phaonica wrote...
Question: Was Cailan really planning on leaving Anora for the Empress of Orlais, or was Loghain exaggerating?
DG: You know actually its funny, that was a plot that was originally in Origins, and we couldn't include it. The Empress of Orlais was supposed to have been visiting Denerim during the time of the Blight. We had a whole plot prepared for it, but that's the way development goes--things get cut all the time. So what you saw in Return to Ostagar was sort of a a callback to what was happening there. The plan was actually originally was, yes, that Cailan was planning to divorce Anora originally and Loghain discovered what was going on, (in an ominous/ironic/sarcastic kind of tone) but of course that's not why he did what he did--right?--Loghain being the completely reasonable man that he is.
editing for references: tuppence95 wrote...
Gaider Q&A - http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/9386107
Talk about the CE's mother - 09:35
Templars using phylactories - 09:55
Seeing DAO characters - 11:00
Cailain - Anora - Loghain - 13:25
Anders - Alistair - 20:49
http://social.biowar...199/137#4683680
So, Loghain had reason to want Caillan dead, Gaider (the voice of God, remember?) uses a sarcastic tone to state that it did NOT influence Loghain's actions.
You all cry that this justifies his actions. I think (and go ahead, flame away) this points to the fact that his plans for Caillans death were made in advance of the beacon lighting, making it premeditated. It also sheds new light on why he wanted Eamon out of the way - he feared Eamon's influence would exceed his own (as it seems it did) more so with his daughter no longer the Queen.
You all also immediately assume Caillan was selling out Ferelden. While he may have been, there are many ways marriage contracts can be made - certainly it's not inconceivable that such a marriage between Caillan and Celene would include a clause that keeps Orlais out of Ferelden. And, since the Landsmeet must apparently approve every new monarch, clearly, Ferelden had a way to keep the half Orlesian son of Caillan off the throne.
Really, this puts it much more in the power grab light, to me. And moreover, the WAY he did the power grab - allowing so many soldiers to die, rather than just executing Caillan - seems so much worse, to me.
Also, if this is the way it was - he found out BEFORE Ostagar - why did he seem so shocked and surprised ahen he sees the letters during RtO? And why does he never mention this little nugget of information ONCE during the game? Seems to me, a man doing whatever it takes to keep Ferelden strong would be PROUD of taking this action, especially given what to him is PLENTY of valid reason - and may even be valid reason to me. Instead, he does it in such a way as to slaughter half the Ferelden army, comes up with a scapegoat to hide his actions, and never mentions his reasons.
This is better than the questions about it we had before? Really?