172 réponses à ce sujet

[CageTheChimera]

Hello my fellow DA lovers. I thought of a very good fist fight scenario this being 
Hawke Vs Commander Shepard now please tell me what you think
Cheers bru:ph34r: 

[Niarviel]

Hawke wins with epic magical arm ripping move.

[Rapidiul]

Yet another thread about the same thing.

[iTomes]

Hawke. Shepards a looser on legs, nothig without his big-nasty-machine gun. hawke doesn't need such things. he just looks at him with these red eyes and then ripps of shepards arms or something.

[Behindyounow]

I'd say Shep, because of the cybernetics.

[Enshaid]

Rapidiul wrote...

Yet another thread about the same thing.

That post is so ****ing win. I hereby grant you 2000 internets.

[Lord Gremlin]

Hawke. Cast a mighty spell and Shepard is finished.

[Annihilator27]

Rapidiul wrote...

Yet another thread about the same thing.

Damn, Allready?

[Saibh]

I don't know...how well do biotic barriers work against magic? Does biotics = magic?



Honestly, if Hawke doesn't have magic, Shepard wins. Also, is Shepard a sniper? Because Shepard wins. There's no beating sniper Shepard.



Also, superior technology.



I can't pick Hawke since I have no idea what he does, besides that one magic move he took forever using. I want to...but I can't.

[silentassassin264]

Infiltrator Shep at 1000 ft away+ widow+ assassin cloak=...never see me coming

[Dynamomark]

Luc0s wrote...

Shepard has already put a bullet between Hawke's eyes before Hawke can even charge up his magic or get close enough for melee-combat. It's really the most unfair fight ever. Hawke doesn't stand a chance.

Don't underestimate our little ninja rogues we're being promised in DA2

[L33TDAWG]

I think people misunderstand the concept of fist fight as the op was asking. I say Shepard if he has cybernetics, but Hawke if he doesn't.

[Behindyounow]

I thought TC said in a fist fight. So no magic, or weapons.

[Marzillius]

Shepard, duh. He has assault and sniper rifles. Hawke wouldn't see it coming.

[Saibh]

Behindyounow wrote...

I thought TC said in a fist fight. So no magic, or weapons.

Oh.

Well, no competition: Shepard. With the cybernetics, s/he can wield weapons only krogan or geth could use without their bones breaking. It makes more sense, at least, if Hawke is allowed to use magic.

[iTomes]

Saibh wrote...

Behindyounow wrote...

I thought TC said in a fist fight. So no magic, or weapons.

Oh.

Well, no competition: Shepard. With the cybernetics, s/he can wield weapons only krogan or geth could use without their bones breaking. It makes more sense, at least, if Hawke is allowed to use magic.

if Shepards allowed to use cybernetics hawkes allowed to use his magic to simply mutilate shepard. if no cybernetics and no magic is allowed hawke wins because of his experience advantage, for shepard usually doesn't fight melee without cybernetics and rarely goes melee at all.

[Saibh]

iTomes wrote...

Saibh wrote...

Behindyounow wrote...

I thought TC said in a fist fight. So no magic, or weapons.

Oh.

Well, no competition: Shepard. With the cybernetics, s/he can wield weapons only krogan or geth could use without their bones breaking. It makes more sense, at least, if Hawke is allowed to use magic.

if Shepards allowed to use cybernetics hawkes allowed to use his magic to simply mutilate shepard. if no cybernetics and no magic is allowed hawke wins because of his experience advantage, for shepard usually doesn't fight melee without cybernetics and rarely goes melee at all.

There is no "allowed". Shepard has them built inside his body. He couldn't take them out if he wanted to. Wheras Hawke can consciously use magic, it's not like Shepard can turn off his muscles.

Also, we do see Shepard occasionally marine SHEPARD PAWNCH SHEPARD KICK. As a trained marine, I'd think he'd know a thing or two about hand to hand. 

I've never seen Hawke fight melee. In DAO, melee consisted of taking swings at people about once every ten seconds.

[iTomes]

Saibh wrote...

iTomes wrote...

Saibh wrote...

Behindyounow wrote...

I thought TC said in a fist fight. So no magic, or weapons.

Oh.

Well, no competition: Shepard. With the cybernetics, s/he can wield weapons only krogan or geth could use without their bones breaking. It makes more sense, at least, if Hawke is allowed to use magic.

if Shepards allowed to use cybernetics hawkes allowed to use his magic to simply mutilate shepard. if no cybernetics and no magic is allowed hawke wins because of his experience advantage, for shepard usually doesn't fight melee without cybernetics and rarely goes melee at all.

There is no "allowed". Shepard has them built inside his body. He couldn't take them out if he wanted to. Wheras Hawke can consciously use magic, it's not like Shepard can turn off his muscles.

Also, we do see Shepard occasionally marine SHEPARD PAWNCH SHEPARD KICK. As a trained marine, I'd think he'd know a thing or two about hand to hand. 

I've never seen Hawke fight melee. In DAO, melee consisted of taking swings at people about once every ten seconds.

i assume shepard can "turn off" his muscles. you know, everything beyond kicking the crap out of things would be beyond his abbilitys. considering that love interests usually survive shepard he has to have the abbility to turn of the biotics. magic is also an essential part of hawke, other then shepard he was actually born with it, so he'll may use it during the fistfight.

if hawke and shepard now agree on not using magic or biotics hawke would propably still win for shepards not used to the way he'd have to fight now. he usually punches his enemys and becaus of his biotics they usually just fly away or something. without biotics shepards pretty much screwed for he doesn't really know what to do if hes actually blocked. and even if shepard would stand a chance hawke would just blind him using his almighty nutella or simply kill shepard using the might of his epic beard.

Modifié par iTomes, 21 août 2010 - 04:18 .

[Behindyounow]

iTomes wrote...

i assume shepard can "turn off" his muscles. you know, everything beyond kicking the crap out of things would be beyond his abbilitys. considering that love interests usually survive shepard he has to have the abbility to turn of the biotics. magic is also an essential part of hawke, other then shepard he was actually born with it, so he'll may use it during the fistfight.

if hawke and shepard now agree on not using magic or biotics hawke would propably still win for shepards not used to the way he'd have to fight now. he usually punches his enemys and becaus of his biotics they usually just fly away or something. without biotics shepards pretty much screwed for he doesn't really know what to do if hes actually blocked. and even if shepard would stand a chance hawke would just blind him using his almighty nutella or simply kill shepard using the might of his epic beard.

There's more to Shep's cybernetics than biotics. He had robotic joints or something added when he was revived.

Modifié par Behindyounow, 21 août 2010 - 04:23 .

[Warden457]

i think shepard would win.shepard has superior workout machines and he might know kung fu or something.and hes badass

[epoch_]

silentassassin264 wrote...

Infiltrator Shep at 1000 ft away+ widow+ assassin cloak=...never see me coming

that was my thought as well. lol...

[Pedro Costa]

Can we make vs topic a bannable offense? Pwettypwease?

[Dynamomark]

DarkLord_PT wrote...

Can we make vs topic a bannable offense? Pwettypwease?

Would be interesting to see how these boards would've fared if they were governed by communism.

[Aedan_Cousland]

Shepard, easily.

It's a bit like asking, who would win in a fight to the death? A Knight Templar or an SAS Operative? Melee Hawke would be bringing a blade to a gun fight. Even if Hawke is a mage he can't do any damage to Shepard. Before Hawke can get in range to cast his first spell he takes a well placed  round from a sniper rifle between the eyes. Game over, Hawke.

Modifié par Aedan_Cousland, 21 août 2010 - 04:45 .