Nightwriter wrote...
You shouldn't think of it like "one is right and one is wrong". There are numerous situations where BioWare intentionally leaves something open to interpretation. The fact that some people argue that the ME1 relationships are over and some argue they are not is proof of this - and those two answers are also mutually exclusive.
That said, it's not particularly out of character for Jacob.
That said, Jacob wouldn't throw in an insult after a meaningful look between him and Miranda. Doesn't fit the tone of the scene.
That said, there are numerous other occasions where Jacob expresses bitterness and hurt feelings about Miranda.
Shepard's ME1 romance is a bad example. Because that relationship involves Shepard, and Shepard has many faces, pun intended. So it is deliberate writing there to let some Shepard move on, and some stay faithful.
That said, I don't deny that at times it does look like the writer in charge, right in the middle of his creative flux, suddenly engaged the handbrakes and said to himself "Deadlines! Deadlines! Enough with this stuff, let's leave it as is - a mystery and food for fanfic."
That said, outside of Shepard's control in-game there is only one casuality, and only one possible sequence of events, which we here can deduce and discuss, in spite of the writers' indifference about the number of plot holes they keep cooking.
That said, I personally don't think there was a faulty party guilty of what happened to Jacob&Miranda relationship.
That said, I think it was Jacob who first said "Maybe we should take a break."
Modifié par Zulu_DFA, 15 octobre 2010 - 12:11 .