338 réponses à ce sujet

[SmokePants]

I don't like handing out 10's, but they earned it. I feel like I've stolen something, even though I paid full price. I'm going to have to go buy the Equilizer and appearance pack to help ease my conscience.

[Thalorin1919]

Shadow_broker wrote...

8/10
Some of meers dialgoue sounded horrible and ruined some great moments for me

Seriously?

Meer has made alot of progress on his voice acting from ME1 to now. He was alot better in ME2, and his voice acting in Overlord I thought was great. But here, I thought he really brought more personality and emotion to Shepard then ever before.

You're high.

[samusfan]

10/10.  Top marks for the gentle and thoughtful continuation to the Liara romance, if you had one and didn't cheat on her.  I thought for sure they would have cheaped out and gone with another "maybe next time, Shepard - I need to focus on the Shadow Broker's data", but I was very pleasantly surprised. 

A couple of Shepard's lines were hilarious!

Liara:  Sometimes you get lucky...
Shepard: That's the idea. 

Also, just thought I'd say that Hale's voice acting is top notch as always.

Bravo Bioware!

Modifié par samusfan, 08 septembre 2010 - 03:48 .

[atheelogos]

It gets a solid10 from me : )

[Sledge454]

I'll give it a solid 9 because I finally ran into an enemy vanguard who charged me. Awesome battle.

[Cheese Elemental]

Thalorin1919 wrote...

Shadow_broker wrote...

8/10
Some of meers dialgoue sounded horrible and ruined some great moments for me

Seriously?

Meer has made alot of progress on his voice acting from ME1 to now. He was alot better in ME2, and his voice acting in Overlord I thought was great. But here, I thought he really brought more personality and emotion to Shepard then ever before.

You're high.

Agreed. He's even better when he gets angry or sad, as evidenced by Overlord and LotSB respectively.

Modifié par Cheese Elemental, 08 septembre 2010 - 04:01 .

[TekFanX]

Mhhh...I'm a PC-User, so I'll give two ratings in order to stay fair:



3/10 for the delivery for PC-Users. It didn't work, but it got fixed within one day.



9.8/10 for the DLC, content and design. It would get the additional 0.2 for several manuals on how to use all these time-consoles.

Also a bit of more Squad-Voicing would be great(I liked that the SB hit on "Archangel"s bounty when facing him, but I'd like a one-liner from garrus in response(something from another mission or such things)).

[ArcanistLibram]

Cons:

- Still very little in terms of interaction with other party members.

- I'd have to run it again to get a better opinion on this, but it didn't really feel like it addressed Shepard's break up with Cerberus

- Tela Vasir dying. She was freakin' AWESOME and my paragon Shepard would have saved her on general principle. I hope we can work with another Spectre in ME3.



Pros:

- The pacing was great and the fights weren't so long that they slowed the game down.

- I liked the investigation elements, both here and in Kasumi's DLC.

- The boss fights were really exciting.

- Feron is the goddamn Batman.

- Liara becoming the Shadow Broker firmly cements Shepard's status as the most powerful faction in the galaxy.

- I was too excited about the Lair of the Shadow Broker to check everything out properly. I'm looking forward to seeing what else will come out of it.



Overall: 7.9/10



I like where the Mass Effect DLC is going and after Lair of the Shadowbroker, I'm committed to buying future releases, but Bioware, if you want to break from a "good" 7.9 to an exceptional 8, 9 or 10, you're going to have to give the squad members more important roles and start developing the story post-Suicide Mission.

[HBC Dresden]

I give my sympathies for PC users who got kinda screwed timing wise because I think this was one of the most satisfying pieces of DLC period (current generation, not including full-fledged expansions). So a 10.

Hey, I brought Tali when that building blew up, she said "Keelah." Gotta love recycled audio.

Favorites: cabin stuff (but I wish I could have the jellyfish at Liara's apartment), new gorgeous environments, the extra stuff at the intel center (dossiers, vids, etc.; a nice mix of tongue in cheek comedy and real/sad background info), and Femshep and Liara's banter during battle. And the best: all the little easter eggs and inside jokes only hardcore fans get.

I don't have a problem with squadmates not talking because it is a business thing, but I wish I could have told the Spectre I broke up with Cerberus. But a bunch of other audio did reference my actions, like the persuasion with the Spectre.

Modifié par HBC Dresden, 08 septembre 2010 - 04:35 .

[DigitalMaster37]

100/10

Heck yeah I am biased.



Seriously though, I loved it, everything was enjoyable to me and I got chills during all the conversation scenes with my love--Liara

[KainrycKarr]

10/10, hands down.

[JeanLuc761]

10/10, not even a question.



I'll be honest, this DLC made me a Liara fan. Everything about the storyline and gameplay was polished to a mirror shine in this one, and the new hub world is fantastic.



Seriously, Bioware, hats off to you.

[Thalorin1919]

One other thing I forgot to add, was how well Bioware did the relationship between Liara and Shepard.



Playing as a male, it was a nice change of pace romance wise. Shepard wasn't able to 'woo' Liara super easy like every other female character in Mass Effect. The three straight paragon interrupts and stuff like that, showed the tension between them at the beginning, and then the ending was just brilliant. With even mentioning getting married and children, which Liara obviously liked.

[ExtremeOne]

5 out of 10 . while the action and the mission was cool but i just think they muted the squad mates for no reason other than stupid Liara fan service.

[DigitalMaster37]

ExtremeOne wrote...

5 out of 10 . while the action and the mission was cool but i just think they muted the squad mates for no reason other than stupid Liara fan service.

Hehe, the next time you plan to "hate" try to be a little more descrete mmmkay?

[kraidy1117]

ExtremeOne wrote...

5 out of 10 . while the action and the mission was cool but i just think they muted the squad mates for no reason other than stupid Liara fan service.

Go troll somewhere else, go have a baby with Miranda Lawson, oh wait you can't!

[kraidy1117]

JeanLuc761 wrote...

10/10, not even a question.

I'll be honest, this DLC made me a Liara fan. Everything about the storyline and gameplay was polished to a mirror shine in this one, and the new hub world is fantastic.

Seriously, Bioware, hats off to you.

Really?

[DarthCaine]

I'm gonna say 4/5, 10 is a but too large a scale for me



I think this DLC just proves how much better and more emotional ME2 is

[ErichHartmann]

10/10



Best DLC period.

[guacamayus]

7/10



SB identity was a disappointment

[DarthCaine]

Squad mates don't have new VA 'cos it's too expensive to drag 13 VAs just for a few lines, since they'd have to pay them a full day's wage (even for one line)

[Nigawatts]

guacamayus wrote...

7/10

SB identity was a disappointment

Adding an entire new race to the setting isn't a disappointment.

[noobzor99]

9.5 out of 10. The one line from Kasumi was just not enough- other than that this was pretty awesome. My only problem is that the data to find the SB came from cerberus who I have officially given the finger to...

[Skyblade012]

Yeah, trying to rate this numerically is folly. I am not going to count that high.



Suffice to say, they have done an incredible job, and LotSB is now my favorite mission in the whole game.