacer13
  • Members
  • 519 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

DragonRacer13 wrote...

So, like, this new revelation makes Loghain a national hero x2 now, right (x3 for those who let him ride the dragon for final redemption)?

Edit: Posted Image by Sarah... lol

Yes, yes it does. Posted Image


*sigh* The sad part is people will STILL find a way to spin this against Loghain. I'm sure they're formulating "damage control" as we speak...

#1077
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Hey, I actually have more faith in Eamon than for him to want Cailan to marry CELENE. I mean, did you hear that line about poncy Orlesian noblemen? This stupidity was all Cailan's. And Celen's. But she, at least, was getting something out of it.

The whole issue is Cailan basically jumping off a cliff because of Eamon's encouragement. I'm not sure how he'd feel about Cailan marrying Celene, but I don't doubt he'd figure out a way for it to benefit him, considering he's married to an Orlesian himself.

I still maintain that there is a difference between marrying an Orlesian and giving your independent country back to Orlais.

True, but if Cailan did have a child with Celene, that would essentially absorb Ferelden into Orlais. Either Cailan hadn't thought that far ahead, or he didn't care.

#1078
Giggles_Manically

Giggles_Manically
  • Members
  • 13 708 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Hey, I actually have more faith in Eamon than for him to want Cailan to marry CELENE. I mean, did you hear that line about poncy Orlesian noblemen? This stupidity was all Cailan's. And Celen's. But she, at least, was getting something out of it.

The whole issue is Cailan basically jumping off a cliff because of Eamon's encouragement. I'm not sure how he'd feel about Cailan marrying Celene, but I don't doubt he'd figure out a way for it to benefit him, considering he's married to an Orlesian himself.


Hence why Loghain's poisoning of Eamon to get rid of his negative influence prior to Ostagar makes infinately more sense.

Where is Costin, I assume he'll be happy about this.

He is probably putting up streamers and Ballons and baking a cake.
All for the Loghain is the best/Calian is the worst party.

I am bringing the punch! Posted Image

#1079
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages

Giggles_Manically wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Hey, I actually have more faith in Eamon than for him to want Cailan to marry CELENE. I mean, did you hear that line about poncy Orlesian noblemen? This stupidity was all Cailan's. And Celen's. But she, at least, was getting something out of it.

The whole issue is Cailan basically jumping off a cliff because of Eamon's encouragement. I'm not sure how he'd feel about Cailan marrying Celene, but I don't doubt he'd figure out a way for it to benefit him, considering he's married to an Orlesian himself.


Hence why Loghain's poisoning of Eamon to get rid of his negative influence prior to Ostagar makes infinately more sense.

Where is Costin, I assume he'll be happy about this.

He is probably putting up streamers and Ballons and baking a cake.
All for the Loghain is the best/Calian is the worst party.

I am bringing the punch! Posted Image

He's probably sleeping. It is 3 AM there after all.

#1080
Giggles_Manically

Giggles_Manically
  • Members
  • 13 708 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

Giggles_Manically wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Hey, I actually have more faith in Eamon than for him to want Cailan to marry CELENE. I mean, did you hear that line about poncy Orlesian noblemen? This stupidity was all Cailan's. And Celen's. But she, at least, was getting something out of it.

The whole issue is Cailan basically jumping off a cliff because of Eamon's encouragement. I'm not sure how he'd feel about Cailan marrying Celene, but I don't doubt he'd figure out a way for it to benefit him, considering he's married to an Orlesian himself.


Hence why Loghain's poisoning of Eamon to get rid of his negative influence prior to Ostagar makes infinately more sense.

Where is Costin, I assume he'll be happy about this.

He is probably putting up streamers and Ballons and baking a cake.
All for the Loghain is the best/Calian is the worst party.

I am bringing the punch! Posted Image

He's probably sleeping. It is 3 AM there after all.

Costin dosent sleep.
He plots.

#1081
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Hey, I actually have more faith in Eamon than for him to want Cailan to marry CELENE. I mean, did you hear that line about poncy Orlesian noblemen? This stupidity was all Cailan's. And Celen's. But she, at least, was getting something out of it.

The whole issue is Cailan basically jumping off a cliff because of Eamon's encouragement. I'm not sure how he'd feel about Cailan marrying Celene, but I don't doubt he'd figure out a way for it to benefit him, considering he's married to an Orlesian himself.


Hence why Loghain's poisoning of Eamon to get rid of his negative influence prior to Ostagar makes infinately more sense.

Where is Costin, I assume he'll be happy about this.

Dude (Is it acceptable to call your liege lord "dude"? Anyway.) No lie. Eamon needs to stay as far away from the throne as possible. Even more reason to put Anora on the throne or let Alistair marry her, if necessary.

#1082
DragonRacer13

DragonRacer13
  • Members
  • 519 messages

Giggles_Manically wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

Sarah1281 wrote...

Hey, I actually have more faith in Eamon than for him to want Cailan to marry CELENE. I mean, did you hear that line about poncy Orlesian noblemen? This stupidity was all Cailan's. And Celen's. But she, at least, was getting something out of it.

The whole issue is Cailan basically jumping off a cliff because of Eamon's encouragement. I'm not sure how he'd feel about Cailan marrying Celene, but I don't doubt he'd figure out a way for it to benefit him, considering he's married to an Orlesian himself.


Hence why Loghain's poisoning of Eamon to get rid of his negative influence prior to Ostagar makes infinately more sense.

Where is Costin, I assume he'll be happy about this.

He is probably putting up streamers and Ballons and baking a cake.
All for the Loghain is the best/Calian is the worst party.

I am bringing the punch! Posted Image


Then... the cake is not a lie this time?

Hooray!

And I'm spiking the punch! Posted Image

#1083
phaonica

phaonica
  • Members
  • 3 435 messages

Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.


editing for references: 

tuppence95 wrote...

 Gaider Q&A - http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/9386107

Talk about the CE's mother - 09:35
Templars using phylactories - 09:55
Seeing DAO characters - 11:00
Cailain - Anora - Loghain - 13:25
Anders - Alistair - 20:49

http://social.biowar...199/137#4683680

Modifié par phaonica, 06 septembre 2010 - 02:13 .


#1084
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

phaonica wrote...

Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.

I <3 Loghain.

#1085
DragonRacer13

DragonRacer13
  • Members
  • 519 messages

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.

I <3 Loghain.


I second that emotion. Posted Image

#1086
phaonica

phaonica
  • Members
  • 3 435 messages
I'm sure Celene was simply sensitive to Cailan's plight and was just trying to help... Posted Image

#1087
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

phaonica wrote...

I'm sure Celene was simply sensitive to Cailan's plight and was just trying to help... Posted Image

Of course, because everyone in line to the throne ahead of her died of natural causes.

#1088
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

I'm sure Celene was simply sensitive to Cailan's plight and was just trying to help... Posted Image

Of course, because everyone in line to the throne ahead of her died of natural causes.


The died because of her overwhelming altruism.

#1089
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

I'm sure Celene was simply sensitive to Cailan's plight and was just trying to help... Posted Image

Of course, because everyone in line to the throne ahead of her died of natural causes.


The died because of her overwhelming altruism.

"Need some help slicing that cabbage? Oh, I'm sorry, it appears I've accidentally slit your throat."

#1090
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
I can't believe people are actually asking what would be so bad about Orlais and Ferelden merging...

#1091
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

I can't believe people are actually asking what would be so bad about Orlais and Ferelden merging...


They should make Poli 101 mandatory.

#1092
Bann Duncan

Bann Duncan
  • Members
  • 1 390 messages

DragonRacer13 wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.

I <3 Loghain.


I second that emotion. Posted Image


Thirded. I wonder how the "Loghain is worsez than the darksponz" crowd will react to this, given that they've criticised all of us who called attention to that fact after RtO.

#1093
DragonRacer13

DragonRacer13
  • Members
  • 519 messages

Monica21 wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

I'm sure Celene was simply sensitive to Cailan's plight and was just trying to help... Posted Image

Of course, because everyone in line to the throne ahead of her died of natural causes.


The died because of her overwhelming altruism.

"Need some help slicing that cabbage? Oh, I'm sorry, it appears I've accidentally slit your throat."


Mmm, yes, and some folks in the Alistair thread think the political country merge would be a good thing or that the marriage wouldn't absorb Ferelden?

Hoo boy.

Isn't there some sort of quote out there about "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't still out to get you"? Seems appropriate given the circumstances...

#1094
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

DragonRacer13 wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

I'm sure Celene was simply sensitive to Cailan's plight and was just trying to help... Posted Image

Of course, because everyone in line to the throne ahead of her died of natural causes.


The died because of her overwhelming altruism.

"Need some help slicing that cabbage? Oh, I'm sorry, it appears I've accidentally slit your throat."


Mmm, yes, and some folks in the Alistair thread think the political country merge would be a good thing or that the marriage wouldn't absorb Ferelden?

Hoo boy.

Isn't there some sort of quote out there about "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't still out to get you"? Seems appropriate given the circumstances...

Yes, yes there is. And all this time I've been thinking that this was the one time Loghain's paranoia didn't serve him. Turns out I was wrong about that too. He was not only right all along, but he wasn't even paranoid because he knew he was right. He knew exactly what the marriage would mean.

#1095
DragonRacer13

DragonRacer13
  • Members
  • 519 messages

Bann Duncan wrote...

DragonRacer13 wrote...

Monica21 wrote...

phaonica wrote...

Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.

I <3 Loghain.


I second that emotion. Posted Image


Thirded. I wonder how the "Loghain is worsez than the darksponz" crowd will react to this, given that they've criticised all of us who called attention to that fact after RtO.


Like I mentioned earlier in the thread, they will most assuredly still find a way to spin all this against Loghain (because, you know, he's a monster and was responsible for the Grinch stealing Christmas from all the Whos down in Whoville and all other sins of the world...). They're probably busy thinking up "damage control" excuses.

Oh, well. It just leaves more of Loghain for us to all Posted Image.

#1096
TJPags

TJPags
  • Members
  • 5 694 messages

phaonica wrote...

Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.


editing for references: 

tuppence95 wrote...

 Gaider Q&A - http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/9386107

Talk about the CE's mother - 09:35
Templars using phylactories - 09:55
Seeing DAO characters - 11:00
Cailain - Anora - Loghain - 13:25
Anders - Alistair - 20:49

http://social.biowar...199/137#4683680



So, Loghain had reason to want Caillan dead, Gaider (the voice of God, remember?) uses a sarcastic tone to state that it did NOT influence Loghain's actions.

You all cry that this justifies his actions.  I think (and go ahead, flame away) this points to the fact that his plans for Caillans death were made in advance of the beacon lighting, making it premeditated.  It also sheds new light on why he wanted Eamon out of the way - he feared Eamon's influence would exceed his own (as it seems it did) more so with his daughter no longer the Queen.

You all also immediately assume Caillan was selling out Ferelden.  While he may have been, there are many ways marriage contracts can be made - certainly it's not inconceivable that such a marriage between Caillan and Celene would include a clause that keeps Orlais out of Ferelden.  And, since the Landsmeet must apparently approve every new monarch, clearly, Ferelden had a way to keep the half Orlesian son of Caillan off the throne.

Really, this puts it much more in the power grab light, to me.  And moreover, the WAY he did the power grab - allowing so many soldiers to die, rather than just executing Caillan - seems so much worse, to me.

Also, if this is the way it was - he found out BEFORE Ostagar - why did he seem so shocked and surprised ahen he sees the letters during RtO?  And why does he never mention this little nugget of information ONCE during the game?  Seems to me, a man doing whatever it takes to keep Ferelden strong would be PROUD of taking this action, especially given what to him is PLENTY of valid reason - and may even be valid reason to me.  Instead, he does it in such a way as to slaughter half the Ferelden army, comes up with a scapegoat to hide his actions, and never mentions his reasons.

This is better than the questions about it we had before?  Really?

#1097
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages

You all also immediately assume Caillan was selling out Ferelden. While he may have been, there are many ways marriage contracts can be made - certainly it's not inconceivable that such a marriage between Caillan and Celene would include a clause that keeps Orlais out of Ferelden. And, since the Landsmeet must apparently approve every new monarch, clearly, Ferelden had a way to keep the half Orlesian son of Caillan off the throne.

It won't matter if Ferelden has a King or not because it will be a puppet and the real ruler will be the half-Orlesian Emperor son of Cailan. And no, I don't think that Loghain knew this.

#1098
TJPags

TJPags
  • Members
  • 5 694 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...


You all also immediately assume Caillan was selling out Ferelden. While he may have been, there are many ways marriage contracts can be made - certainly it's not inconceivable that such a marriage between Caillan and Celene would include a clause that keeps Orlais out of Ferelden. And, since the Landsmeet must apparently approve every new monarch, clearly, Ferelden had a way to keep the half Orlesian son of Caillan off the throne.

It won't matter if Ferelden has a King or not because it will be a puppet and the real ruler will be the half-Orlesian Emperor son of Cailan. And no, I don't think that Loghain knew this.


What are the rules of succession in Orlais?  Do we know?  Is there already an Orlesian heir?  Could there not be 2 kids, one ruling each country?

And which part are you saying "I don't think Loghain knew this" about?

#1099
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

You all also immediately assume Caillan was selling out Ferelden. While he may have been, there are many ways marriage contracts can be made - certainly it's not inconceivable that such a marriage between Caillan and Celene would include a clause that keeps Orlais out of Ferelden. And, since the Landsmeet must apparently approve every new monarch, clearly, Ferelden had a way to keep the half Orlesian son of Caillan off the throne.

It won't matter if Ferelden has a King or not because it will be a puppet and the real ruler will be the half-Orlesian Emperor son of Cailan. And no, I don't think that Loghain knew this.

So, I thought I'd better come over here to eat crow.  :)

Hearing Gaider confirm that Cailan meant to divorce Anora and marry Celene makes me revise my opinion about him.  I don't think it's "traitorous," but I think it's stupid and would have backfired in a big way.  No way Ferelden was ready for a marriage alliance with Orlais.  I also feel sorry for Anora, which is a major feat.

Doesn't revise my opinion of Loghain any.  Treason is still treason, he still sold slaves and all the rest, he'll still die in all my games because I don't want to see him in my camp and couldn't enjoy my game if he didn't get his just like Howe.  But I'm sad to have lost a favorite character in Cailan.  Not that anyone here cares.  LOL

#1100
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages
Loghain was supposed to have known in the original version. In-game, he only knew at RtO. So no, he did not know before Ostagar. But his instincts of an Orelsian plot were correct.