79 réponses à ce sujet

[Fiery Phoenix]

PWENER wrote...

[img]http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:01ybjhznl9LC5M:http://img706.imageshack.us/img706/5315/nooneleftbehind.png&t=1[/img]

ALWAYS!!!

This is what I got on my first playthrough. And it was pure luck.

[JockBuster]

Zulu_DFA wrote...

Pinkflamingo22 wrote...

but do you agree for the sake of a good story some people have to die?

Yes.
My main and only playthrough to be imported in the "3" is quite close to Ecael's "worst playtrough".

Mine are also based on Ecael's guides:
Male, Sentinel, Earthborn Ruthless (but not stupid), no LI in ME1, saved Kaiden (one #4 with Liara just in case)
Very first play thru everyone survived (easiest actually, MUCH harder to kill select few, especially if they are loyal)
1) 3 Survivors: Grunt, Zaeed, Modrin, Joker, EDI & Dr. Chakwas, ALL others dead / Grunt pulled me into the ship
2) All survive EXCEPT: Miranda, Jacob Thane, Kasumi, Jack & Cerberus crew dead / Grunt pulled me into the ship
3) All survive EXCEPT: Miranda, Jacob Thane, Kasumi & Cerberus crew dead 
4) All survive EXCEPT: Miranda, Jacob Thane, Kasumi & Cerberus crew dead / ME1 LI with Liara
Cerberus crew NOT needed, EDI can run the entire ship but gives Joker "license to screw up," also much quieter
I don't let Grunt die any more than I kill Wrex or let Ashley murder him in ME1 on Virmire

Modifié par JockBuster, 24 août 2010 - 12:37 .

[Harley_Dude]

I have a couple where crew die and one where everyone is saved. I will start with a save where most everyone is dead as I don't believe all the crew members return in ME3. If they do return then I will have additional content to make subsequent playthroughs more interesting.

[Shwiggliness]

EVERYONE BABY



I think I lost some Normandy crew mates though, I don't know how, I didn't do any missions after the Abduction.

[Cheese Elemental]

Addendum: On my third import playthrough (Infiltrator, Colonist, Sole Survivor), Miranda, Jacob, Zaeed and the Normandy crew are all dead because this Shepard is bitter as hell and didn't forget Akuze.

[Mallissin]

My first play-through, since they described the vents as being hot I figured Thane would be a good pick. I didn't realize it would be the door decryption that would be the real issue.



So, Thane was my only loss in all play-throughs and I'll probably carry that one over first.

[CC-Tron]

Every one survives except Miranda, Jack, Samara, Kasumi, and Tali.

[Computer_God91]

Unfortunately, my first play through everyone survived and for anyone to die I had to purposely make mistakes and the wrong choices, which was pretty tough to do. However I surprised myself when my cannon shep and representation of myself who makes the choices I would if I were there (100% para with 30-40 rene) saved the base for the illusive man. I regret that choice but it'll make for an interesting ME3 because I'll have to carry around a choice I regret making. Ha, kinda like real life huh?

[Skybound2X]

I think someone else mentioned it earlier, but I also consider my 'canon' playthrough to be the first one that I completed, when I was keeping myself clear of game spoilers.

For me, the 'best story' is the one that evolved naturally, warts and all. Whether it was simply luck, or because I am just a tactical genius (survey is still out ;-P), my entire squad survived the first 'suicide mission.' Sadly, my crew wasn't so lucky. I lost Gardner, Gabby, Hawthorn, and Kelly. My CIC and mess hall are so quiet, and Donnelly is so sad :-(

I actually think having lost a chunk of the crew, but keeping her squad together, is more powerful for my Shep. It drives home the point that she can do everything right (as far as she can tell) and still lose people.

Modifié par Skybound2X, 24 août 2010 - 01:19 .

[Sturmwulfe]

They said it was a suicide mission, but no one really knew what was going to happen.



It just so happened I made good choices and got everyone home safely.



Because I did that without any walkthrough help, I'm keeping that as my male Shepard's canon play through.



My female Shepard is going to be a lot more ruthless and pro-Cerberus, so she'll probably have different results. I'll see if anyone actually dies off of that one.



I don't try to figure out the game's logic to make it do what I want. I make decisions that my characters probably would and see what goes from there, story be damned.

[Spartas Husky]

Mallissin wrote...

My first play-through, since they described the vents as being hot I figured Thane would be a good pick. I didn't realize it would be the door decryption that would be the real issue.

So, Thane was my only loss in all play-throughs and I'll probably carry that one over first.

.....doesn't Miranda says "we need a tech expert"???? I duno.... that seemed self explanatory . sry:wub:

[Big Yam]

Canon first playthrough: 

Everyone lives except for Legion.  I lost his loyalty and then sent him through the vents.

[VivaLaNES]

First Crack though? Femshep Paragon All Crew survived, all Squadmates survived.

I was pleased to say the least.

[Dave of Canada]

Everybody survived including crew. It was rather simple and I never understood how people lost companions.

Modifié par Dave of Canada, 24 août 2010 - 03:36 .

[Marxman2]

Pinkflamingo22 wrote...

My first time playing EVERYONE survived. It really wasn't hard at all.

However I decided that I wouldn't keep that file, simply because its not a good story for everyone to survive the "suicide mission". After all it's supposed to be the single most dangerous mission ever, even Garrus says deaths are guarenteed.

So I always kill Zaeed and let half my crew die, i feel this is better story telling, however I dometimes don't feel its enbough. My squad is still 11 people, and when you can only bring 3 with you, its seems a bit much.

Exactly how i feel when playing the Suicide mission.

For my very first playthrough, which is also my canon playthrough, only Mordin, Thane and Miranda died. Reasons were i failed Thanes side mission (Kinda got lost when tracking the guy, don't ask, just failed there lol) so he died while holding the line, and since i told Garrus to escort the crew, and taking Grunt and Miranda with me to fight the Reaper, Mordin died holding the line also. Miranda died because i told her to shut the **** up during her arguement with Jack. (Didn't have enough Paragon to make peace).

However, since then i can't seem to stop doing the "No one left behind" method, mainly because after getting Zaeed the suicide mission becomes much simpler. ( No, I didn't have any DLC for my first playthrough)

Overall im quite happy with my canon turnout though.

[earthbornFemShep]

In my first playthrough Legion and Samara died.  Both deaths were Samara's fault for not being a good enough leader.... which I guess is a reflection of Shep not being a good enough leader to pick a suitable 2nd in command.  Whoops.

My second playthrough all survived but Jack... she died in the final stand.  All others survived.

My other playthroughs I let all survive and then got bored and experimented on how I could do the mission epically wrong.  After having my ship ripped a new one three times (killing Jack, Tali, and Garrus), I killed Mordin in the shaft... then killed Grunt as a leader... then killed Samara as an escort... then Jack got carried away.... so I had Zaeed, Miranda, and Jacob left.  Zaeed, alone, held the door like a champ and survived even though he wasn't loyal.  Miranda and Jacob, both loyal, survived final assault.  (EDIT: You might notice that I did not recruit Thane, Kasumi, or activate Legion.  I did this on purpose to ensure a higher deathrate in the suicide mission.)

So, my favorite playthrough is Zaeed, Miranda, and Jacob because of the amazing amounts of epic fails. 

Modifié par earthbornFemShep, 24 août 2010 - 03:59 .

[Gibb_Garrus]

My canon playthrough has everyone survive. Shepard is supposed to be the best of the best leader wise, thats why TIM put so much effort into bringing him back. He is one of a kind, and only one of a kind can enter a "Suicide mission" and come out with everyone alive. Thats how i see my shep anyway.

[Snowship]

Main Paragon: All bar Thane & Miranda
Main Renegade: All bar Garrus

[RiouHotaru]

PWENER wrote...

[img]http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:01ybjhznl9LC5M:http://img706.imageshack.us/img706/5315/nooneleftbehind.png&t=1[/img]

ALWAYS!!!

AMEN.  I don't care about this whole "Good story means someone has to bite the bullet", I want everyone alive for ME3, and by god that's exactly what I'm gunna GET!

[Lisa_H]

I have always managed to keep everyone on the team alive, but the first time some of the crew died

[Dr. Peter Venkman]

Real save will include everything I did the first time around...everyone lived.

[Cypher0020]

main run....squad + crew lived.....cuz I feel more badass that way....



2nd run.... I got basic dlc... so I'll have everyone live, but I'm carrying over zaeed, firewalker, etc.....



I just can't purposely kill anyone off....

[Pinkflamingo22]

CC-Tron wrote...

Every one survives except Miranda, Jack, Samara, Kasumi, and Tali.

.... you killed ALL THE WOMEN?!?!?! Why?