Kaidan and Ashley in ME3 Wishlist
#551
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 01:41
So there you have it: Feature the Virmire Survivor in a significant way, bring the Alliance back into play in the Mass Effect universe, provide some true bridging material leading up to the announcement of ME3, and provide the perfect setting for both meaningful conversation/relationship continuation with Ashley/Kaidan and also for some kickass combat, all in one swoop.
#552
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 02:06
Modifié par Ashii6, 04 septembre 2010 - 02:06 .
#553
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 02:43
#554
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 03:31
What happened on Horizon was that Shepard was NOT allowed to explain fully HIS connection with Cerberus. Kaidan & Ashley only remember what happened in ME1 where Cerberus was THE enemy and still is to the Alliance & Council. Their reaction was not unexpected, but people seem to blame K&A for the whole scene. Listen to what K&A said in ME1 and the VERY beginning of ME2 during the attack. Pick the middle option and listen VERY carefully to the inflection of their replies to Shepard.Ashii6 wrote...
I am glad that we make a wishlist here, but I have a feeling that BioWare will simply ignore it. I'm not sure why... Maybe after that what happened on the Horizon. We knew that someday will be released a DLC with Liara, but we do not have a information about VS DLC so far. But I'll keep waiting for VS DLC as long as I'll have to.
Actually a VS DLC with bringing Kaidan or Ashley back to rejoin Shepard's squad would work out really nice. Sure, some don't want either to return = solution don't buy it! Nobody is forcing anyone to buy anything; that said, LotSB does appear to be integral to the story and is a "bridge DLC" to ME3.
Modifié par JockBuster, 04 septembre 2010 - 03:40 .
#555
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 03:38
JockBuster wrote...
Actually a VS DLC with bringing Kaidan or Ashley back to rejoin Shepard's squad would work out really nice. Sure, some don't want either to return = solution don't buy it! Nobody is forcing anyone to buy anything; that said, LotSB does appear to be integral to the story and is a "bridge DLC" to ME3.Ashii6 wrote...
I am glad that we make a wishlist here, but I have a feeling that BioWare will simply ignore it. I'm not sure why... Maybe after that what happened on the Horizon. We knew that someday will be released a DLC with Liara, but we do not have a information about VS DLC so far. But I'll keep waiting for VS DLC as long as I'll have to.
lotsb is more about the LI with the character you had from me1, now if bioware does indeed do something with kaidan and ashley my suggestion would be is the story could center around the decision you made on virmire and that sheps motives are even more question since his alliance with cerbrus, the goal could be in order to regain that members loyalty is to infiltrate the ((supposed)) illusive mans base and wipe it out and after the specific mission finished and pending if you romanced either of the 2 in game 1 they could be a LI
Modifié par Tazzmission, 04 septembre 2010 - 03:39 .
#556
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 04:37
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Ashii6 wrote...
I am glad that we make a wishlist here, but I have a feeling that BioWare will simply ignore it. I'm not sure why... Maybe after that what happened on the Horizon. We knew that someday will be released a DLC with Liara, but we do not have a information about VS DLC so far. But I'll keep waiting for VS DLC as long as I'll have to.
Well, to get your feelings more optimistic, here's a list of how fan requests might lead to DLC.
- it takes enough people to get support. Isn't that how Tali and Garrus got to be romance options?
- A lot of the things people didn't like in ME1 were eliminated because of fan criticism
- Ms. Norman asked for shirt ideas on her twitter account. I suggested some ideas of mine, and two of them are being made; I'm not suggesting she took only my shirt ideas, but obviously enough people asked for the same shirt ideas, and BW is making them. But it takes more than a couple requests to get something, I think.
- On the issue of shirts...they made one of Tali. I personally don't feel comfortable wearing character shirt faces, but obviously enough people like Tali to want to wear her on their clothing. Might have something to do with the fact that the Tali thread, before it got shut down, was 10,000 pages or so.
- From my understanding, a lot of the weapons and armor DLC caters to fan requests too.
- Moderators have made themselves known on the threads, and have made comments about certain issues. They haven't graced this thread yet, but hopefully that might change. So, they're definitely lurking around.
- Most importantly, fans are telling BW that we are willing to give money for Kaidan and Ashley to be a major NPC in DLC.
- The Kaidan Alenko Support Thread has 2217 or so pages by now. Ashley's support thread has 153. This thread has 23. There's obviously enough support for a DLC that BioWare can't ignore it
Storywise, it makes sense to have DLC featuring Ashley and Kaidan (POTENTIAL IN-GAME SPOILERS AHEAD):
- They were an important part of your crew in ME1
- Only one could make it out of Virmire--what ramifications does that have?
- PS3 users won't know who the heck they are, so BW might be making DLC to explain to new PS3 players in case they wonder "that crazy person yelling at me on Horizon," is.
- They were important enough to be sidelined so they could have a role in ME3--they can't be in ME3 if they die during the Suicide Mission.
- Ashley and Kaidan are high-ranking Alliance soldiers in ME2. They got promoted from ME1--doing what?
- Ashley or Kaidan work with the Alliance. Shepard works with Cerberus. The Alliance vs Cerberus issue is an important ME subplot--dare I say as important as the Shadow Broker's subplot? Obviously, DLC addressing this issue while involving A&K would be a logical choice.
- Ashley and Kaidan were a love interest.
- Liara's getting her chance. It's logical that Ashley and Kaidan should get theirs next.
- BioWare has stated bridging DLC will shape the storyline between ME2 and ME3. Ashley and Kaidan are important characters, even if they weren't all there in ME2. So, it's logical for their role to be reintroduced in DLC.
EDIT: I figured if there's more than a page page of people agreeing that Virmire would be an interesting area, it would be a good idea to add it on the list, so that's been updated.
Modifié par Brodyaha, 04 septembre 2010 - 02:07 .
#557
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 07:04
Modifié par Prince of Kemet, 04 septembre 2010 - 07:05 .
#558
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 01:28
JockBuster wrote...
What happened on Horizon was that Shepard was NOT allowed to explain fully HIS connection with Cerberus. Kaidan & Ashley only remember what happened in ME1 where Cerberus was THE enemy and still is to the Alliance & Council. Their reaction was not unexpected, but people seem to blame K&A for the whole scene
By the actions of Ash/Kai on the Horizon they wanted to push people to a new LI from ME2.
Besides, I never blamed Ash/Kai for their actions on the Horizon.
Relax, I know what they say.JockBuster wrote...
Listen to what K&A said in ME1 and the VERY beginning of ME2
during the attack. Pick the middle option and listen VERY carefully to
the inflection of their replies to Shepard
Modifié par Ashii6, 04 septembre 2010 - 01:54 .
#559
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 05:30
(Means that we actualy support VS DLC for ME2)
#560
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 05:31
KKs_45 wrote...
Ash, you know us. Got you covered.
(Means that we actualy support VS DLC for ME2)
Good boy, Legion!
I knew I can count on you.
#561
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 06:49
Guest_Brodyaha_*
we all have several requests for the DLC, but what would be your number one request for any Ashley and Kaidan DLC?
Here's mine: (HORIZON DESCRIPTION UP AHEAD)
I especially hope BioWare listen to our requests for different character development and dialogue. Hopefully I'm not beating a dead-horse by bringing up this topic.
I know it would be more effort on BioWare's part to create different characters, and maybe I'm judging A&K's character development too fast--but I have to go from what I've seen in ME2. Lately, I've been analyzing Kaidan and Ashley's reactions on Horizon. I've seen Ashley's reaction on Horizon on Youtube (I've only played through twice, and I saved Kaidan both times), but I've seen her email on the Mass Effect wikia. Both seem sad, and react the same, yet Ashley seems stronger from her email. Maybe it's just my preconceptions of her?
However, what got me thinking was that both Kaidan and Ashley use their guns to shoot at the Collector Swarms as it's heading in for the colony. Wouldn't it be more logical for Kaidan to have tried using his biotics, such as Barrier or Warp? Why shoot at a Collector swarm with a gun? Also, the near-identitcal dialogue is also sad-making.Both hug Shepard if they shared a romance; that's understandable.
IMO, Ashley sounds really mad; Kaidan sounds more broken than anything. Other than different voice inflection, to what extent could BioWare have changed the dialogue for that?
Anyways, I've been getting worried--part of me feel like they could potentially turn into the same character, placeholders for each other. It seems like there's attempts at character differentiation within the voicework and emails, but Horizon is a very little cameo...maybe it's not possible to analyze character personalities.
It also doesn't make sense to go through the trouble of creating two characters with different backgrounds, different talents, different personalities, and of course different voice actors, and then sideline that for ME2.
Having DLC that resolves the romances and ties into the main story is good too, but those can also be introduced in ME3. Having Shepard show emotion is nice too, but I can excuse Shepard's reaction as a personality quirk--seeing so much death has numbed him/her, or s/he's not good at showing emotion, etc.
....but I don't want to go into ME3 and see that Ashley and Kaidan are characters with the same dialogue. I wouldn't be able to make excuses for that. If they are the same character in DLC and ME3, it essentially tells me my choice on Virmire didn't matter, if that makes sense.
Anyways, hope this isn't just a stupid ramble.
But what's the one thing you most want to see in Ash and Kaid DLC?
Modifié par Brodyaha, 04 septembre 2010 - 07:24 .
#562
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 07:17
Modifié par siriusrambles, 04 septembre 2010 - 07:18 .
#563
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 07:36
Brodyaha wrote...
But what's the one thing you most want to see in Ash and Kaid DLC?
Character development - for both of them, respecting that Ashley and Kaidan have very different personalities.
Character development is one of the things I find overall lacking in ME2 and the reason why I did not like some new characters and some of the characters I knew from ME1 as much as before. I'd hate to see it happening to Ashley and Kaidan, too. They went through so much in the two years after Shepard's death and it should be shown: what they went through, how they got through it and what it has made them. They've both grown, they've been promoted.
Horizon and the following message was an indication but I'd very much like that indication to be explored.
#564
Posté 04 septembre 2010 - 09:06
Brodyaha wrote...
But what's the one thing you most want to see in Ash and Kaid DLC?
Character development, but not as in who they were in ME1, but what they've become over that time between meetings. Kaiden seems a beat-down and a little broken, a bit irrational. He reminds me of how Carth (and yes I realize he's a carth clone) had that dark-cloud of Telos follow him around over his head. Ash seems a bit more vulnerable to me, and as if she's trying to move on and be strong but can't quite, especially now that Shepard is back in the picture.
That being said, yes they definitely need different personalities in a possible DLC. They're completely different characters. Kaiden's very logical, passive, understanding, open-minded, and thinks about everything from multiple-perspectives. Ashley is fairly brazen, sympathetic, and actually seems to try to act conservatively with her attitude and feelings, and just tries to push things away.
#565
Posté 05 septembre 2010 - 02:40
Shortly said .. I support DLC contents and I definitely support this .. It would suck to play ME1 and right away the third one.
<_<
Modifié par Snowie79, 05 septembre 2010 - 02:44 .
#566
Posté 05 septembre 2010 - 04:18
It's not so much what they say, it's how they say it. First it is "Shepard..." very familiar and NOT Military protocol. And the inflection of Kaidan's voice (sorry I never save Ashley) and second (then "Commander...") sounding like he really did not want to abandon Shepard but finally is resigned to leave Shepard and the Normandy.Ashii6 wrote...
By the actions of Ash/Kai on the Horizon they wanted to push people to a new LI from ME2.JockBuster wrote...
What happened on Horizon was that Shepard was NOT allowed to explain fully HIS connection with Cerberus. Kaidan & Ashley only remember what happened in ME1 where Cerberus was THE enemy and still is to the Alliance & Council. Their reaction was not unexpected, but people seem to blame K&A for the whole scene
Besides, I never blamed Ash/Kai for their actions on the Horizon.Relax, I know what they say.JockBuster wrote...
Listen to what K&A said in ME1 and the VERY beginning of ME2
during the attack. Pick the middle option and listen VERY carefully to
the inflection of their replies to Shepard
I never blamed them either, actually with all that happened it is expected and the e-mail bears that out.
As to "By the actions of Ash/Kai on the Horizon they wanted to push people to a new LI from ME2." "That's just BW messing with our heads." Or seeing how many people stay loyal to their ME1 LI or willing to cheat on him/her.
Modifié par JockBuster, 05 septembre 2010 - 04:20 .
#567
Posté 05 septembre 2010 - 02:23
- i agree, character development. ash/kaidan went through a LOT in the intervening years, so much that upon a sudden meeting with their former commander/good friend or commander/best friend or commander/lover, they were willing to turn on their heel and walk away without waiting for a full explanation. okay, yes, shep does a "derp", but really, they walked AWAY - the person who had once been with you until the end of a mutiny and suicidal run to stop saren. something clearly changed with them - i can guess what it is, heck, i've written/read fanfic on what it was, but seriously, i'd like to see BW give us a hint of that in game.
- with the above, this is a story-driven shooter (what a concept!) and a character-driven story. two major characters disappeared into horizon of...Horizon. i want those characters back and to see them developed.
- second most want? repair relationships with ash/kaidan
- third most want: resolution with the alliance somehow - either telling them to F-off for those sheps who feel betrayed and hate them, telling them to move out of the way for those who feel neutral, or proving loyalty to them for the ones who want to go back. seriously, in ME1, the alliance either saved you from the streets, from mindoir, or is almost synonymous with your spacer family. i dunno about others, but i found it very hard to leave them.
#568
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Posté 05 septembre 2010 - 10:20
Guest_Brodyaha_*
sagequeen wrote...
with the above, this is a story-driven shooter (what a concept!) and a character-driven story. two major characters disappeared into horizon of...Horizon. i want those characters back and to see them developed.
.....can I quote that and put it in my signature? I think that's awesome.
I guess I should admit I'm envious of Liara fans. *SPOILERS*
She's an LI in ME1.
She risks her own life to save Shepard's corpse.
She becomes an information broker in two years, rivaling that of the SB.
She's getting her own DLC, which will allow those to continue the romance.
I know BioWare saved all of the LI's from ME1 so they wouldn't get killed for the Suicide Mission. But Liara has been developed into an important character. Aside from being saved for ME3, and being a LI there's been no word of development on Kaidan and Ashley's characters. Which is why I'm paranoid about the character development, and another reason I think we need some DLC to establish that connection for ME3. I know I should have faith, because BioWare has great stories and characters most of the time, but the more time goes by, the more paranoid I become. Even just some hint of what might be coming....that would be good enough to placate some fears for a while.
Modifié par Brodyaha, 05 septembre 2010 - 10:22 .
#569
Posté 05 septembre 2010 - 10:27
I have faith the VS is still important, but I, too, would LOVE some indication that this is so. I think it is harder, because the VS is two characters, not one, and one is gone, and they're same-sex only (mods aside, and for now, anyway), so it is harder to develop them post Virmire. But yes, I am with you on all that.
I just love the VS characters so much - both of them - and want them to return to a huge role in the ME saga.
Modifié par sagequeen, 05 septembre 2010 - 10:28 .
#570
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Posté 06 septembre 2010 - 03:20
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Here's a thread discussing Shepard's emotional development.
Put in your two cents!
Modifié par Brodyaha, 06 septembre 2010 - 03:23 .
#571
Posté 06 septembre 2010 - 10:11
sagequeen wrote...
most want?
- i agree, character development. ash/kaidan went through a LOT in the intervening years, so much that upon a sudden meeting with their former commander/good friend or commander/best friend or commander/lover, they were willing to turn on their heel and walk away without waiting for a full explanation. okay, yes, shep does a "derp", but really, they walked AWAY - the person who had once been with you until the end of a mutiny and suicidal run to stop saren. something clearly changed with them - i can guess what it is, heck, i've written/read fanfic on what it was, but seriously, i'd like to see BW give us a hint of that in game.
- with the above, this is a story-driven shooter (what a concept!) and a character-driven story. two major characters disappeared into horizon of...Horizon. i want those characters back and to see them developed.
- second most want? repair relationships with ash/kaidan
- third most want: resolution with the alliance somehow - either telling them to F-off for those sheps who feel betrayed and hate them, telling them to move out of the way for those who feel neutral, or proving loyalty to them for the ones who want to go back. seriously, in ME1, the alliance either saved you from the streets, from mindoir, or is almost synonymous with your spacer family. i dunno about others, but i found it very hard to leave them.
Very good points as always, sagequeen.
And yes, I agree. Even some hint from Bioware would be great.
#572
Posté 06 septembre 2010 - 04:36
#573
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Posté 06 septembre 2010 - 11:22
Guest_Brodyaha_*
Snowie79 wrote...
Both Ash and Kaidan were very poorly implemented to the ME2 .. you had Joker flying the ship .. Garrus and Tali on the team .. could repeatedly visit Liara and Wrex (not much of a thrill but at least something) .. but you only had one cutscene and letter from Ash/Kaidan, they were great moments and letters were nice but that's just not enough for a statement that romances will continue in ME2.
Shortly said .. I support DLC contents and I definitely support this .. It would suck to play ME1 and right away the third one.
<_<
I can understand the Horizon cutscene if Casey Hudson truly means that Kaidan and Ashley were saved to return in ME3. I feel Ashley and Kaidan reacted reasonably well.
I just wish...there had been with better dialogue I could've chosen for my Shepard.
And I wish that there wasn't so much secrecy. You're right, Snowie79, Shepard could visit recruit Tali and Garrus and visit Liara and Wrex. But after Horizon, Ash and Kaid disappear (hence sagequeen's quote in my sig).
Which is why fans are hoping for something special for Ashley and Kaidan. With character development, an awesome introduction, and hopefully they can save Shepard instead of the other way around.
#574
Posté 06 septembre 2010 - 11:40
No question if it comes out - only when.
Modifié par Angmir, 06 septembre 2010 - 11:41 .
#575
Posté 06 septembre 2010 - 11:43
Quaay wrote...
Kaidan needs a heroic cutscene where he shows off his biotic ability...in DLC and ME3 plz!
From what I had heard, they were supposed to be huge in ME3 (one of the "big decisions have big impacts" things) but I don't see why they can't throw us a bone and give us some bridging content... I'd take just about anything right now. ~sighs~
I do want to see a scene in ME3 however with Kaiden using his awesome biotic abilities. I remember this one elevator conversation from ME1 between Tali and Kaiden where Tali said how impressed she was by his abilties and he responded how he was never going to hold back on the biotics anymore. It always made me grin like a Chesire cat when I'd get to hear that conversation. Getting to see it action would be even better.




Ce sujet est fermé
Retour en haut




