[quote]Gandalf-the-Fabulous wrote...
[quote]AmstradHero wrote...
Being a Warrior or a Ranger or a Paladin made so much difference to me because... hrmm, I might get to use slightly different gear? Being a mage vs a specialist mage or a sorceror... these are the quibbles you're getting into? And what difference did picking your race have in BG2 aside from a slightly different character model and maybe a handful of conversations that had minor changes?
[/quote]
How about the strongholds and the quests asociated with them? Theives get to control a branch of the Shadow theives, Bards get their own theatre, fighters take control of a keep ect. But stats, gear and skills aside what effect did your class actually have on Origins other than a few extra lines of dialogue?
[/quote]
Origin story vs Stronghold. Let's call it a draw, shall we?
[quote]Gandalf-the-Fabulous wrote...
[quote]AmstradHero wrote...
I'm not going to replay a game in full just so my main character can use a different set of armour and a different sword. However, I will replay a game if I get to pick between sparing an entire order of mages or destroying them and get numerous other weighty decisions.
[/quote]
And how much weight exactly do these decisions have? I mean what effect did sideing with the elves have over siding with the werewolves other than different units at the final battle? You scream "BIG CHOICES" however you dont tell us what effect they actually have. ... you could pretty much experience everything in Origins with little to no consequence.[/quote]
With choices in BG2 I might experience a few different quests I might not otherwise get, but really, you can milk a really large percentage of BG2's content in a single playthrough.
[/quote]
You've proven in your previous posts that you don't care about game/world lore. I do. I get people referencing my actions in DAO a lot more than they do in BG2. But more importantly, I've had a massive effect on the game world at large. I can defile Andraste's ashes, I can bring back golem creation... and so on. For me,
that is roleplaying, because I've played a huge role in shaping the future of one or more nations within the game world. I'd consider that immersive... but I guess I must care more about the narrative and the fictional reality that are presented as part of a game.
It's funny, I always thought roleplaying was about the story, the characters and the game world. According to some "hardcore RPG fans", I'm wrong. Go figure.
Modifié par AmstradHero, 17 août 2010 - 06:01 .