Aller au contenu

Photo

Aveline Female Warrior: the Appreciation Thread!


4454 réponses à ce sujet

#2776
Nova-FoV

Nova-FoV
  • Members
  • 127 messages

Shiro_the_Gambler wrote...

Still having trouble coming to terms with this. I guess it just another reason to have low expectations even if it is Bioware. Aveline is going to be a Sten clone with a dash of Samara thrown in. Fenris is Morrigan with some Sten flavoring. Merrill is Alistair crossed with Leilana. Anders is probably going to be Wynne with a splash of Leilana. Varric, no doubt, is going to be a rehash of Bodahn with Zevran. Isabella is kind of tough, oh wait, no she isn't; easily Zevran with a dash of Morrigan.

Let's see for romances should be a little difficult, but I don't think so. Since Aveline is out; guess Isabella is going to fill Zevran's role. Merrill is going to fill Alistair's. Fenris is going to be Morrigan's mirror. Anders will probably take the role of Leilana. Until I'm proven wrong this is how I'm going to look at.


Look at it from their point of view. Of course they want to be original and try some new formulas, but at the same time, the end result has to be something that appeals to a wide array of people. What's the point in making a totally original video game if no one's interested in buying it? There are a lot of people here complaining about lack of originality, but I can guarantee if they did give us something wildly outside the box there would be even more complainers. The fact of the matter is it's a tried and tested formula that deep down inside most people don't want to stray from.

You should read The Hero with A Thousand Faces by Joseph Campbell. It has a very interesting stance on the formula of the heroic journey. It's not directly related to lack of originality in characters, but it does explain why people have a tendency to tell the same story over and over- and like it.

#2777
GameBoyish

GameBoyish
  • Members
  • 3 605 messages
I really wanted Aveline as an LI... oh well, let's see what happens after 10 years...

#2778
Uhh.. Jonah

Uhh.. Jonah
  • Members
  • 1 661 messages
As long as we can still flirt with her.. I'm good.

#2779
RunNeonTiger

RunNeonTiger
  • Members
  • 124 messages

Shiro_the_Gambler wrote...

Still having trouble coming to terms with this. I guess it just another reason to have low expectations even if it is Bioware. Aveline is going to be a Sten clone with a dash of Samara thrown in. Fenris is Morrigan with some Sten flavoring. Merrill is Alistair crossed with Leilana. Anders is probably going to be Wynne with a splash of Leilana. Varric, no doubt, is going to be a rehash of Bodahn with Zevran. Isabella is kind of tough, oh wait, no she isn't; easily Zevran with a dash of Morrigan.

Let's see for romances should be a little difficult, but I don't think so. Since Aveline is out; guess Isabella is going to fill Zevran's role. Merrill is going to fill Alistair's. Fenris is going to be Morrigan's mirror. Anders will probably take the role of Leilana. Until I'm proven wrong this is how I'm going to look at.


I just don't think I see how Aveline will be like Sten or Samara at all. Samara is the way she is because she's a justicar, and Sten, well, he's just one serious bro. I get the feeling that Aveline will be much warmer than them, at least after a while. I just fail to see it, and I don't understand how you do. 

It's also unfair to make those kind of comparisons without actually playing the game and getting to know the characters.

#2780
Shiro_the_Gambler

Shiro_the_Gambler
  • Members
  • 387 messages

Look at it from their point of view. Of course they want to be original
and try some new formulas, but at the same time, the end result has to
be something that appeals to a wide array of people. What's the point in
making a totally original video game if no one's interested in buying
it? There are a lot of people here complaining about lack of
originality, but I can guarantee if they did give us something wildly
outside the box there would be even more complainers. The fact of the
matter is it's a tried and tested formula that deep down inside most
people don't want to stray from.

You should read The Hero with
A Thousand Faces by Joseph Campbell. It has a very interesting stance on
the formula of the heroic journey. It's not directly related to lack of
originality in characters, but it does explain why people have a
tendency to tell the same story over and over- and like it.


I am familiar with the book.  I am one of those people who don't buy into the whole "Tropes are Bad" mentality.  Quite the contrary, tropes and archetypes when presented well are quite enjoyable.  Morrigan was a 'defrosting ice queen' that had a really beautiful romance subplot.  If this branch of Bioware keeps using the same tropes and archetypes though, I will call them on it.



RunNeonTiger wrote...

I just don't think I see how Aveline will be like Sten or Samara at all. Samara is the way she is because she's a justicar, and Sten, well, he's just one serious bro. I get the feeling that Aveline will be much warmer than them, at least after a while. I just fail to see it, and I don't understand how you do. 

It's also unfair to make those kind of comparisons without actually playing the game and getting to know the characters.


A bit unfair, yeah it is.  That is the lowest my expectations go though.  I'll try to sum this up quickly:

Aveline Vallen is a soldier, a master of sword and shield, and a
tireless guardian... to a point. The daughter of an exiled chevalier,
Aveline is not the knight her father wished her to be. Although fully
trained in chivalrous combat, she was raised in the shadow of a lost
life and will not lose another for the sake of honor. Protecting her
adopted home of Kirkwall becomes a chosen duty, not a privileged
calling. The people she stands for will not be wasted on lost causes or
protecting the foolish from themselves. Pride can be bandaged like any
other wound—when threats are dead and everyone is safely home.


This is the first piece of information we obtained about our stalwart warrior.  She has a strong code that she adheres to with almost fanatical zeal.  That is how I can make the comparison between Aveline and Sten or Samara.  It is just the baseline.  Sten and Samara are presented differently from each other, as will Aveline.  Go down far enough and there isn't much change.

Don't get me wrong.  I want to eat these words.  I want them crammed down my throat.  I'm just not going to expect it.

#2781
JediHealerCosmin

JediHealerCosmin
  • Members
  • 2 289 messages
Rooting characters into some kind of category is fairly common, however I don't really recommend comparing them with companions from other BioWare titles before we have first hand knowledge of their behavior/person (aka when we finally play it). 

They may surprise us in various ways, all of them having their light and dark sides. Sten was a prime example, I would have never guessed he was nuts about cookies :P   And can anyone on this forum honestly say that they expected Mordin to sing??

And you never know how something unexpected like this may, or may not turn up. The marketing strategy for the game may not have been the most... um, enlightening... but it doesn't have to be. The fact that we didn't get character trailers this time around pleased me. 

If there is one thing I've learned about BioWare trailers, is trust nothing.

#2782
otaku4ever

otaku4ever
  • Members
  • 436 messages

JediHealerCosmin wrote...

Rooting characters into some kind of category is fairly common, however I don't really recommend comparing them with companions from other BioWare titles before we have first hand knowledge of their behavior/person (aka when we finally play it). 

They may surprise us in various ways, all of them having their light and dark sides. Sten was a prime example, I would have never guessed he was nuts about cookies :P   And can anyone on this forum honestly say that they expected Mordin to sing??

And you never know how something unexpected like this may, or may not turn up. The marketing strategy for the game may not have been the most... um, enlightening... but it doesn't have to be. The fact that we didn't get character trailers this time around pleased me. 

If there is one thing I've learned about BioWare trailers, is trust DG and CP.

Fix'd

You mean Aveline will sing AND like cookies? :wub:
Rooting is bad. I still don't get how people compare Alistair and Anders...

#2783
TheRevanchist

TheRevanchist
  • Members
  • 3 647 messages
I find myself with not much else to say on this thread anymore...I'm still excited to see Aveline of course but now I'm too paranoid about wondering if she'll hook up with someone else to think about the good things I look forward to. I seriously feel like my GF just dumped me...I am honest to god in love with this pixelated woman....and that seriously bothers me.

#2784
Herr Uhl

Herr Uhl
  • Members
  • 13 465 messages

kylecouch wrote...

I find myself with not much else to say on this thread anymore...I'm still excited to see Aveline of course but now I'm too paranoid about wondering if she'll hook up with someone else to think about the good things I look forward to. I seriously feel like my GF just dumped me...I am honest to god in love with this pixelated woman....and that seriously bothers me.


And so it should. Especially since you've hardly been exposed to said pixelated woman.

#2785
TheRevanchist

TheRevanchist
  • Members
  • 3 647 messages

Herr Uhl wrote...

kylecouch wrote...

I find myself with not much else to say on this thread anymore...I'm still excited to see Aveline of course but now I'm too paranoid about wondering if she'll hook up with someone else to think about the good things I look forward to. I seriously feel like my GF just dumped me...I am honest to god in love with this pixelated woman....and that seriously bothers me.


And so it should. Especially since you've hardly been exposed to said pixelated woman.

Shush you...no one wants to hear your logical arguments! Posted Image

#2786
Risax

Risax
  • Members
  • 2 127 messages

RunNeonTiger wrote...

Shiro_the_Gambler wrote...

Still having trouble coming to terms with this. I guess it just another reason to have low expectations even if it is Bioware. Aveline is going to be a Sten clone with a dash of Samara thrown in. Fenris is Morrigan with some Sten flavoring. Merrill is Alistair crossed with Leilana. Anders is probably going to be Wynne with a splash of Leilana. Varric, no doubt, is going to be a rehash of Bodahn with Zevran. Isabella is kind of tough, oh wait, no she isn't; easily Zevran with a dash of Morrigan.

Let's see for romances should be a little difficult, but I don't think so. Since Aveline is out; guess Isabella is going to fill Zevran's role. Merrill is going to fill Alistair's. Fenris is going to be Morrigan's mirror. Anders will probably take the role of Leilana. Until I'm proven wrong this is how I'm going to look at.


I just don't think I see how Aveline will be like Sten or Samara at all. Samara is the way she is because she's a justicar, and Sten, well, he's just one serious bro. I get the feeling that Aveline will be much warmer than them, at least after a while. I just fail to see it, and I don't understand how you do. 

It's also unfair to make those kind of comparisons without actually playing the game and getting to know the characters.

It's mentioned in an interview with David Gaider that Aveline is his favorite character in DA 2 (or one of his favorites I can't remember). And that is because Aveline is a strong confident woman, but not in the traditional sense. Meaning that she isn't some Mary Sue, or has to act like a ****.

And I also think that she becomes something of a sister to Hawke, I mean they both lost someone they loved.

Modifié par Risax, 11 février 2011 - 02:22 .


#2787
JediHealerCosmin

JediHealerCosmin
  • Members
  • 2 289 messages
[quote]otaku4ever wrote...

 trust DG and CP.[/quote]

[/quote]

:blink: 

Oh dear, they've already gotten to you, haven't they mate? :alien:

#2788
blothulfur

blothulfur
  • Members
  • 2 015 messages
It will be nice to have a well written strong female character who's also likeable, too often especially in movies we have unpleasant women who in trying to appear strong just exude weakness and a nasty personality in their need to belittle men or dominate everyone around them in a way that if it were a man we would say he's a bully and an **** if we even bothered talking to him.

Tron legacy had a really appealing female lead who was quietly strong, funny and likeable and that's the kind of thing i'd be hoping for in Aveline though with a certain rougher edge as befits a warrior woman.

#2789
TheRevanchist

TheRevanchist
  • Members
  • 3 647 messages

blothulfur wrote...

It will be nice to have a well written strong female character who's also likeable, too often especially in movies we have unpleasant women who in trying to appear strong just exude weakness and a nasty personality in their need to belittle men or dominate everyone around them in a way that if it were a man we would say he's a bully and an **** if we even bothered talking to him.
Tron legacy had a really appealing female lead who was quietly strong, funny and likeable and that's the kind of thing i'd be hoping for in Aveline though with a certain rougher edge as befits a warrior woman.


Indeed the "tough woman" troupe too often comes off as far too b****y and just plain mean.

#2790
Maelora

Maelora
  • Members
  • 608 messages

Wynne wrote...
With all due respect, that is utter crap. Mike Laidlaw wouldn't say that there would be romance options for players of all genders and orientations if it wasn't true. He's too knowledgeable and too nice a guy to lie on such an epic scale.


Sorry, but no.  There will be a non-party-member same-gender LI.   Kelly Chambers v2 if you like.

No Paramour achievement, not even a kiss.

But Bioware can tell us honestly that there's s/s in the game.  You wait and see.

However, this is the Avenline Mourning Thread, so I'll say no more here. Posted Image

Again, sorry you didn't get what you wanted guys.

Modifié par Maelora, 11 février 2011 - 06:46 .


#2791
ReallyRue

ReallyRue
  • Members
  • 3 711 messages
I was a bit miffed about the whole Aveline not being a LI thing. But I wonder if something might happen like with Samara. As in, you can't technically romance her (for whatever reason) but there is still a *moment* where she's on the verge of confessing her feelings to you. That scene with Samara was so sad, but it's far better than not being able to romance her at all and was very in-character for Samara. So yeah, I hope for something like that with Aveline.

#2792
falconlord5

falconlord5
  • Members
  • 1 024 messages

Maelora wrote...

Wynne wrote...
With all due respect, that is utter crap. Mike Laidlaw wouldn't say that there would be romance options for players of all genders and orientations if it wasn't true. He's too knowledgeable and too nice a guy to lie on such an epic scale.


Sorry, but no.  There will be a non-party-member same-gender LI.   Kelly Chambers v2 if you like.

No Paramour achievement, not even a kiss.

But Bioware can tell us honestly that there's s/s in the game.  You wait and see.

However, this is the Avenline Mourning Thread, so I'll say no more here. Posted Image

Again, sorry you didn't get what you wanted guys.


You have evidence for this, yes? 'Cause we weren't promised s/s romances for ME2. Fact, they came right out and said that we weren't going to have any.

And proved themselves liars with Shadow Broker, but that's a different story altogether Posted Image

#2793
Kritanakom

Kritanakom
  • Members
  • 281 messages
How does one define an LI, anyway? I remember reading that some people don't consider ME2's Kelly Chambers to be a true LI although you do talk to her almost as often as other LIs and by the end the relationship can definitely be sexual in nature.



Maybe there simply isn't an achievement for Aveline simply because we don't get a cut-to-black cutscene with her, but an implied relationship may still exist?

#2794
JediHealerCosmin

JediHealerCosmin
  • Members
  • 2 289 messages
The chat was great. We didn't really get to hear Aveline, but at least we saw the girl in action. Her tanking skills are awesome btw. (Mr. Laidlaw played ok too :P


There is also something that needs to be said.
*gathers courage*

I... may have... you know... been wrong. About Isabela.
She wasn't... you know, how I imagined her. Letting the slaves go and all. Even Aveline bowed her head a little.
And I can't help but feel, Mr. Laidlaw showed that scene on purpose.


Well, it's good to get that out. I apologise, I was wrong...
Somebody give a hug already ;(

#2795
TheRevanchist

TheRevanchist
  • Members
  • 3 647 messages
That may be...but I still don't like her enough to make her my LI <_<

#2796
JediHealerCosmin

JediHealerCosmin
  • Members
  • 2 289 messages

kylecouch wrote...

That may be...but I still don't like her enough to make her my LI <_<


Me neither... at least not yet. We'll see how the other characters fair as well. 
I've learned a few things from this tho ;)

#2797
ReallyRue

ReallyRue
  • Members
  • 3 711 messages

JediHealerCosmin wrote...

The chat was great. We didn't really get to hear Aveline, but at least we saw the girl in action. Her tanking skills are awesome btw. (Mr. Laidlaw played ok too :P


There is also something that needs to be said.
*gathers courage*

I... may have... you know... been wrong. About Isabela.
She wasn't... you know, how I imagined her. Letting the slaves go and all. Even Aveline bowed her head a little.
And I can't help but feel, Mr. Laidlaw showed that scene on purpose.


Well, it's good to get that out. I apologise, I was wrong...
Somebody give a hug already ;(


Aww *hugs*

I have to admit, I'm glad to have seen Isabella, and what Laidlaw said about why she is is favourite character. She sounds more interesting and appealing than I first thought too. Still not going to be first choice LI... but she'll be one at some point, now.

#2798
Wynne

Wynne
  • Members
  • 1 612 messages

Shiro_the_Gambler wrote...

Still having trouble coming to terms with this. I guess it just another reason to have low expectations even if it is Bioware. Aveline is going to be a Sten clone with a dash of Samara thrown in. Fenris is Morrigan with some Sten flavoring. Merrill is Alistair crossed with Leilana. Anders is probably going to be Wynne with a splash of Leilana. Varric, no doubt, is going to be a rehash of Bodahn with Zevran. Isabella is kind of tough, oh wait, no she isn't; easily Zevran with a dash of Morrigan.

Aveline isn't as wise or as old as Samara, nor does she have a different cultural background. Fenris is NOT Morrigan ffs, he is "stoic", as his writer has said, and has been compared to Valen a bit. He has a dry, deadpan sense of humor that some people mistake for seriousness. Merrill is a freaking blood mage--she's not going to be all cutesiness regardless of her looks. Anders--WYNNE? WTF? No! Not in the least! Just because he's a spirit healer? Ridiculous nonsense. Wynne never had a spirit of vengeance, and Anders is as goofy as Alistair, albeit in a different way; there's a comparison I could understand.

Maybe it's good to lower your expectations after a blow like this, but that's going pretty far.

kylecouch wrote...

I find myself with not much else to say
on this thread anymore...I'm still excited to see Aveline of course but
now I'm too paranoid about wondering if she'll hook up with someone
else to think about the good things I look forward to. I seriously feel
like my GF just dumped me...I am honest to god in love with this
pixelated woman....and that seriously bothers me.

*hugs* Hey, there... it's okay. Believe it or not, there are real women who are pretty similar to Aveline--cops, detectives, soldiers, even SPCA workers... real-life guardians, tougher than the average girl and with a deep soul. I admire Aveline precisely because she reminds me of qualities I've seen in the real world. If I ever have a little girl, I've already basically decided to call her Aveline because that's the kind of female character I view as a good role model, from what I've seen so far. (Plus, it's a beautiful name in general.)

It may be that Aveline shares a lot of qualities with your ideal woman. Nothing wrong with that. As connected as you are to what you know of the character, you will be deeply drawn into the story. If you try to view the ache as a roleplaying tool, as a connection to your character, then that pain won't be quite as strong as it was before.

There's something beautiful about unrequited love despite how sad it is, and in the end it can lead to happiness one way or another. If you want to see Aveline happy, and you play the game with that in mind, then it can be really enriching.

I remember when Alistair dumped me and started up a relationship with alcoholism. I could've reloaded and tried for a different ending. But as much as it seared my heart, it made me feel like my little Brosca heroine was all the more badass for pushing aside her own pain to do what she knew was right. As much as it sucks to see your beloved walk away from you, even in a game, it can also be a very involving experience. How bittersweet to stab that archdemon with Loghain at my side--my love had become my foe, and my foe had become my man-at-arms. *suddenly feels like a dork* Anyway, it felt really cool despite how depressing it was in ways. It was a memorable playthrough.

Maelora wrote...

Sorry, but no.  There will be a non-party-member same-gender LI.   Kelly Chambers v2 if you like.

No Paramour achievement, not even a kiss.

But Bioware can tell us honestly that there's s/s in the game.  You wait and see.

That "Sorry, but no" of yours is shaped like a boomerang. Why? Because as many people have yet to get through their heads, the DA team=/=the ME team. The ME series never had a real lesbian or gay romance; they always skirted the issue by choosing an alien in the first place, while the DA series never did. Half the romance options in DAO were available to homosexuals--not so with ME1.

GayGamer.net has written evidence of this. Mike Laidlaw said, verbatim, "Not every follower is interested romantically in Hawke, though there are options for players of all genders and orientations." That's highly inclusive terminology--Mike is the very person who would be the most careful about his wordings as he is in front of the camera all the time, and he knows people will remember what he says.

And as David Gaider said about people who might be offended by S/S romances and don't want them included, "So long as romances of any kind are optional and need to be actively pursued by the player in order to be experienced, they simply don't have a leg to stand on. Advocating that nobody should be able to have content you don't intend to personally use is largely pointless--outside of a vague notion that such efforts should go towards other things, instead. Personally, it's not a lot of effort to include them. The resources we can devote to a minority of players isn't great, but I imagine to those players it's quite worth it... and I would hope that some folks could be sensitive enough to be happy for those players, at the very least out of the selfish notion that they may one day end up in the minority of some content issue and receive the same consideration if nothing else."

Have you heard the ME team give such detailed and open responses? Realize that this may be Bioware, but it's another team with another philosophy. There will be similarities, there will be comparisons, but not everything is the same because these are two different groups of people and two different game series.  

It does no harm to lower your expectations--but don't talk like you know these people. You don't, or you wouldn't think they'd retcon Isabela to be straight (or did you forget that DA, unlike ME, specifically chose a known bisexual character to star in their second game?) rather than just put forth the small amount of effort it takes to add a few gender checks and record a few extra lines.

But you're right, this thread is about Aveline. That settled, back to her and how awesome a character she is.

Modifié par Wynne, 11 février 2011 - 10:43 .


#2799
TheRevanchist

TheRevanchist
  • Members
  • 3 647 messages
Wynne...thank you for your kind words...you made my absolutly terrible week just a little bit better. You are far more consideret then most people I know. It is indeed true Aveline embodies the perfect woman for me as you said, which is why I took this revelation so hard to begin with. Because since I have been unable to find such a woman in reality...for a few months I thought "well at least I'll have it in the game." Looking back at my foolish posts I clearly over-reacted. But I honestly felt betrayed even if it was unfounded and foolish. I can freely admit to myself I'm pretty jelous when it comes to women I like. Which is why the thought of her shacking up with someone else at the end of the game makes my blood boil with contained rage. But like you said...if that happens...I should put that aside and try to be happy for her. After all some of the best love stories ever written were tragic.



So again...thank you...for being a bright spot in a very very dark week.

#2800
blothulfur

blothulfur
  • Members
  • 2 015 messages
Wynne is nicer than Wynne.